Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
True. I am still alive too but I'm not the threat you are. I have to go out to daughter's graduation but will muse on it while there.

I agree its unlikely but if true revealing everyone hands it to you.

don't sell yourself short :)

and, honestly, if i was the kami/alpha with tomorrow and the new seer on my side, i think we would be in such a dominant position that we wouldn't need this at all
 
I get it, but if you're infected and you started this whole thing, I'm going to be ticked at you! :p

I'm the Thug. At the end of the day, if I get lynched today the wolves knowing about it won't matter anyway.

Thank you. but being the thug does clear you, village exclusive! see you later FenrisMoonlight ;)
 
Good grief what a shiznitstorm... :eek:

Let me read and catch up; but just so you know I'm not ignoring the call, I'm online and will update shortly. Let's just say I have a sort of immunity.

Moyank24 -- just hoping Tomorrow's vote wasn't just a wild guess.

I'm beginning to doubt you have even been reading the past posts at all. Tomorrow was the Seer and had two scans, DP and Plutonius, and he's confirmed his Seer power has been swapped out after Pluto died. Goodness, just read the very post above yours... It's like you don't want to have the facts, or want to cast uninformed votes. :?

--
...what are the odds that Don't Panic is one of the core WW and Tomorrow was infected? I haven't read back through the past two pages yet, just tossing that out there. It would be mighty lucky odds to infect the Seer, but a huge boon to the WW who have been playing a very clever game. The whole outing of roles therefore also plays directly into their hands, correct? I mean, for three games now I've been soapboxing to have information-related roles more in evidence; what motive is there for Don't Panic to push so hard to get everyone to reveal themselves?

...and, yes, DP, my old former NW watch buddy, I do bear a slight grudge from having betrayed trust in the last game.

......srsly not really. :p In all reality this game has been all over the place. = fun. :D
 
Last edited:
paging @Comeagain?, @anjinha, @rick snagwell, @ravenvii, @Melrose

care to share your opinion on the question being discussed?

@Moyank24 , players still without a role are:

Melrose: ?
anjinha: ?
comeagain: ?
fenris: ?
dontpanic: ?

players still to vote are: anjinha, comeagain, rick sangwell


It is now Night 5. Lynch away!

Next deadline is Thursday 10:00 AM EST.

Ok, I should not log back tonight and could have some trouble tomorrow morning, placeholder on comeagain

So should I scan Pluto or no?

You should choose which target is best for you, because it will help you on your decisions tomorrow;)
 
Ok, I should not log back tonight and could have some trouble tomorrow morning, placeholder on comeagain

I'm curious about Comeagain as well, and increasingly so with Don't Panic for his rabid push at revealing unnecessary roles basically only useful to Le Carnivoreurs. Sceptical is gone, so we can't ask for any sort of verification on her end, and in my somewhat Riesling-influenced* brain atm it fits.

I'll keep my unwaffling vote on Ravenvii for the time being but I'll be on well before deadline tomorrow to catch up.

players still to vote are: ...rick sangwell

I don't know about sang well but he certainly did sing multiple tunes quite loudly. :D

*my only remaining scotch is a rare 17yo malt. It awaits my father's retirement later this year.
 
I'm curious about Comeagain as well, and increasingly so with Don't Panic for his rabid push at revealing unnecessary roles basically only useful to Le Carnivoreurs. Sceptical is gone, so we can't ask for any sort of verification on her end, and in my somewhat Riesling-influenced* brain atm it fits.

I'll keep my unwaffling vote on Ravenvii for the time being but I'll be on well before deadline tomorrow to catch up.



I don't know about sang well but he certainly did sing multiple tunes quite loudly. :D

*my only remaining scotch is a rare 17yo malt. It awaits my father's retirement later this year.
I really don't think that this helps the wolfies more, especially now that guard and thug are out in the open.
The only ones missing are you, fenris, comeagain and anjinha. Plus mine of course which is being held back temporarily as a fail-safe mechanism ( with tomorrow in control)

The possibilities of me and tomorrow both being wolves has been discussed at lenght earlier in the thread. Not impossible, but very very unlikely, especially compared to other scenarios. And not true, but it is kind of pointless to me to reiterate this.

