Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
If I wanted the Beatles I would have bought their CD(s) years ago. Where's the yawn smiley?

but its not all about you my friend. though i think apple sort of poked with its hyper stick at all the loyal fans with this announcement. yet it was a subtle announcement, only a day in advance.
 
Much ado about nothing. Personally, having grown up with the Beatles, my sister going to see them Live in LA and so on. I have become utterly sick of them over the years. They have been overplayed and oversold and have fallen into the category of elevator music. Besides, thought of another penny going to that whack job of Yoko Ono is repugnant to me after all her reticence over the the selling of the songs. So I have no idea why it should be an earth shacking event, it is in the same category of another tweet from Sara Palin.
 
Life is very short, and there's no time
For fussing and fighting, my friend.
I have always thought that it's a crime,
So I will ask you once again.

Try to see it my way,
Only time will tell if I am right or I am wrong.
While you see it your way
There's a chance that we may fall apart before too long.

We can work it out,
We can work it out.
 
So where's the accompanying video by Jonny and the Ivettes? Surely to goodness such a momentous announcement as this warrants one. Perhaps that oversight is why so many of us (myself included) have totally failed to grasp the import of today's...err..."event"?
 
There's great music in all eras (ok maybe not the 80s:D, my personal bias there) and in all styles. The Beatles were different to a large degree because of their unique place in the culture. They were both a catalyst of and simultaneously benefited from deep and profound changes in the culture. The amazing thing is how sophisticated and inspired their music was, to have also been in exactly the right place at the right time. They took a nascent form of music (rock and roll) and created entirely new forms out of it. Their influences were wide ranging. A great deal of it has to do with the fact that their producer was classically trained, introduced the young geniuses to a much wider palette, and contributed a great deal to the process that I think still goes uncredited (people may have this documented by now, haven't read up on it in years...). The result is still astonishing musically and lyrically after all these years.

If you don't know their music well, there's a lot you don't know.
 
Right, but that doesn't matter anymore. When your music is that old, just being the first to do it just doesn't mean the same thing. Their music isn't timeless. To me, that's why they're irrelevant now.

This has to be the funniest thing I've read today.
 
I know what you are saying- love the Doors too. I wouldn't call their music a downer, but dark might be the perfect word. It isn't all about love with cheerful lines and up-beat music. But man, Jim's words will have you thinking- sometimes about love, sometimes death, sometimes even our crappy jobs- "all our lives we sweat and save, building for a shallow grave."

Yeh, I'm going back to my dark description, I think i got it right the first time.
 
I think all the posts in this thread saying that nobody cares about the Beatles could be taken more seriously if there weren't almost 1300 posts discussing it.

Just sayin'.

I don't think it's the Beatles as much as it's the hype of "a day we won't forget" by Apple. There are probably a bazillion other things that Apple could have announced that would make November 16th, 2010 a memorable day. (For me, all I'll remember about today is that I accidentally sent my LG phone through the wash.)
 
Ok, not a huge rap fan here. But not all rap is garbage. And Eminem if you listen to it does have some clever rhymes. And there is some trash rap (I have no idea what the artists' names are cause I have only heard some teens playing it really loud and I don't go bother finding music I think is totally talentless hack that the only reason the kids listen to him is cause they can make himself sound tough) but don't paint all rap cause of some crap. Crap rap = the stuff where they are talking about their ho's, they have no rythm at all, they just talk in a low voice usually about their ho's and how tough they are and don't mess with them (but there is no talent in their rap, no cleverness in the words they choose, nothing of real interest at all). Now.. I'd like to see you rap like Eminem (I sure can't.. I'm horrible in that I try to sing along to anything I listen to and I completely fail whenever it comes to trying to rap, I can't keep up with it. Least when they are actually rapping and not just talking tough to a beat in the background. There's a difference).

There's a ton of crap popular music (hey, shoot, I listen to some of it but I wouldn't call it good. Shoot, I have one Kanye West song I listen to and I'll agree that he's definitely not all that good. Just I like the song he uses in the background and it works. But he's not clever, he doesn't really rap all that well and I'll admit his ego tends to turn me off of him even though really it hsould be about the music, not the singer). Should we paint Beatles as crap cause there's a lot of crappy popular stuff?

Just cause you don't like it doesn't mean you can't give credit where credit is due (and just cause you like it doesn't mean it's good either. I fully admit there's some music I listen to that I wouldn't consider good, just I like it *shrug*).

Even I'll admit there are some Rap songs I find catchy. I wouldn't put any of it anywhere near the musical genius of The Beatles though.
 
I don't think it's the Beatles as much as it's the hype of "a day we won't forget" by Apple.

If that's the case then mission accomplished for their marketing department. They got a ton of free press, they're already getting good sales, seems like they got exactly the result they hoped for.
 
I love the Beatles and they changed the world half a century ago. This is nothing people will never forget.
 
I was expecting a sweet feature or update of some kind, since they did put a big countdown on their MAIN page... But this? They're re-selling what has existed for many, many years and think it's an amazing ground-breaking announcement. The Beetles disc boxes have existed and been released in so many forms before i can't event count them.

