Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Giving this more thought and reading about @jbachandouris experience, if Apple permanently locked my me.com email of 18 years and I lost access to email as well as purchases, I would nuke all Apple stuff. Yeah, it would be short term self-inflicted pain, but I’d go Pop!_OS+Framework, Pixel+Graphene, change everything to my startmail.com email and deal with the loss of Messages. I already don’t use any social media except YouTube, MacRumors, and a couple Linux and retro gaming forums. Family and friends already begrudgingly forward photos and other stuff via text or email if they really want me to see something. So good news is I only see important stuff like birthdays and anniversaries and graduations these days, and not daily food/cat/fashion/random stuff. All this to say I would be sufficiently disgruntled to walk from Apple if they ever permanently locked my account and I would get on with my life without iCloud/Messages/FindMy. But for now, all is well! lol
It's a bit more than short term pain if other accounts you rely on use your iCloud email for access. If you can't access your iCloud email because Apple cut you off, how do you get the things you may need to access your other accounts that use that email address?

Fixing that is going to take a while.
 
My biggest gripe with Apple in recent years is all of the security overhead. I feel like I am constantly entering a password, confirming my identity, etc. Perhaps it's just as miserable on other platforms, but I've really grown tired of all this security theater in general, whether it's in the TSA line or on my Apple device. I'm also really tired of constant UI changes. Every major version gets tons of unnecessary marketing-driven UI tweaks. Today's Apple is totally undisciplined when it comes to UI/UX and it really shows.

I was a huge Apple fanboy for many decades, but I've lost my love for the company and would definitely switch if something better existed. More than anything, what keeps me in the Apple ecosystem are the Apple services like iCloud Photos and iCloud Music Library. I have a huge collection of audio files (ripped CDs, FLAC, etc) and Apple's Music app is the only app/service that integrates one's personal library with streaming. I love how seamlessly Music and Photos manage my music and photo libraries across all of my devices. I have yet to see apps/services on other platforms that work this well.

That said, I'm an Apple customer because of the Mac. I could easily switch to an Android phone and I wouldn't notice much difference, but the Mac is still the best desktop experience. Unfortunately, each version of macOS is more locked down than the previous one. The writing is clearly on the wall. I'm tired of all of the bugs. I'm tired of the constant UI changes that don't improve the user experience. But, despite how far Apple has fallen, it's still the best platform so I stay, for now.
 
Ternus is now the second CEO after Jobs so I expect things to get worse, not better. Schiller kind of retiring is a really bad thing for Apple’s soul. OS27 hasn’t much fixed my major gripes with their software (same janky ash UX) and my iPad is nowhere near any closer to a desktop experience than it was 10 years ago.
Totally agree. Ternus will stay the course and double down on everything about today's Apple. Cook built a cash machine and Ternus isn't going to rock the boat. The biggest problem with Apple's UI/UX work these days is that they've basically thrown out the human interface guidelines. They are completely and totally undisciplined in that area and have been for years now. It all started with (ridiculously overrated) Ive's redesign of iOS and has been a downward spiral ever since. I don't expect much to change under Ternus. I'm hopeful that he might take software quality more seriously, but I don't expect any major changes in how Apple operates or the kind of products it releases.
 
It's a bit more than short term pain if other accounts you rely on use your iCloud email for access. If you can't access your iCloud email because Apple cut you off, how do you get the things you may need to access your other accounts that use that email address?

Fixing that is going to take a while.
I probably wasn’t clear how I worded things. I meant if they did lock my account (this is the long-term pain) and I nuked all Apple stuff, the short term self-inflicted pain would be my voluntarily walking away from the things that still worked like Messages and Find My. My feeling is Apple would have already f’d me quite severely, my walking away would incur further inconveniences, but nothing as bad as the initial account lock. Hope this makes more sense in what I was trying to say the first time. 🙂
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
I probably wasn’t clear how I worded things. I meant if they did lock my account (this is the long-term pain) and I nuked all Apple stuff, the short term self-inflicted pain would be my voluntarily walking away from the things that still worked like Messages and Find My. My feeling is Apple would have already f’d me quite severely, my walking away would incur further inconveniences, but nothing as bad as the initial account lock. Hope this makes more sense in what I was trying to say the first time. 🙂
Yes, that makes it more clear thanks.

For me, I had never considered that Apple would lock my iCloud account. But, for other reasons (mentioned earlier), I've not used an iCloud email account for anything over the years. So, while this would largely be a huge inconvenience for me, it wouldn't be a showstopper.

