Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] Knee-Deep in the Dead - WOOF WOOF WEREWOLVES WIN

Sorry, wasn't actually prepared for a ML - so action-report comes in two hours later or so. :D

1000 questions unsolved - later in the rules thread. These complex games: devil in the detail I say!!

Sorry again to Melrose The Gourmet as I messed up the Bluff (had that role still in the General Pool when assigning) and to the wolves in general since a Lost in The Woods rule would heve helped them tremendously.

@All: thanks for playing. hope it worked out more or less.
 
Don't panic said:
i kept hoping till the end that comeagain would use the executioner power
Click to expand...

Well, not sure how that should be done tbh. Your role description wasn't telling anything what to do when ML appears: wait till DL (and kill the drama)? Give a short deadline (and make him extra suspicious now since I didn't do that explicitly before when ML got reached? Eventually end game?
 
twietee said:
Well, not sure how that should be done tbh. Your role description wasn't telling anything what to do when ML appears: wait till DL (and kill the drama)? Give a short deadline (and make him extra suspicious now since I didn't do that explicitly before when ML got reached? Eventually end game?
Click to expand...
usually there is a 'reasonable window' right after the deadline/ML for the executioner to use their power
also, you could have PMed me or chris.
but you are right some of the roles need to be explained better with new GG onboard.

in any case,
really excellent games twietee.
we'll fix the rules afterward
Moyank24 said:
Sweet Victory! :D
Click to expand...


well played, lady ;)
i was sure it was you and i was going nooooooooooooooo :D :D

wolfies all played well (quite the all-star team, too:))
 
  • Like
Reactions: twietee and Scepticalscribe
rick snagwell - Scavenger
Sythas - Guard
Moyank24 - infected villager/Thug/NW
Scepticalscribe - Spy
Don't panic - Die-Hard
Plutonius - Swapper
Koodauw - Rioter
chrmjenkins - Hunter/NW
Melrose - Alpha/Bluff
anjinha - Judge
Queen of Spades - Reverber
ravenvii - Leech
comeagain? - Executioner
TechGod - Undertaker
FenrisMoonlight - Kami/Soother
Intell - Amplifier
Tomorrow - Seer
WoodNUFC - Necromancer
Astroboy907 - Morpher​
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Melrose and Scepticalscribe
Comeagain? said:
On who? I had no reason to change who I was voting for at the end. Then we hit majority and AFAIK then I can't use it anyway. That day happened without any talk from anyone.
Click to expand...

once it came out fenris was the ww, to me to me it seemed clear the other one must be moyank by the way the fenris lynching went.
she just waited to the last moment to see what i would do, if i voted raven, she would too and they win, if i vote fenris she piles up, if i vote rick or you, she does as well and fenris switches.

wolves clearly were very active, so the other WW would have not likely be MIA.

also, anyone ML at the end would likely be the wolfie, especially if it happened quickly.
 
Don't panic said:
how soon was the infection?
Click to expand...

The turn before I died (night three I think).

I guessed correctly about Wood being the Necromancer :).
I did however believe that SS was the thug trying to get us to attack her and that Tomorrow was NOT the seer since he would have scanned me by turn 3.

Note - The new forum is great for WW. We had a long thread going.
 
Last edited:
Don't panic said:
Ouch.
well done wolfies.
Click to expand...
The early soothe gained us a day and people not voting one day helped us too. Although I think it cost us Pluto as he voted to tie them up for the soothe. Tomorrow seemed suspicious of Pluto anyway though so maybe he'd have still scanned him.

Everyone revealing roles almost messed us up because we had two roles we couldn't reveal. Although knowing all the roles at that point helped us as a lot too.

We took a risk that Sythas had protected himself when he said he'd gone random - I really didn't believe he'd just rolled the dice and killed him the next night. After that the fact we couldn't miss a kill meant you only had to miss once.

I really enjoyed using the kamikaze to take you out DP :)
 
Comeagain? said:
On who? I had no reason to change who I was voting for at the end. Then we hit majority and AFAIK then I can't use it anyway. That day happened without any talk from anyone.
Click to expand...
I wanted to kill you rather than Tomorrow but it was Moyank's decision at that point. Was thinking you'd look for who people jumped on and then take out the other person who couldn't be an original wolf.
 
Too much cross checking of roles occurs with the new rules. The infection needs to be moved back to anytime (tactical) rather then only at night (strategic). Currently, depending on which player is the alpha, the WWs may be forced to infect on night one rather then infecting someone who is cleared.
 
Plutonius said:
Too much cross checking of roles occurs with the new rules. The infection needs to be moved back to anytime (tactical) rather then only at night (strategic). Currently, depending on which player is the alpha, the WWs may be forced to infect on night one rather then infecting someone who is cleared.
Click to expand...

I think the wolves have enough advantage without changing the infection back, personally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
FenrisMoonlight said:
The early soothe gained us a day and people not voting one day helped us too. Although I think it cost us Pluto as he voted to tie them up for the soothe. Tomorrow seemed suspicious of Pluto anyway though so maybe he'd have still scanned him.

Everyone revealing roles almost messed us up because we had two roles we couldn't reveal. Although knowing all the roles at that point helped us as a lot too.

We took a risk that Sythas had protected himself when he said he'd gone random - I really didn't believe he'd just rolled the dice and killed him the next night. After that the fact we couldn't miss a kill meant you only had to miss once.

I really enjoyed using the kamikaze to take you out DP :)
Click to expand...

i am sure you did. :D
i was hoping i might still be protected by sythas

i think if we didn't come out it would have been a very easy win for you guys. this way we came close.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FenrisMoonlight
Plutonius said:
Too much cross checking of roles occurs with the new rules. The infection needs to be moved back to anytime (tactical) rather then only at night (strategic). Currently, depending on which player is the alpha, the WWs may be forced to infect on night one rather then infecting someone who is cleared.
Click to expand...

imo that is exactly why it shouldn't be changed back.
otherwise it becomes automatic, and this way the wolves need to protect the alpha, at least at the beginning. which makes sense for gameplay and thematically
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Don't panic said:
i am sure you did. :D
i was hoping i might still be protected by sythas

i think if we didn't come out it would have been a very easy win for you guys. this way we came close.
Click to expand...
It was nearly a very easy loss for you. I made the scan call the night before the wrong way - it was going to be either TechGod or you. I scanned TechGod - if I'd scanned you - we'd have been able to hide much easier as TechGod was already out and a lot of the others was known.
 
Don't panic said:
imo that is exactly why it shouldn't be changed back.
otherwise it becomes automatic, and this way the wolves need to protect the alpha, at least at the beginning. which makes sense for gameplay and thematically
Click to expand...
I'd say allow it be used day 1 as well - so it can still be used if the villagers randomly lynch the alpha the first day.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back