Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Wait, why would the attack fail? If he's the WW what's the point of the insta kill. I know in previous games Ravenvii posted a hunter insta kill on a ww. Maybe he is the ww hunter?

The rules have changed since last game. The vampire hunter cannot kill werewolves, only vampires.
The vampire hunter can kill the werewolf hunter in the first shot( or at least that's what I gain from the rules).
 
The rules have changed since last game. The vampire hunter cannot kill werewolves, only vampires.
The vampire hunter can kill the werewolf hunter in the first shot( or at least that's what I gain from the rules).

That makes sense. Thanks!
Well then....get 'em!!!
 
If of course, we can trust abbie.:p;)

I am sure we can.
having voted to send her to the gallows in the last two days, i consider myself rather unbiased on this point, and i would certainly follow her lead here.
there are way too many villagers left for this to be a sound strategic move if she is a ww, as she knows she would be next if philbeeney would turns out to be a regular joe.

besides, I think that the failed attempt will probably be in some way mentioned by ravenvii narrative, which would come as an ulterior confirmation of her word.
 
I've been mulling over the philbeeney shot for a couple of days. I was sure he was something, but not sure what. So, when it came right down to it, I figured it was my best shot either way.
 
philbeeney is a werewolf. I tried the insta-kill on him and it failed. I'm guessing I will get eaten tonight for posting this, but you all know who to take down next.

EDIT: and about 2 seconds later I figured out I should have waited until morning to post this.

I've been mulling over the philbeeney shot for a couple of days. I was sure he was something, but not sure what. So, when it came right down to it, I figured it was my best shot either way.

You're absolutely right, you should have waited.........wolfess. As you know very well, I'm just a villager. Thank you for confirming my suspicions that you have been infected by the werewolves.

In the immortal words of Cal Lightman...... You're lying.

Can I suggest fellow villagers that abijnk is the one to be lynched this round. If you get rid of me, then the fate of the village will be sealed. Why do you think I have been more active in this game compared to others??? Think about it very carefully but has anybody confirmed whether the Werewolf Hunter is still around?

I offer the following in my defence.

The werewolves want to win, so who best to have in their employ right now? The Vampire hunter. Not only does she have the insta-kill (well did have, which I might add has been foolishly used up), but should the vampires make a move, she can protect the werewolves from the vampires allowing the werewolves to continue their domination over the villagers.
 
You're absolutely right, you should have waited.........wolfess. As you know very well, I'm just a villager. Thank you for confirming my suspicions that you have been infected by the werewolves.

In the immortal words of Cal Lightman...... You're lying.

Can I suggest fellow villagers that abijnk is the one to be lynched this round. If you get rid of me, then the fate of the village will be sealed. Why do you think I have been more active in this game compared to others??? Think about it very carefully but has anybody confirmed whether the Werewolf Hunter is still around?

I offer the following in my defence.

The werewolves want to win, so who best to have in their employ right now? The Vampire hunter. Not only does she have the insta-kill (well did have, which I might add has been foolishly used up), but should the vampires make a move, she can protect the werewolves from the vampires allowing the werewolves to continue their domination over the villagers.

**** just got real.
I'm not sure if I believe you, but it might be something to consider.
Abbie, can you disprove philbeeney's claims?
Kmm, maybe a scan of Phil is in order?
 
**** just got real.
I'm not sure if I believe you, but it might be something to consider.
Abbie, can you disprove philbeeney's claims?
Kmm, maybe a scan of Phil is in order?

I don't see what good outing herself right now might have done, don't we have two or three more nights left?

EDIT:
Before risking us knowing of her infection?
 
You're absolutely right, you should have waited.........wolfess. As you know very well, I'm just a villager. Thank you for confirming my suspicions that you have been infected by the werewolves.

In the immortal words of Cal Lightman...... You're lying.

Can I suggest fellow villagers that abijnk is the one to be lynched this round. If you get rid of me, then the fate of the village will be sealed. Why do you think I have been more active in this game compared to others??? Think about it very carefully but has anybody confirmed whether the Werewolf Hunter is still around?

I offer the following in my defence.

