Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
actually, i have to revise my statement. there were 6 ways rick could have known for sure chrmjenkins was not the oracle.
rick excluded one, so there are still 5, though a couple are a bit far-fetched

EDIT the first to post the correct answer, wins 5 likes :D
if you prove me wrong, 10 likes :D:D
i excluded two sir.
 
Actually, re-reading the roles (and rules) I confess that I cannot come up with four, five, six or eight roles/reasons why rick should know that chrmjenkins was not the Oracle (excluding the Undertaker, which is an impossibility.)
 
Well, that tiny tidbit of info was useful but not at the expense of you exposing yourself.

Gosh I hope this village doesn't have any children about....

meanwhile all the wolves are quiet and laughing.

melrose? amiright!?

Okay "Intell" (or was it Twietee last game?) I'm guilty because I voted for you. Faced with such logic I can only confess: (Wait for it....)






















I AM THE WALRUS!!!! :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Gosh I hope this village doesn't have any children about....



Okay "Intell" (or was it Twietee last game?) I'm guilty because I voted for you. Faced with such logic I can only confess:

I AM THE WALRUS!!!! :p
"The time has come," the Walrus said,
"To talk of many things:
Of shoes--and ships--and sealing-wax--
Of cabbages--and kings--
And why the sea is boiling hot--
And whether pigs have wings."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
"The time has come," the Walrus said,
"To talk of many things:
Of shoes--and ships--and sealing-wax--
Of cabbages--and kings--
And why the sea is boiling hot--
And whether pigs have wings."


...upon further self examination, I believe I am the Cabbage. :(

Goodness these new roles...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Melrose, I haven't voted for you in a long time. Maybe never in the history of these games. Why would I vote for you now?
 
I'm not sure why the votes for Intell are obvious....did I miss something?

What do you mean by obvious? I think the last two votes (me, DP - which happened simultaneously) were just an attempt to even things up and not make Koodauw the obvious lynchee just yet. Intell and some others had 2 votes to Koodauw's 4.
 
Well, this is interesting. I'll take Rick's word that he is a villager, but I haven't decided where my vote will be cast.
 
@Don't panic I think I have ideas.
This includes hypotheticals. Ones that aren't even possible in this scenario:
-Seer
-Undertaker
-Oracle
-Leech
-Scavenger
-Night Watch??

How are you getting 6?!
Undertaker isn't possible but you got one I missed so I'm up to 9 possibles now. Of which 1 he's denied, 1 I'm sure isn't the case and 5 out of the remaining 7 he could still be a wolf.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Don't panic
Undertaker isn't possible but you got one I missed so I'm up to 9 possibles now. Of which 1 he's denied, 1 I'm sure isn't the case and 5 out of the remaining 7 he could still be a wolf.
As I said, I'm counting ones that are impossible in this scenario:p Can you tell me which ones I've missed out?
 
As I said, I'm counting ones that are impossible in this scenario:p Can you tell me which ones I've missed out?
I guess since you've already revealed most of the friendly options it doesn't hurt to reveal the unfriendly ones at this point.

Alpha/Kamikaze/3rd wolf (if the oracle is a wolf or the wolves know chrmjenkins wasn't the oracle via some other power use).

Note: If he knows by being Leech/Scavenger - it doesn't discount him also being a wolf.

You also missed Morph
 
  • Like
Reactions: Don't panic
I guess since you've already revealed most of the friendly options it doesn't hurt to reveal the unfriendly ones at this point.

Alpha/Kamikaze/3rd wolf (if the oracle is a wolf or the wolves know chrmjenkins wasn't the oracle via some other power use).

Note: If he knows by being Leech/Scavenger - it doesn't discount him also being a wolf.

You also missed Morph
I considered morpher, but it says that if that role is in play already then he/she will get a person to choose without knowing what power they have. I didn't think about the possibility that it might have not originally been a role though.
He also seems to suggest he is a villager so that's why I didn't add the baddie options(although this is a game about lying, soooo)
 
I considered morpher, but it says that if that role is in play already then he/she will get a person to choose without knowing what power they have. I didn't think about the possibility that it might have not originally been a role though.
I think your misreading Morpher. If the role is assigned the player can choose whether or not to assume the alignment of the other player and can exchange PMs with that player.

So rick could have morphed to chrmjenkins role and been able to exchange PMs with him before he died.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Don't panic
I think your misreading Morpher. If the role is assigned the player can choose whether or not to assume the alignment of the other player and can exchange PMs with that player.

So rick could have morphed to chrmjenkins role and been able to exchange PMs with him before he died.
Ah. Yeah ok, I misinterpreted it then. Maybe I need to read the rules again.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.