I just want to add that at this point the wolves already plenty of informations, and the lack of the last four makes little difference to them, but a huge one tne village

At this point what is the poi t of holding back, you are just providing the wolves a spot to hide. Same for fenris and the other two, if they ever decide to post again here ( they have been active in the forum, so it's not like they are away)
 
I really don't think that this helps the wolfies more, especially now that guard and thug are out in the open.
The only ones missing are you, fenris, comeagain and anjinha. Plus mine of course which is being held back temporarily as a fail-safe mechanism ( with tomorrow in control)

The possibilities of me and tomorrow both being wolves has been discussed at lenght earlier in the thread. Not impossible, but very very unlikely, especially compared to other scenarios. And not true, but it is kind of pointless to me to reiterate this.
I don't see it as all that improbable, actually. The bottom line is this: if you're both wolves, you can vouch for each other till the cows come home to roost, and snicker all the way to victory. The only times I see you get this pushy is when you're hiding something; and in the meantime you've got yourself a tidy little catch-22 of 'Trust Me I'm a Lawyer' going me here, but whether it's you or you and tomorrow or you and anybody, it's still just one word against another and your proof is same thing.

Truthfully, I think you're afraid to come out and say what you are because you don't want to take chance of giving claimed someone elses role. Clever rhetoric, and your verbals skills will no doubt trump mine, but super effective at this point in the game, as it usually is regardless of which side you're batting for.

Anyway I'm tired and have had a glass or two of imbibements.
 
Random guess or something tipping you towards her?

Not random - I'm basing it on votes and the nature of her posts up to that point.

I'm the guard. First night Protected DP, second night protected myself, third night protected SS. Obviously I will not tell last night.

What a colossal blunder. Now the wolves will take out our last bit of protection - with no seer and now, no guard, the scales have tipped greatly in the Wolves' favor.

DP you can be alpha or kami if the Seer was infected... Unlikely but it is possible.

However. if the Seer was infected before revealing himself they can both be wolves. Seer scanned DP Night 1 and found a wolf - either the Seer was also infected Night 1 or they waited to reveal and were infected before they revealed.

At this point Tomorrow doesn't even have to be the Seer - he could have been initial wolf soother all along. The infected Seer is still in play and they still have the swapper power to use and they are fishing for who best to use it on. Pluto didn't have a useful power so was sacrificed to sway the village.

...what are the odds that Don't Panic is one of the core WW and Tomorrow was infected? I haven't read back through the past two pages yet, just tossing that out there.

You two baffle me - I can't, for the life of me, wrap my head around "let me offer up my (hypothetical) werewolf teammate for lynching first thing in the morning" as a sound strategy.

Changing my vote to anjinha.
 
I don't see it as all that improbable, actually. The bottom line is this: if you're both wolves, you can vouch for each other till the cows come home to roost, and snicker all the way to victory. The only times I see you get this pushy is when you're hiding something; and in the meantime you've got yourself a tidy little catch-22 of 'Trust Me I'm a Lawyer' going me here, but whether it's you or you and tomorrow or you and anybody, it's still just one word against another and your proof is same thing.

Truthfully, I think you're afraid to come out and say what you are because you don't want to take chance of giving claimed someone elses role. Clever rhetoric, and your verbals skills will no doubt trump mine, but super effective at this point in the game, as it usually is regardless of which side you're batting for.

Anyway I'm tired and have had a glass or two of imbibements.
the point of me going last is EXACTLY be ause i cannot look at what other say and pick another one, because tomorrow scanned me on day 1 ( confirmed by SS) and he knows what i am
If i declare now, then you, fenris, anjinha or comeagain (whoever waits longer) can do precisely what you are accusing me of doing, but without Ny risk of getting caught.
All the relevant roles are exposed already, the only reason to bold on now is good ol' stubborness or a very hairy neck
 
Not random - I'm basing it on votes and the nature of her posts up to that point.



What a colossal blunder. Now the wolves will take out our last bit of protection - with no seer and now, no guard, the scales have tipped greatly in the Wolves' favor.







You two baffle me - I can't, for the life of me, wrap my head around "let me offer up my (hypothetical) werewolf teammate for lynching first thing in the morning" as a sound strategy.

Changing my vote to anjinha.

The scales were already almost turning over
It is not a blunder if the villagers buy in,
If only some do, then yes, it becomes an advantage to the wolves

edit: typos
 
Last edited:
Not following what is the urgency?
We have plenty of time, no?

And why intell? Isn't he the amplifier?

Wood would be good ( might expose a fake role)
If we get a wolfie that would be the best target, imo
Yeah. Wood seems to be a good option. I just wanna send the person I wanna scan to Tweetie now in case I can't come online again today.
 
I'm too skeptical about Don't Panic. He's been around longer than usual and is still pushing for everyone to reveal themselves.

Btw, I'm a villager with an often misused power.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.