Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] The MRville Horror, Part 3 GAME OVER - Villagers Win!

Status
Not open for further replies.
situation:

jav6454: 5 (willbro, Mexbearpig, Gelfin, ucfgrad93, Don't Panic)
ucfgrad93: 1 (abijnk)
willbro: 7 (iBookG4user, jav6454, tooz, King Mook Mook, Tomorrow, Melrose, Renewed)

MIA: mscriv, rodimus prime (apparently in timeout)

1 vote to willbro or 3 to jav6454 to move on. remember people, you can change your vote

i remain of my opinion that willbro is not a wolf because otherwise the other 2-3 WW would have tried to change the tide, but he got zero support from anyone
 
ravenvii said:
Time for yet another lynching! 15 remain. The majority this round is 8.
Click to expand...

jav6454: 5 (willbro, Mexbearpig, Gelfin, ucfgrad93, Don't Panic)
ucfgrad93: 1 (abijnk)
willbro: 6 (iBookG4user, jav6454, tooz King Mook Mook, Tomorrow, melrose)

So, let's see if what I've listed above is correct and Rodimus is in TO then it's just me and renewed left to vote. Very interesting... if we both vote for willbro then we have a lynching, but if either of us votes for someone else then we have a stalemate until someone changes their vote.

Here's the thing, I'm undecided at this point and actually on my way out the door for a baseball game with the inlaws I mentioned earlier. So, I'll mull this over for nine innings and check back later tonight. If anyone wants to continue to shed some clarity on things for me or provide better information then I'll look for your posts when I get back.
 
mscriv said:
jav6454: 5 (willbro, Mexbearpig, Gelfin, ucfgrad93, Don't Panic)
ucfgrad93: 1 (abijnk)
willbro: 6 (iBookG4user, jav6454, tooz King Mook Mook, Tomorrow, melrose)

So, let's see if what I've listed above is correct and Rodimus is in TO then it's just me and renewed left to vote. Very interesting... if we both vote for willbro then we have a lynching, but if either of us votes for someone else then we have a stalemate until someone changes their vote.

Here's the thing, I'm undecided at this point and actually on my way out the door for a baseball game with the inlaws I mentioned earlier. So, I'll mull this over for nine innings and check back later tonight. If anyone wants to continue to shed some clarity on things for me or provide better information then I'll look for your posts when I get back.
Click to expand...


renewed did vote (against willbro). it's just you, dude. Their young and probably innocent lives at your discretion (Aaahhh the pressure! :D )
 
Don't panic said:
situation:

jav6454: 5 (willbro, Mexbearpig, Gelfin, ucfgrad93, Don't Panic)
ucfgrad93: 1 (abijnk)
willbro: 7 (iBookG4user, jav6454, tooz, King Mook Mook, Tomorrow, Melrose, Renewed)

MIA: mscriv, rodimus prime (apparently in timeout)

1 vote to willbro or 3 to jav6454 to move on. remember people, you can change your vote

i remain of my opinion that willbro is not a wolf because otherwise the other 2-3 WW would have tried to change the tide, but he got zero support from anyone
Click to expand...

I just now saw your post and realize I missed renewed's vote. Wow, it's all up to me huh. Well, I've decided not to keep you guys waiting as that would be mean since I'm the only one left.

Drumroll please......................



jav6454
 
jav6454 said:
No one shows sign to change vote and mscriv locked down the vote.
Click to expand...

Which will show people that they can either change their vote or wait an indeterminate amount of time for another player to get out of time-out, realize he has to vote, and then actually vote. Someone will cede to expediency.
 
Tomorrow said:
I think we can also collectively decide not to lynch anyone. Not sure if that strategy is a good one or a bad one, at this point.
Click to expand...

No, I think Don't panic is right, it would give the baddies a fairly big advantage, even if we do end up lynching a villager. I didn't think it through well.
 
i don't see how staying 'inactive' can be a winning strategy.
during the day we hide, during the night we get eaten. not fun :D

that said, i would say anyone can vote not to lynch anyone by putting it in bold.
if the option gets a majority, its a binding decision.

i'm not voting for that though. i'd rather vote fro willbro (sorry bro) if it comes to that.
i don't think he is a wolf, but i don know for sure he isn't either, so a little chance to get one of the bad guys is better than the zero chance if we pass.

however, for now i'm still holding for jav (sorry bro) as of the two unwilling candidates it came down to, in my view he is less likely to be a simple villager.
 
Lynching someone would either help the ww/vamps or us. If we lynch and the person turns out to be a ww/vamp than +1 for the villagers but if the person turns out to be a seer, hunter, or just a plain villager than +1 for the ww/vamps. I think we should lynch someone to make the game more interesting.
 
willbro said:
Lynching someone would either help the ww/vamps or us. If we lynch and the person turns out to be a ww/vamp than +1 for the villagers but if the person turns out to be a seer, hunter, or just a plain villager than +1 for the ww/vamps. I think we should lynch someone to make the game more interesting.
Click to expand...

