Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Why would I want to use a payment system that only works at one store even if it is a large chain like Walmart?
I'd image that the idea behind it is more like a 'Store Card' rather than as a competitor to Apple Pay (bit of a sensationalist title to this article). Department Stores always had their own version of credit card, solely for use in their particular store, and have offered customer various incentives to use it. I see this as purely a more modern approach.

So to answer your question, all those that have owned this sort of 'Store Card' would no doubt be their target market.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MH01
Lots of people are getting upset over a paymemt "Option". I just use my debit card and shop where it suits me, not going to make a choice based on a payment method.
 
still dont get it, what is so awesome about apple pay? I am using nfc debit/credit cards for years, why should I tap phone instead of card near the reader? where is the benefit?

I guess it's the security, my biggest issue is that only some places take Apple Pay, while most take contactless , so you still end Up using your card , for most transactions , unless u change your lifestyle around shops that take Apple Pay....

And by security, this is what I mean http://www.theguardian.com/money/2015/jul/23/contactless-card-is-too-easy-says-which
 
16 pages so I'm late to the party but..

Do people who can afford iPhones even shop at Wal-Mart?

Seriously though, I'm by no means rich. I get by.. But I refuse to shop at Wal-Mart.
I used to live in a town where the only options were Walmart and Kmart. And oh boy, that Kmart was run down...
 
Elephant Restaurant and Bar was recently hacked in the US, so how is Walmart a greater risk? Target, Home Depot, etc. also had breaches......
It's a matter of trusting Google and Apple to keep your data safe, which are tech companies, or Walmart....
 
knowing what you buy is probably exactly what they want. I used the savings catcher on the walmart app, and next thing i know I'm getting emails asking me to rate my purchases. seriously! ask my cats how they like the frisks cat food and arm and hammer cat litter.
You are a human not an ape (are you?). You observe your animal and rate a damn product, cannot be that hard.

Or are you just trolling? If so, I'm sorry for the misunderstanding.
 
Everyone's thinking the exact same thing... "seriously?"

Agreed. In fact, how DARE any company try to compete with our beloved Apple on anything. I think we agree that whatever product or service that Apple creates, there should be a law preventing others from competing with them, and if they already have a product or service in that category ... abandon it immediately. Because, you know, like, Apple's solution has got to be the best, right?
 
Cash will always be the most welcomed option because 2% of it doesn't disappear off the top in transaction fees.

Do US retailers not have pay a similar transaction fee to deposit cash into a business account? They do in the UK.
 
But why..?

That's easy, because of Apple. They are the first to promote fragmentation on every level with "App for this and that" and now its biting them back. Flawed concept led by greed to make more money while demeaning user experience.

Now that they have seen what they have done they are trying to remedy that by obstructing third party apps by not allowing them to be default apps or to use some low level features but its little too late.
 
The difference is that with Apple Pay you do not use your real credit card number. When you register your card with Apple Pay it generates a virtual number that it is attached to your account and only works from your iPhone. Also if you were to lose your phone you do not have to cancel your card. You just use Find My iPhone to wipe the phone remotely or to unregister the cards and you're done. Even if the store's POS system gets compromised, your card information is useless to those who steal it.

And then you get home and hand out your credit card number in much less secure places like websites.
 
'Walmart Pay's QR code-based checkout process will involve opening the Walmart app, selecting Walmart Pay, activating the camera, scanning the code displayed at the register and waiting for the cashier to finish bagging your items'...


No thanks!
 
  • Like
Reactions: APlotdevice
I know that we are all blaming Walmart for this and that we will never shop there again (except for me) but isn't the ultimate failure in Apple's court? Ask yourselves why is Walmart doing this in the first place? Is Apple going about this in the wrong way? And it's not only Walmart? I haven't used Apple pay in over a month because it so inconsistent at the locations I shop at.
Why is taking my money so difficult now? I wouldn't even mind paying a small percentage fee (less than 0.1%) to the store just for the convenience of using it at way more places. Apple should not get a cut because your buying a phone from them in the first place. It's a selling point.
 
Seems like it would just make it hard on people who have no control over what payments their employer accepts.. I think simply using Apple Pay wherever its accepted would send a clearer message.

The employee doesn't suffer, they are paid regardless. The merchant however, will clearly see big ticket sales walk in direct response to not supporting Apple Pay. Simply going elsewhere is a passive way of sending the message, one the merchant may never understand.
 
I'm chuckling over all of the people here who are not going to shop at Walmart as a result of Walmart not going with Apple Pay... as if they would shop there in the first place.

I'd like to see this in action before drawing a conclusion. I currently use an app for all of my loyalty cards. It takes a few seconds to take my phone, open the app, select the store and show the cashier the barcode to scan it. If this Walmart solution to payment is similar, then it should work fine for the many people who DON'T own an iPhone 6 and beyond.
 
I'm chuckling over all of the people here who are not going to shop at Walmart as a result of Walmart not going with Apple Pay... as if they would shop there in the first place.

I'd like to see this in action before drawing a conclusion. I currently use an app for all of my loyalty cards. It takes a few seconds to take my phone, open the app, select the store and show the cashier the barcode to scan it. If this Walmart solution to payment is similar, then it should work fine for the many people who DON'T own an iPhone 6 and beyond.

Perhaps you should educate yourself a little more on NFC.
 
Or perhaps he's talking about the larger idea of paying with the phone.

You don't need an iPhone 6 or above to use mobile payments.

Most Android phones have NFC... Samsung's newest Phones have MST and NFC built into them, and of course you can use your Apple Watch for payments if you have an iPhone 5 or 5S, or above. The guy is acting like there's two phones out there that are capable of doing NFC payments, which isn't true.
 
You don't need an iPhone 6 or above to use mobile payments.

Most Android phones have NFC... Samsung's newest Phones have MST and NFC built into them, and of course you can use your Apple Watch for payments if you have an iPhone 5 or 5S, or above. The guy is acting like there's two phones out there that are capable of doing NFC payments, which isn't true.

I have an android phone without NFC that I got less than two years ago. Most budget phones don't have NFC and most iPhone users don't have an AW. That is the inherent benefit of the QR payment system a customer doesn't need to have a particular phone to use it. That doesn't however mean that they shouldn't support AP/GW
 
I have an android phone without NFC that I got less than two years ago. Most budget phones don't have NFC and most iPhone users don't have an AW. That is the inherent benefit of the QR payment system a customer doesn't need to have a particular phone to use it. That doesn't however mean that they shouldn't support AP/GW

Most people don't own a budget phone. Even a lot of the cheap phones have NFC... Did you check your settings? Are you 100% sure your phone doesn't have an NFC chip inside of it?
 
Most people don't own a budget phone. Even a lot of the cheap phones have NFC... Did you check your settings? Are you 100% sure your phone doesn't have an NFC chip inside of it?

I'm 100% sure.

If you look at the market share Android/iOS market share I you'll see that most people don't own high end phones if they did most of the of the Android OEM's would be rolling in dough but most are barely surviving. That will all change in the coming decade and NFC becomes common and cheap but right now only recent high end devices have NFC
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.