But it does make you think just how much power one company has. And it's for that reason (among a few others), that I diversified my services a long time ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: conmee
Totally agree. Ternus will stay the course and double down on everything about today's Apple. Cook built a cash machine and Ternus isn't going to rock the boat. The biggest problem with Apple's UI/UX work these days is that they've basically thrown out the human interface guidelines. They are completely and totally undisciplined in that area and have been for years now. It all started with (ridiculously overrated) Ive's redesign of iOS and has been a downward spiral ever since. I don't expect much to change under Ternus. I'm hopeful that he might take software quality more seriously, but I don't expect any major changes in how Apple operates or the kind of products it releases.
And the fact Tim Apple isn’t going anywhere, he’s still going to be Chairman and can (or will) have a lot of influence on how the company is run. The Board in the past fired Steve (or persuaded him to leave), so ultimately the CEO answers to the Board. That said I think Tim will be a supportive Chairman and hopefully has the same trust and respect for Ternus that Steve had for Tim.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brother Cavil
And the fact Tim Apple isn’t going anywhere, he’s still going to be Chairman and can (or will) have a lot of influence on how the company is run. The Board in the past fired Steve (or persuaded him to leave), so ultimately the CEO answers to the Board. That said I think Tim will be a supportive Chairman and hopefully has the same trust and respect for Ternus that Steve had for Tim.
100%. The Board ultimately runs the show and if they're not happy with the CEO's performance, they'll fire him. Apple is a very mature company at this point. Untold millions of people are invested in Apple through their retirement accounts. Apple prints money, breaking records quarter after quarter. Ternus might prove to be a great CEO, but he certainly isn't going to make any major changes to how Apple operates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: conmee
Yes, that makes it more clear thanks.

For me, I had never considered that Apple would lock my iCloud account. But, for other reasons (mentioned earlier), I've not used an iCloud email account for anything over the years. So, while this would largely be a huge inconvenience for me, it wouldn't be a showstopper.

But it does make you think just how much power one company has. And it's for that reason (among a few others), that I diversified my services a long time ago.
I always used me.com email mainly because it was the shortest email domain (I also still have my live.com email from my Microsoft days). I also used it because I was concerned Proton or Startmail could go out of business randomly some day or they could encounter a country/legal issue that could impact the service, and I didn’t want to self-host because of laziness and the modest cost vs free. But… being reminded how easy it is for AI or mistakes or not so transparent policies to be seemingly arbitrarily enforced and cause significant disruption and inconvenience, I’m now reconsidering either using my Startmail email or even self-hosting. I also recall during the CSAM debates about some guy with a Google account trying to send pics of his baby/toddler to the doctor and he got flagged as having CSAM and lost access to all his Google stuff. I’m not sure if that was a hypothetical example or urban legend, but if true, it is nearly impossible to get a human to help resolve these kinds of issues.

This may be the year I start diversifying services rather than all eggs in one basket.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
I always used me.com email mainly because it was the shortest email domain (I also still have my live.com email from my Microsoft days). I also used it because I was concerned Proton or Startmail could go out of business randomly some day or they could encounter a country/legal issue that could impact the service, and I didn’t want to self-host because of laziness and the modest cost vs free. But… being reminded how easy it is for AI or mistakes or not so transparent policies to be seemingly arbitrarily enforced and cause significant disruption and inconvenience, I’m now reconsidering either using my Startmail email or even self-hosting. I also recall during the CSAM debates about some guy with a Google account trying to send pics of his baby/toddler to the doctor and he got flagged as having CSAM and lost access to all his Google stuff. I’m not sure if that was a hypothetical example or urban legend, but if true, it is nearly impossible to get a human to help resolve these kinds of issues.
There was a time where I had more email addresses than I have fingers. But slowly, over the years, as texting largely took the place of email, things have been whittled down to a small amount. I do have three Gmail addresses and three iCloud email addresses. But oddly enough, the Gmail addresses aren't used much either - just like my iCloud addresses.

My primary address was from my ISP, but my ISP abandoned handling email over a year ago and it turns out that the new provider is the same as the free email provider I've used for a very long time. So, over the past year, it's that old free email address I've largely used. They handle spam well, which I suppose is now primarily the reason I use them most. I don't believe they will disappear, they are too large for that, although not dominant in their slice of the industry.

This may be the year I start diversifying services rather than all eggs in one basket.
You may find yourself asking yourself at some point why you didn't do it earlier. While not every third party service is equivalent to what Apple offers, there are some that I find to be better or less complicated. And being cross-platform can be a major benefit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: conmee
I want to switch right now, and just haven't got around to it. Leasing an Iphone 18 pro might keep me in Apple for another year though.
Nice, funny thing is I genuinely think the leasing program is designed to trap people.

Cause when you think about it you might pay $750 for a $1099 17 pro over 2 years but then at the end Apple might ask for around $450 to own the phone at the end.

