You're right, I held off buying an iPhone 4, but have an iPhone and don't remember any kind of controversy like this or Consumer Reports not recommending it. The only problem with the original iPhone was the ATT networks in certain markets, and not my market I might add. I had great reception. From multiple tests I read, holding the iPhone 4 in a certain way drops a call and it's easy to repeat the problem.
Do you tell people, "Well, don't hold that way then"? LOL
And it's worse than other phones and Apple got caught fudging tests.
I find it hard to believe Consumer Reports is less credible that fanboys on MacRumors! HAHA!
And I hardly believe Consumer Reports has it in for Apple either like some of the conspiracy nuts here have suggested. They simply were easily able to reproduce the problem. It's that simple.
But like I said, arguing here is pointless, everyone's under Steve Jobs' infamous reality distortion field.
That said, I WILL be looking into the VERIZON iPhone and/or iPhone 5 since I love my iPhone.