Yesterday was just odd. No advertisement, I just happened to check the site. My Apple store in TN had all colors/sizes of ATT 5s at 5 pm. I cancelled my wife's online order for a 32 gb silver and ordered it for in store pickup. 30 minutes later, got the email it was ready and 5 minutes in the store, I was done. So random!!
Thats good you got that done. So the apple pick up option works at random times? I check my local store on apple.com and it shows "not eligible for pickup in store only".