Goodamit, that was to fast, I was about to edit the question when I saw the answer... oh well... so #1 through #7 we have suspects
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] MRville VI: GAME OVER - VILLAGERS WIN
- Thread starter ravenvii
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Goodamit, that was to fast, I was about to edit the question when I saw the answer... oh well... so #1 through #7 we have suspects
Here is where the Nightwatch comes in handy; they can pick me in their club, I am a confirmed villager with immunity through this Night and Day 3... it ends on Night 3. Also, here is to where the Seer should scan now, those people listed.
divine speed i suppose. 
oh well, since i don't think i can be as frequently online for a while, i will proceed to sort the 'other 6' suspects in order of perceived badness (for the newbies, before we get in this argument once again: no, I am not on my own suspect's list)
1)philbeeney, 2) appleguy123, 3) iblue, 4) stonyc, 5) ibookg4, 6) nathanmuir
since i doubt all the bad guys are in the top 7, here is my badness ranking of the 'bottom 5':
1) Rodimus 2) cBoss 3) mexbearpig 4) mscriv 5) jav (as a possible future infectee)
jav, you really have to fix the fur-o-meter
oh well, since i don't think i can be as frequently online for a while, i will proceed to sort the 'other 6' suspects in order of perceived badness (for the newbies, before we get in this argument once again: no, I am not on my own suspect's list)
1)philbeeney, 2) appleguy123, 3) iblue, 4) stonyc, 5) ibookg4, 6) nathanmuir
since i doubt all the bad guys are in the top 7, here is my badness ranking of the 'bottom 5':
1) Rodimus 2) cBoss 3) mexbearpig 4) mscriv 5) jav (as a possible future infectee)
jav, you really have to fix the fur-o-meter
Yes, you are confirmed villager with immunity through Day 3. But if the WW knew that you were inducted into the night watch (or knew with enough certainty to make a good guess that you were), they could choose to infect you and then just wipe out 3 players (the night watch) in one night.
I'm going to disagree about inducting you into the NW because even though you are an obvious target of infection (which makes you less likely of a target of infection to some degree), the risk that we could lose the entire night watch in one night is too high.
IMO, I think it's better that you stay a regular old villager at this time, but since you are a confirmed villager (with a lesser chance of actual infection), we can more safely eliminate you from lynching considerations. Feel free to disagree about the risk of infection versus the risk of losing the night watch because it's not up to me... just my opinion.
Regarding the Top 7, of which I am a part... I can't provide proof, but I'm not a WW or Vampire/Goth. I will say that I want to stick around, for good reasons.
EDIT: I don't think philbeeney is a bad guy. I'm going to vote for NathanMuir because in the last round, his vote for ibro was based solely on his name change (at least according to Nathan's vote post). That doesn't give me a particularly good feeling about him.
Last edited:
Not gonna, happen, I'll rebel before turning over the villagers
For sucking blood?
I can also say that I am not a vampire or a werewolf(though a vampire and a werewolf would say that).
Out of this list, Philbeeney is acting the most like his werewolf mode (when I was a werewolf with him).
I can assure you I am not a werewolf or a vamp.
I'll reveal my role if I get dangerously close in votes.
I am going to vote for Appleguy123
My reasoning is I was looking threw the votes of last round and he was among the people who never really took a stand. I have noticed in games past that wolves often try to avoid voting or avoid taking a stand against someone with the majority.
Since he was among the people who voted for people who only had one vote I am voting for him.
My reasoning is I was looking threw the votes of last round and he was among the people who never really took a stand. I have noticed in games past that wolves often try to avoid voting or avoid taking a stand against someone with the majority.
Since he was among the people who voted for people who only had one vote I am voting for him.
What? Excuse me if I wasn't exactly emboldened at the choice of voting someone off due to a name change or another likely villager. It's day one. If I had taken a powerful stance, it should have been more suspicious.
Remember, everyone has a role in this game. There is a lot to lose by making quick and baseless accusations.
I guess that it's some of my real life dripping into my posts. I don't tell lies, and when people question me, it makes me rather offended. I get that people have no bearing on how I am through my posts, and I'm sorry that I appeared desperate there.
GAH, I just don't know what to think. I think the baddies are at a HUGE advantage in this game. Equal numbers of baddies/possible baddies to good players is quite a problem because it leaves pretty much no room for mistakes. Especially with what I think is a VERY stupid rule that if someone in the "Secret Society" is infected they can kill the whole society in one go. What a disastrous thing to add under these circumstances. It also makes it more problematic for the good people to reveal themselves because the wolves would probably target the society.