By then most people can’t justify that level of expense for a device that the novelty would have worn off over a year ago.

So they’re more likely to dive back in with an upgrade for an affordable monthly cost and a reset finance clock.

Get to the end, see the same buyout price which you might struggle to justify again.

Jump back in again, rinse and repeat.

Great in the short term, a trap in the long.
 
Nice, funny thing is I genuinely think the leasing program is designed to trap people.

Cause when you think about it you might pay $750 for a $1099 17 pro over 2 years but then at the end Apple might ask for around $450 to own the phone at the end.

By then most people can’t justify that level of expense for a device that the novelty would have worn off over a year ago.

So they’re more likely to dive back in with an upgrade for an affordable monthly cost and a reset finance clock.

Get to the end, see the same buyout price which you might struggle to justify again.

Jump back in again, rinse and repeat.

Great in the short term, a trap in the long.
That is something that I have been thinking over. I wouldn't be leasing the phone and then paying to own it, I would merely be leasing, then returning it, then leasing again.

However I am thinking of alternatives, as I am having doubts.
 
The price hikes are slowly making me reconsider my future with Apple. Not just the ram and storage as every company is doing it - but the other subtle hikes. I’ll be priced out sooner than later.
 
Honestly, Apple have left the users during Cook - stupid company - think they can survive with only stockholders.
See if Ternus will change Apple?
 
That is something that I have been thinking over. I wouldn't be leasing the phone and then paying to own it, I would merely be leasing, then returning it, then leasing again.

However I am thinking of alternatives, as I am having doubts.
In short, there's no good deal. The only way to make an iPhone more affordable is to keep it longer. Buy it outright and take advantage of someone's financing deal to pay over time. It's the same phone whether you buy it from Apple, Best Buy, or Walmart. So go with whoever gives you the best 0% financing terms. And once you've paid it off, keep it. I keep my iPhones for 4 years usually. I'm on a 15 Pro Max now and, other than having a new shiny bauble, I don't really see any reason to upgrade. It's all just incremental upgrades year after year at this point. The days of major advances between models are long gone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ClaraStahlbaum
TL;DR: Apple Maps ads triggered me, a step away from what I liked most about them, no ads and privacy, so time to explore alternatives.

I have been happily living in the "walled garden" for many years, deeply invested in the ecosystem with icloud photos, files and backups, etc. I have been happy to pay extra for Apple devices just because things work so well.

But recently a few of Apple's decisions have are making me second-guess if I should explore alternatives, for example adding ads to the App Store and Maps. Also, whenever I use my Linux computers, the friction of trying to use Apple services from those is very high, sometimes totally impractical (photos from the iCloud web interface kinda suck) or impossible (no AirDrop in Linux).

I am currently testing a few things: using Immich for personal/local cloud photos, got an old cheap pixel phone to try out "degoogling" it as much as I can, using Proton services for calendar+mail+cloud files, KDE Connect and LocalSend for sending files between devices, even testing Asahi linux on one of my macs (those guys are wizards!). The experience so far varies from "OK" to "janky", but usable, and at least I have control moving forward.

So where do you draw the line? What would make you switch?
Honestly I don’t think I’d ever leave.

1. I’m used to using iOS, Mac OS and iPad OS.

2. A flagship android is normally the same price (on launch) as a flagship iPhone.

3. If I didn’t want a flagship, Apple still offer more budget options now like the e series or last years flagship.

4. To best of my knowledge despite the ads being implemented within the App Store and maps.

Their commitment to privacy is still the best.

5. I like to set up my new phone without uninstalling bloatware as part of the process.

I know I am openly admitting to falling for all of their traps to keep us in the eco system and some how I’m fine with that. 😂
 
My current primary Mac is a 2009 Mac Pro running Sonoma (via OCLP). I've been fully Intel since May 2020, so a little over six years. I was PowerPC from 2001 to 2020.

So, if Apple does cause a reconsideration at some point, I still have some time. Once the M-series Macs start to drop into my price range (around $250), I may consider upgrading.

My primary iPhone is my 11 Pro Max. No 5G. But it runs iOS 27.

Both my Mac and my iPhone (and my iPads for that matter) do everything I need/want them to do. With my stuff, AI is largely a non-issue.

When you run 5 to 17 years behind, most of the Apple products that are going to die have already died, leaving most of the good ones (and parts) available.
That’s fair although finding an M series Mac at $250 is most likely never going to happen.

Although not an M chip in terms of specs the A18 pro Neo which is the same foundational architecture as the M chips.

That used to start at $599 and that was a miracle.