The werewolves want to win, so who best to have in their employ right now? The Vampire hunter. Not only does she have the insta-kill (well did have, which I might add has been foolishly used up), but should the vampires make a move, she can protect the werewolves from the vampires allowing the werewolves to continue their domination over the villagers.

see philbeeney, if you are not a wolf, this doesn't make any sense.

and why didn't you vote for her before if you suspected of her 'turning'?

then you suggest that you are the ww hunter? if you were, you'd already have bolted her with the insta-kill

honestly, it looks like you want us not to believe you...
 
Thanks for pointing that out Don't Panic, now I am convinced that phil is a werewolf and abijnk is telling the truth.
 
I don't see what good outing herself right now might have done, don't we have two or three more nights left?

EDIT:
Before risking us knowing of her infection?

Yeah, I don't see it either and Abbie's not a noob so this is really odd.
Edit: the burden of proof is still on you, philbeeney.

I think we found the other wolves... I've been "outed" for quite some time now.

As for proof, no, I cannot offer proof per the rules. You have to take it on faith. But mark my word: not following my suggestion is foolish
 
see philbeeney, if you are not a wolf, this doesn't make any sense.

and why didn't you vote for her before if you suspected of her 'turning'?

then you suggest that you are the ww hunter? if you were, you'd already have bolted her with the insta-kill

honestly, it looks like you want us not to believe you...

I wasn't completely sure that she had been infected by the werewolves. This action confirmed that she has been.

Why would I "bolt" her with the insta-kill? I have no need to do that as she has already outed herself with her actions. I'll leave that ability to get any other werewolves before the end of the game. I only have one shot and I want to use it wisely.

I added that comment for dramatic effect. Perhaps not a wise choice considering the circumstances.

The vampire hunter and the werewolf hunter are supposed to be on the same side. Why would the vampire hunter say that she tried to kill the werewolf hunter if she hadn't been infected by the werewolves.

Proceed wisely and with caution villagers otherwise you will end up being defeated again, just like the last game.
 
The village woke up to a grisly sight.

In front of each of the villagers' front doors is a body part. It so happens that renewed opened the door to discover King Mook Mook's head.

On the gallows, they found King Mook Mook's feet planted on the platform, and a writing next to it in blood; "plant your feet here."

Yet another day is dawning, and the dreaded debate begins.

King Mook Mook was dismembered by the werewolves. 12 now remain, and 7 is the majority vote.
 
I think we found the other wolves... I've been "outed" for quite some time now.

As for proof, no, I cannot offer proof per the rules. You have to take it on faith. But mark my word: not following my suggestion is foolish

Per philbeeney:

You're absolutely right, you should have waited.........wolfess. As you know very well, I'm just a villager. Thank you for confirming my suspicions that you have been infected by the werewolves.

I was questioning what good it would have done for the wolves if you had outed yourself as the infected wolf as he suggested given that we have several more playable days before such an action could even be considered necessary.

I was actually defending your veracity.

EDIT:

I see that ravenvii has posted, per Abijnk's confirmation I will be voting for philbeeney.
 
Now you guys can trust that I'm not a werewolf, unless of course I got infected, as well as everyone else that KMM scanned. Which leads me to believe that abijnk is right, since she was scanned also, philbeeney is a werewolf.
 
Per philbeeney:



I was questioning what good it would have done for the wolves if you had outed yourself as the infected wolf as he suggested given that we have several more playable days before such an action could even be considered necessary.

I was actually defending your veracity.

EDIT:

I see that ravenvii has posted, per Abijnk's confirmation I will be voting for philbeeney.

I misunderstood.

Edit: philbeeney
 
FordPrefect.jpg "That's awkward!"

OK, if Philbeeney really is the WW hunter saving his shot for another werewolf the only way to confirm that is either have him prove it with killing the purportedly wolftastic abijnk or we wait and see if the wolves kill him. That could take two nights though if he's the WW hunter. That could spare the village one killing "tomorrow night" but we lose the werewolf hunter the next.
All of this seems pretty improbable and more like desperation. I don't want to be too hasty though so maybe since all we have to go on here is words and the insta-kill to prove it, do you want to take that shot at abijnk, Phil? If she's really a wolf it won't be wasted, especially as these votes are not going your way and it's likely the only chance you have to prove and save yourself.