</game despondence>
Another game note - I'm also starting to wonder if seer scans should take place during the day. It would sure help with the voting. It may also be helpful if the seer reveals themselves they don't have to feel the torment of dying with a scan result they can't reveal.
</just my two pennies>
Some of your wording is starting to make me think that you could be a goth though.
Why do you think he isn't, out of curiosity?
</game despondence>
Another game note - I'm also starting to wonder if seer scans should take place during the day. It would sure help with the voting. It may also be helpful if the seer reveals themselves they don't have to feel the torment of dying with a scan result they can't reveal.
</just my two pennies>
Some of your wording is starting to make me think that you could be a goth though.
Why do you think he isn't, out of curiosity?
Something he posted caught me off guard at first, and philbeeney was actually about to get my vote, until I re-read what he posted in a slightly different way. I'll admit it's a little thin, but re-reading some of his posts didn't give me a strong vibe that he is a baddie, at least for now.
Nathan, I'm not fully convinced of your innocence... but I'll keep an open mind and will re-consider my vote should circumstances or further reflection warrant it.
current situation:
deadline thursday, 2AM (majority 7 votes)
philbeeney.....3 : (iBlue, don't panic, appleguy123)
appleguy123...2: (jav6454, rodimus prime)
nathanmuir.....2: (stonyC, cBoss)
iBlue..............1: (pheelbeney)
did not vote yet : mscriv, mexbearpig, nathanmuir, ibookg4user
deadline thursday, 2AM (majority 7 votes)
philbeeney.....3 : (iBlue, don't panic, appleguy123)
appleguy123...2: (jav6454, rodimus prime)
nathanmuir.....2: (stonyC, cBoss)
iBlue..............1: (pheelbeney)
did not vote yet : mscriv, mexbearpig, nathanmuir, ibookg4user
So, here's where we stand.
The prayer identified a baddie amongst:
1: iBookG4user
2: stonyc
3: philbeeney
4: appleguy123
5: Don't panic
6: Nathanmuir
7: iBlue
And voting so far is at:
iBlue - 1 vote (philbeeney)
philbeeney - 3 votes (iBlue, Don't panic, appleguy123)
NathanMuir - 2 votes (stonyc, Cboss)
appleguy123 - 2 votes (jav6454, Rodimus Prime)
4 left to vote: iBookG4user, Mexbearpig, mscriv, and Nathanmuir
majority needed is 7 votes.
Hmm.... what to do, what to do?
EDIT: oops, I see my friend Don't panic beat me to the update post... sorry to duplicate.
The prayer identified a baddie amongst:
1: iBookG4user
2: stonyc
3: philbeeney
4: appleguy123
5: Don't panic
6: Nathanmuir
7: iBlue
And voting so far is at:
iBlue - 1 vote (philbeeney)
philbeeney - 3 votes (iBlue, Don't panic, appleguy123)
NathanMuir - 2 votes (stonyc, Cboss)
appleguy123 - 2 votes (jav6454, Rodimus Prime)
4 left to vote: iBookG4user, Mexbearpig, mscriv, and Nathanmuir
majority needed is 7 votes.
Hmm.... what to do, what to do?
EDIT: oops, I see my friend Don't panic beat me to the update post... sorry to duplicate.
I would advise those who voted for me to change their vote, as it will be wasted.
Unless of course, the villagers voting for me want a plain ol' villager out the way, almost as if they're not good guys themselves.
Unless of course, the villagers voting for me want a plain ol' villager out the way, almost as if they're not good guys themselves.
you know, great minds....
also it is at least one baddie in the top 7, it could even be all 3 (2 WW+V, i don't think infection has been used yet).
on the other hand it also means there could be 1-2 baddies in the bottom 5.
pluse there are the goths, who could be anyone (including the dead ones)
as far as what to do, a vote would be a good starting point
Wait, is that deadline right? THURSDAY at 2am? (as in, late "tonight"?) It seems a day short being as the day switch was 35 hours ago. Shouldn't that be Friday 2am? (or am I sampling my baked™ goods too much? )
)
Appleguy123 just seems to be really desperate at this point. I'm not completely sure about him right now, but he just seems the most suspicious up to now. I wish that the prayer had been a bit more limited though, we have a few too many suspects right now. Although at least we're better off than we were last game. Just speaking my mind right now, but it will be interesting to see if the werewolves go to off those who were included in the prayer or if they go for those who were not.