Sorry for the long post, weekend catch up.
Oh man!
Fear killing much? That is really brutal!
RIP, mscriv. Please help yourself to some baked goods in the zombie lair.
Would anyone mind explaining why so much faith is going into KMMs vote? I went back and look and no where does it he say that he scanned Rodimus Prime and thus has reason to suspect RP.
I'm just curious if I missed something huge...
There are only so many people a seer can scan. When your scan hits a villager you have to take a guess, just like everyone else.
And I wouldn't say "faith" but I think constantly distrusting everyone may not always be the best strategy. King Mook Mook put a huge target on his back revealing himself so early but because it's SO obvious I would have though the wolves wouldn't infect him... at least not yet. He's probably been protected by the WW hunter up until this point. Now my trust in his word will steadily decrease. Especially as I think we lost our hunter by that recent narrative.
I think automatically suspecting the Seer after they reveal themselves is a bad move for the village. That Seer is sometimes the best chance the village has. As I've said, maybe I'm biased for having been a Seer that died trying to help out the village but I consider the role to be a stronger positive than a negative.
If I am ever the seer again and if I've revealed myself and subsequently became infected, I'd like it to be clearly known that I would not help the wolves but I probably wouldn't name them either. (so really, wolves, it would be a wasted infection.) I'd simply tell the village that I've been infected and let them lynch me. It may sound silly but I think the Seer is a
special special role and I don't think it should be defiled and abused. That is precisely what a baddie would want, for us to distrust our best chance, and I urge the rest of you to look at it in a similar way and perhaps agree the same thing.
it was more a timing question: can he declare the result of the scan as soon as he is notified it, or should he wait till the narrative morning comes? tp some extent it's obvious he should wait, but since other people can freely 'talk' during the game "night", why shouldn't the seer? (unless of course te result are notified at the last moment by ravenvii, just before morning announcements, in which case the whole point is moot).
...
(OK, more "When I was a Seer" talk...)
In a previous simple game my last scan was on a wolf and that same wolf had sent a PM to kill me. I was told of this result before my official death post but I was instructed NOT to reveal my result. It was torture! So I don't think KMM can post his scan results if he's also been killed on that same night. (unless ravenvii handles his games differently than chrjenkins does.)
I don't think that the seer or anyone else should be allowed to talk at night, as they should be sleeping.
I think that there should be allowed one post during the night to discuss the lynching, and then people are "asleep"
I disagree. This is a forum game and people can and should be able to speak when they like. (with the exception of being dead or as my post above states.)
For now I am going to trust what KMM has said and not vote for willbro or abijnk, who is probably the last shot the village has.
Rodimus Prime gives me an uneasy feeling though so that is where I'll place my vote.