Might I remind you that we are both on the spotlight here. However, the only way to break this is for someone to change your vote to vote against you, or if Rodimus Prime casts his vote against you.

That is one option, the other if two people change their vote an target me. But like I said, everyone is locked in their votes, no one wants a change. We have to wait for Rodimus Prime to vote before we can continue, this way we get all the votes in and then decide.


Don't panic said:
i remain of my opinion that willbro is not a wolf because otherwise the other 2-3 WW would have tried to change the tide, but he got zero support from anyone
Click to expand...

I still haven't gotten support of someone who is vocal enough to fight for me. I've been doing my defense on my own. In fact, Gelfin admitted I did a somewhat convicing job. If I were the wolf, wouldn't I have 2 or 3 others defending me? That is by your logic what should be happening, yet I don't see it.
 
jav6454 said:
I still haven't gotten support of someone who is vocal enough to fight for me. I've been doing my defense on my own. In fact, Gelfin admitted I did a somewhat convicing job. If I were the wolf, wouldn't I have 2 or 3 others defending me? That is by your logic what should be happening, yet I don't see it.
Click to expand...

support can be subtle. plus, as you said, you are doing a pretty good job yourself, and it has been effective because the inertia changed from you being on the hotspot to willbro. :p

all in good spirit Jav, nothing personal here. it's just that my new pitchfork is collecting dust
 
Hey everyone, I'm back and the Rangers lost. :(

I see we're still at somewhat of a stalemate. The lines are pretty even except for abi whose vote for ucfgrad is of no significance due to it being the only one for him. So abi, why not change your vote and either end the stalemate or put us at a dead tie, depending on who you think appears more guilty. Don't Panic has postulated a theory that jav6454 and abi could be pack mates and that she cleverly distracted the vote by slowing the momentum with her wild card vote for ucfgrad. Well abi, by changing your vote to jav6454 you could do a lot of damage to that theory or by changing your vote to willbro you could end the stalemate. I'm not trying to put you on the spot, but your vote being the odd one out sorta puts you in this obvious position.

I've never had a TO, but from what I hear it could be a few days or more, so I think we need to see what ravenvii wants to do about Rodimus being out of the loop for the time being. Maybe we all change our votes to Rodimus and just put him out of his misery thereby teaching him that when he's playing in MRville he needs to be on his best behavior and not jack it up for everyone else.

Hmmm... so many choices at this point in the game. :confused:
 
mscriv said:
Hey everyone, I'm back and the Rangers lost. :(

I see we're still at somewhat of a stalemate. The lines are pretty even except for abi whose vote for ucfgrad is of no significance due to it being the only one for him. So abi, why not change your vote and either end the stalemate or put us at a dead tie, depending on who you think appears more guilty. Don't Panic has postulated a theory that jav6454 and abi could be pack mates and that she cleverly distracted the vote by slowing the momentum with her wild card vote for ucfgrad. Well abi, by changing your vote to jav6454 you could do a lot of damage to that theory or by changing your vote to willbro you could end the stalemate. I'm not trying to put you on the spot, but your vote being the odd one out sorta puts you in this obvious position.

I've never had a TO, but from what I hear it could be a few days or more, so I think we need to see what ravenvii wants to do about Rodimus being out of the loop for the time being. Maybe we all change our votes to Rodimus and just put him out of his misery thereby teaching him that when he's playing in MRville he needs to be on his best behavior and not jack it up for everyone else.

Hmmm... so many choices at this point in the game. :confused:
Click to expand...

On the issue of making abijnk change her vote:
1. To make a tie: We gain nothing, but a stalemate that will end with Rodimus Prime, we'll have to wait for him because like it or not, he is part of the game.
2. If she votes against willbro she will get that unjust suspicion, so she has no incentive to make this one and end the Day. Honestly, just because she broke the mob mentality doesn't make her guilty.
In General, I mean, it's a choice that she has to make, and a tough one, why make her pay for something we created. Yes, WE because, we as a group decided to make the votes tally up to now. I view it unfair for her to pay.

On the issue of Rodimus Prime:
1. It would be unfair for him to be lynched without a just defense build up. willbro and I both had our chance to defend ourselves, and that means Rodimus Prime should have his.

On the issue of your vote:
1. You could have ended it with your vote, but decided to drag it on. I won't go into detail here, but if you wanted this lynching to end, you would have voted for willbro and get it over with.

On the issue of the Rangers:
1. I was seriosuly hoping your team won.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back