P.S. - MOOKSTER!!! :( (though who couldn't see that one coming?)
 
Votes so far:

philbeeney: 3 (NathanMuir, willbro, abijnk)

Majority is 7

Left to vote:
Rodimus Prime
ucfgrad93
Melrose
Philbeeney
Mexbearpig
appleguy123
iBlue
Don't panic
Renewed
Stonyc


Methinks iBlue is a werewolf too, she hasn't voted very often during this game. She usually is kind of quiet but no voting for that long? Defense iBlue?
 
Methinks iBlue is a werewolf too, she hasn't voted very often during this game. She usually is kind of quiet but no voting for that long? Defense iBlue?

Pfffft, yeah right! :rolleyes: Though I can explain my voting. (I think I only missed a total of two, BTW) In the early stages of the game voting was happening faster and also while I was sleeping or busy. I didn't have a chance to vote because you'd all reached majority before I'd signed on to MR. I have voted ever since because the game has gone slower. Why have I not just jumped on the bandwagon and voted Phil? Because I am giving him one last chance to prove himself. I probably will vote for him because I think this could be a ploy on his part but I'm trying not to be too hasty.
 
Pfffft, yeah right! :rolleyes: Though I can explain my voting. (I think I only missed a total of two, BTW) In the early stages of the game voting was happening faster and also while I was sleeping or busy. I didn't have a chance to vote because you'd all reached majority before I'd signed on to MR. I have voted ever since because the game has gone slower. Why have I not just jumped on the bandwagon and voted Phil? Because I am giving him one last chance to prove himself. I probably will vote for him but I'm trying not to be too hasty.

Okay, it was just a thought... and yes you are in a different time zone so you might miss a round or two of voting. Good to see that you aren't voting with the mob.:)
 
NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!! :( :( :(

Darn it, stupid school! I got my scan at 8:42 AM, school finishes at 3:30 PM and I just got home (4:30 PM), to find myself killed and dismembered by werewolves (which happened at 3:04 PM)! Damn school blocking MacRumors!

And I had found a wolfie too!

I think that's all I can say, given I'm not allowed to influence that game (I think?), but ravenvii, given the circumstances am I allowed to say at least what/who I've found? I totally understand if you say no, just wondering, for precedent too (if you had to be away from the game, than are you allowed to post info that you could've when you were away?)

In any event, you guys have been a great village!

I must, say, I am feeling a little iBlue. :p

Hint hint??? :confused:

That's not a hint, sorry bro (I'm sorry willbro, doing that never gets old)! Apologies iBlue, I didn't mean to throw suspicion on you, just when I was posting this last death note, I looked down and saw your previous post, and thought, "boy, I am sad about this whole death thing!" :)p), and thought that it would be witty to end with that I was feeling iBlue (get it, get it? :p) So, no secret conspiracy or message, I wouldn't break the rules like that! It was an honest accident, nothing to do with iBlue (I didn't even scan her last night, and that's all I'll say about that for now!)

So, just to make clear for all, I did not scan iBlue on the night I died, or any night for that matter! I have no idea if she is a wolf (I'm inclined to believe she isn't, just from her actions, but, I have to admit, I'm not terribly good at this game!) Comprende?

No, absolutely not. That is not within the rules of the game.

Yes, I realise this, I was just curious, in regards to the current circumstances! I know that it's not in the rules, I looked, I know you can't influence the game after death (it makes sense!) That would be exactly why I didn't do it (one needs to follow the rules after all). Particularly after the jav incident that shall not be named! :p
 
^ I doubt it because that's breaking game rules, plus it's not correct.


edit - thanks for clarifying, Mookster because that did make me go "WTF?!"
 
For anyone suspecting abijnk for infection, riddle me this. Why would they risk losing a wolf with so many players left. The more wolves the easier they can turn the majority away from each other. It would be a very foolish move for them. So for now I believe her. Philbeeney
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.