Ridiculous imo... But if it makes some people happy then good
 
Its a generation thing. I am pushing 30 and I still listen to the 80's metal I grew on. Now my tastes have matured I listen to a lot of Pink Floyd and Led Zepplin now. I have tried to get into the Beatles but I can't do it. I like a few songs a lot but the ones I don't like I really don't like. The music hasn't aged as well as something like Black Dog or Money. Those songs still kick ass even today.

But don't you see that if there had been no Beatles there would have been no Pink Floyd and Led Zepplin as you know them? Even if you don't like the Beatles all that much, there is no denying that those artists were directly influenced by the Beatles. And not just musically but by the changed musical landscape the Beatles inspired.

I too grew up on 80's metal; that was my pop music. Do you not see the Beatles influence in even that music? For example, Motley Crue was heavily influenced by the Beatles. The most obvious is the remake of "Helter-Skelter", but what about "Slice of Your Pie" which ripped off a Beatles riff from "I Want You (She's So Heavy)." There are countless examples of that throughout pop history.

Even if you are sick of the Beatles or can't get into them or consider them totally irrelevant to your musical world, you can't deny that they are the most influential music group of all time.
 
The only people that will remember today are the surviving Beatles and the families of the deceased Beatles. The day Apple deposited a crap load of cash into their bank accounts.

Who gives a rat's a$$ about the frigging Beatles??? Overrated music from eons gone by. If it wasn't for their greed and over inflated egos, the music would have been sold in digital format years ago.

Apple lost a great deal of credibility today because of Steve and his longtime musical obsession with the Beatles. At least we don't have to hear Beatles rumors any longer. Bring on the Verizon iPhone I say, LOL!!

I imagine the delay in iOS 4.2 for Apple TV Gen 2 is because they are busy rewriting it from scratch instead of trying to fix all the bugs in it, and also to put in some of the missing feature and UI elements from Apple TV Gen 1. /S

-ITG
 
Again people are looking beyond the Beatles with this issue. The Beatles aren't the issue, its Apples lack of definitive direction the last few months. People where expecting this announcement to shed some light on decisions Apple has made lately.

Maybe you should stop caring so much about a megacorporation who just cares about making profit. Seriously. Apple's just another company that makes plastic crap and sells it to you at ridiculous markup. Stop caring so much, they don't care about you.


I wonder of there will be this much interest in the Lady Gaga Catalogue in 2050?

That bitch is going to be irrelevant in 2015, let alone 2050.


No it isn't because no one cares. They wanted a huge fanfare and all they got was bitching on internet messageboards like this. Don't get me wrong the hardcore Beatles fans who already have every song on every single format available will buy these and {heaven forbid} take 'Hey Jude' to number one on sunday. However if they think teenagers will suddenly stop listening to Lady Gaga and start buying up music that is forty years old, then you're mistaken.

You think teenagers are the only people in the world, or Apple's only target market? I have some news for you. The huge majority of people who are going to be buying these tracks aren't sitting here on MacRumors bitching about it. Nope, they're the regular people who don't know much about computers who just pop on to CNN and read the headline "Beatles now on iTunes". And then they'll go on and buy it.

It's hilarious that people on these forums think they are the only people in the world that Apple caters to. Guess what, you make up less than 1% of Apple's market.
 
Even I'll admit there are some Rap songs I find catchy. I wouldn't put any of it anywhere near the musical genius of The Beatles though.

Exactly. I like some Rap and Hip Hop, but will I still be listening to it 40+ years after it came out? I highly doubt it. Maybe it will be a cheesy joke like Disco at some point but no one will take it seriously in 2050. Something tells me that when they release the complete output of the Beatles in "Holographic Audio" or whatever the format of the day is, it will make a major splash, whereas the collected works of Snoop Doggy Dogg will probably be largely forgotten.
 
I'm amazed at all the whiney hypercritical comments in here today. I think some people need to relax a little.

For those who say that The Beatles are irrelevant to today's music, you really should re-think that. The Beatles continue to have an impact on modern music. For example, I remember several months back when the Rock Band Beatles game came out and there was some special on VH1 about it. They interviewed several musicians from bands in various genres (including James Hatfield - Metallica) who talked about how The Beatles were an influence on them and their music. I really don't think The Beatles will ever be irrelevant in the music world.
 
It seems of the 52 pages, at least 48 pages have no taste in good music. Cry more, little babies. The Beatles own you all.
 
But don't you see that if there had been no Beatles there would have been no Pink Floyd and Led Zepplin as you know them? Even if you don't like the Beatles all that much, there is no denying that those artists were directly influenced by the Beatles. And not just musically but by the changed musical landscape the Beatles inspired.

I too grew up on 80's metal; that was my pop music. Do you not see the Beatles influence in even that music? For example, Motley Crue was heavily influenced by the Beatles. The most obvious is the remake of "Helter-Skelter", but what about "Slice of Your Pie" which ripped off a Beatles riff from "I Want You (She's So Heavy)." There are countless examples of that throughout pop history.

Even if you are sick of the Beatles or can't get into them or consider them totally irrelevant to your musical world, you can't deny that they are the most influential music group of all time.

And without Chuck Berry and Little Richard etc we wouldn't have the Beatles yada yada yada. Saying we wouldn't have certain bands if it weren't for the Beatles is a pointless argument. That is until we discover parallel dimensions that didn't have the Beatles. ;) Music is an integral part of humanity that existed before the Beatles and would still exist without the Beatles.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.