Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] Knee-Deep in the Dead - WOOF WOOF WEREWOLVES WIN

Current votes with only two people yet to vote. Koodauw still out in the lead but closely followed by Intell. My vote for Koodauw was pretty much a joke based on the fact he broke my script, so I could be persuaded to switch. Koodauw/Intell - either of you have any defense?

Koodauw: 5 FenrisMoonlight, Intell, Scepticalscribe, Tomorrow, anjinha
Intell: 4 Sythas, TechGod, Don't panic, Queen of Spades
Tomorrow: 2 Plutonius, ravenvii
rick snagwell: 1 Melrose
Moyank24: 1 rick snagwell
Scepticalscribe: 1 Koodauw
no vote: 1 Comeagain?

Yet to vote: Moyank24, WoodNUFC

Voting Log
Post 253 Plutonius voted for Tomorrow
Post 256 Don't panic voted for rick snagwell
Post 257 Koodauw voted for Scepticalscribe
Post 260 rick snagwell voted for Scepticalscribe
Post 264 FenrisMoonlight voted for Koodauw
Post 272 Melrose voted for rick snagwell
Post 273 rick snagwell voted for Moyank24 replacing previous vote in post 260 for Scepticalscribe
Post 285 Sythas voted for Intell
Post 291 TechGod voted for Intell
Post 294 Intell voted for Koodauw
Post 298 Queen of Spades voted for no vote
Post 299 ravenvii voted for Tomorrow
Post 314 Scepticalscribe voted for Koodauw
Post 315 Comeagain? voted for no vote
Post 316 Tomorrow voted for Koodauw
Post 323 anjinha voted for Koodauw
Post 334 Queen of Spades voted for rick snagwell replacing previous vote in post 298 for no vote
Post 348 Don't panic voted for Intell replacing previous vote in post 256 for rick snagwell
Post 349 Queen of Spades voted for Intell replacing previous vote in post 334 for rick snagwell
 
Queen of Spades said:
You basically have outed yourself. The only way you can be certain that chrmjenkins is not the oracle is if you have the means to find that out. Changing my vote for obvious reasons. Intell.
Click to expand...
well kind of. but not the seer or undertaker. dont want those guys thinking im lying and saying im that role.
 
this early in the game would be an unnecessary risk for a wolk to come out with a blatant lie, especially when they are not in great danger.
there are only limited options for him to know about chris's role, especially this early in the game (i can think of 3), if not one of them, he will, be found out soon and lynched.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rick snagwell
Don't panic said:
this early in the game would be an unnecessary risk for a wolk to come out with a blatant lie, especially when they are not in great danger.
there are only limited options for him to know about chris's role, especially this early in the game (i can think of 3), if not one of them, he will, be found out soon and lynched.
Click to expand...

agreed. can you do a wolf analysis on melrose?
 
rick snagwell said:
i didnt really do much techgod, just gave a tiny tidbit of info, you dont have to believe me. but please look after the game so i can get your benefit of the doubt next time. xo
Click to expand...
Well, that tiny tidbit of info was useful but not at the expense of you exposing yourself.
 
Don't panic said:
this early in the game would be an unnecessary risk for a wolk to come out with a blatant lie, especially when they are not in great danger.
there are only limited options for him to know about chris's role, especially this early in the game (i can think of 3), if not one of them, he will, be found out soon and lynched.
Click to expand...
I'll have to re-read the roles again. I only make it 2 given the ones he's denied.
 
I see two or three roles. I doubt one of them though so for all intents and purposes I wanna say that he has two possible roles.
 
actually, i have to revise my statement. there were 6 ways rick could have known for sure chrmjenkins was not the oracle.
rick excluded one, so there are still 5, though a couple are a bit far-fetched

EDIT the first to post the correct answer, wins 5 likes :D
if you prove me wrong, 10 likes :D:D
 
Last edited:
Don't panic said:
actually, i have to revise my statement. there were 6 ways rick could have known for sure chrmjenkins was not the oracle.
rick excluded one, so there are still 5, though a couple are a bit far-fetched
Click to expand...
Ok - now I really need to go re-read the rules again. I have 4 (3 after the 1 excluded by rick), 1 of which would allow him to still be a wolf and know for sure that chrmjenkins was not the oracle.
 
TechGod said:
I'm trying to think in what cases the undertaker is useful but I can't think of anything.
Click to expand...

It is a lesser role, but one which comes into its own later in the game. The Undertaker can offer proof that a deceased person held a particular role; that is valuable late in the game when people are not sure what roles are still in play. Thus, they can offer proof that a particular person held a specific role; this eliminates people and roles, and it also makes it harder for the wolves to bluff.

Moreover, the Undertaker can also offer precision as to which role a dead WW held, which can be rather useful when planning strategy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Don't panic
Don't panic said:
actually, i have to revise my statement. there were 6 ways rick could have known for sure chrmjenkins was not the oracle.
rick excluded one, so there are still 5, though a couple are a bit far-fetched

EDIT the first to post the correct answer, wins 5 likes :D
if you prove me wrong, 10 likes :D:D
Click to expand...

Remind me, again, please of these three or four. Or five. Hypothetically, of course…..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back