Let's reimagine this situation as a non-tech thing so we can see how ludicrous that statement is, shall we? Let's couch that whole premise in beer... because hey, it's beer.
So, one day, Apple Brewing looked around and said, "Gah, everyone's drinking p**s beer. We can do better!" They went on to release a premium beer in a 12 oz. bottle. That was a smash hit. They then went on to prove that people also wanted a premium beer in a 32 oz. bottle--despite being derided by critics that it was "just a big 12 oz. bottle." And contrary to everyone's expectations, the 32 oz. bottles absolutely flew off the shelf at an astonishing rate.
Samsung Brewing comes along and, in a stroke of absolute genius, says, "Hey, maybe people who like 12 oz. bottles of beer and like 32 oz. bottles of beer, would also like 16 oz. bottles of beer." And what do you know? It's a hit!
Gee, who could have seen that coming?
Can you imagine anyone in the world of beer production actually bothering to bring this up as a win? It just sounds silly. Just like Samsung's "phablet" revelation. It was an idea already proven by Apple. Samsung just took the next logical step. It isn't something they deserve any kind of accolades for.
Analogy fail!