But thanks to Ramogedon that didn’t last long. 😂
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
That is something that I have been thinking over. I wouldn't be leasing the phone and then paying to own it, I would merely be leasing, then returning it, then leasing again.

However I am thinking of alternatives, as I am having doubts.
The other aspect of how much a phone ultimately costs is the service one uses. I was tired of paying nearly $100/month for my phone service and decided to try Visible. The first six months were a bit rocky, but I've now had it for three years and it's been great. I pay $32/month vs. $100.
 
Yeah, I hear you. And I agree. I'm hoping it's a one-off and it either stays there or goes away. Fortunately, I don't use Apple Maps anyway, so I can avoid that.

But if Apple becomes the new Amazon in that regard I'm certainly with you.
That’s a fair point.

If all of apple’s OS’s turned into windows tomorrow in the sense of mining your devices for data and forcing adds on you all the time then I’d be out too.

I love Apple and although I’m a skeptic of Apple Tax (depending on the product) I would say that I’m happy to pay that tax if it means superior privacy and the least amount of ads and bloat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
That’s fair although finding an M series Mac at $250 is most likely never going to happen.

Although not an M chip in terms of specs the A18 pro Neo which is the same foundational architecture as the M chips.

That used to start at $599 and that was a miracle.

But thanks to Ramogedon that didn’t last long. 😂
Oh, I wasn't talking new. And I wasn't talking like in a year or so.

eBay is great for old, used Macs. That's where I got my 2009 Mac Pro for $250 in 2020. But, eBay isn't everything either. I own five 30" Apple Cinema Displays that are all attached to this Mac Pro. Three of those displays were free, a MacRumors member gave them to me a year and a half ago. One was a $100 local purchase and the other was the only one that cost me more than $200.

In say, about 10 years, an M1 something is going to be at my price or less. And somebody, somewhere will have figured out how to run a newer version of MacOS on it. Just like they did with OCLP for Intel Macs.

It's just time. And my lack of money means I wait.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TVreporter
The other aspect of how much a phone ultimately costs is the service one uses. I was tired of paying nearly $100/month for my phone service and decided to try Visible. The first six months were a bit rocky, but I've now had it for three years and it's been great. I pay $32/month vs. $100.
I buy my phones outright and unlocked from Apple. On a 3 to 4 year refresh. I do this so I can change carriers at will and not enter carrier contracts. I went from paying $145 or so per month for two lines with Verizon to $46/mo with US Mobile in 2020 (plan is unlimited talk/text/high speed data and 50GB tethering - and more tethering data and international data are dirt cheap). US Mobile lets me switch to which network I want whenever I want to and they offer AT&T, Tmo, and Verizon networks. I currently use Verizon’s network but when I visit Seattle colleagues, I switch to Tmo as it seems to work better downtown. There may be use cases for people to use/pay for AT&T, Tmo, or Verizon, but I’ll never use them again as the service I get with an NVMO has been just as good at least in my case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brother Cavil
Oh, I wasn't talking new. And I wasn't talking like in a year or so.

eBay is great for old, used Macs. That's where I got my 2009 Mac Pro for $250 in 2020. But, eBay isn't everything either. I own five 30" Apple Cinema Displays that are all attached to this Mac Pro. Three of those displays were free, a MacRumors member gave them to me a year and a half ago. One was a $100 local purchase and the other was the only one that cost me more than $200.

In say, about 10 years, an M1 something is going to be at my price or less. And somebody, somewhere will have figured out how to run a newer version of MacOS on it. Just like they did with OCLP for Intel Macs.

It's just time. And my lack of money means I wait.
Ah, that makes more sense.

The M1 Airs are still solid machines and eventually they should get to that price while still being capable.

I actually think Apple made a mistake by making the M1 too good over the intel versions that now casual users or more likely to keep their machines for longer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
To be fair, removing apps from the app store doesn’t “weakened security/encryption and/or provided a back door for government or anyone else”, which is what the OP was worried about.

Not all “caving in to the government” are equal. Living in a world of black and white is silly and counterproductive.
Governments don't always needs to provide backdoors or need to weaken phone privacy to get people's data. Much of the time its just about controlling what apps they use and removing privacy tools that might help them. Having a 'secure app' doesn't mean much when it can be taken away from you and you can't download the same app elsewhere like you can with andriod.
 
I believe RCS has solved all those issues. But iMessage is superior anyway.
It hasn’t because, for one, RCS only rolled out to some very new versions of iOS, so any family member on older iOS is stuck. Next, I’m still prettty sure rcs still breaks group iMessages. It is absolutely deplorable that companies were allowed to build proprietary messaging on top of the default app, it creates both interoperability issues and ecosystem lock in issues.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.