Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] - They Live?! - GAME OVER - Villagers win!
- Thread starter chrmjenkins
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Nice, I'm pleased with my post-death scene.
Well, that's not good.
And also,
I'm glad you're properly moved by my unfortunate passing! (at least according to chrmjenkins)
My girlfriend is....not taking this well. I think without Neymar and Silva their expectations were very much tempered, because Germany has been much more impressive...but wow. I'm treading very carefully, here.
Then, it's Twietee.
Ironically, the only one of us 3 that Pluto didn't vote for before he was outed.
Or, of course, there's a chance she's either lying or Pluto infected her night 1. Certainly an unfortunate coincidence QOS wasn't able to be protected last night.
Last edited:
no, it doesn't clear me (although i am a villager)
and yes, it appears the maniac is here and used their power.
if we have a necromancer, it might be a good time to bring back QoS.
she would have her scan from last night, although she would likely be killed again the next night (since SS cannot protect her again).
Must admit that moyank totally bested me. Hats off.
Still could be a bluff by ss but quite unlikely.
----------
I'm the swapper. Wanted to use it now (waiting for nightly death / scan first) so if the necromancer is lurking around we could eventually provide even more than one scan.
Still could be a bluff by ss but quite unlikely.
----------
I'm the swapper. Wanted to use it now (waiting for nightly death / scan first) so if the necromancer is lurking around we could eventually provide even more than one scan.
i usually take people at their word, until the word collides with facts.
so i will assume scepticascribe is indeed the guard, and thus one of moyank and twietee is the ZW anticipated by koodauw's prophecy.
it possible that scepticascribe is the ZW however, if
- she is indeed the guard, but plutonius infected her on night one, so she in not protecting anyone (if we have a seeker, they might know this if they followed the guard)
- she is impersonating the guard. if this is true, the real guard will know and can out her (at the cost of being exposed). it is also possible that the ZWs targeted QoS without the Maniac, so the fact that the attack was successful might have suggested that the guard was already dead, and inspired SS's putative gamble.
however, the easiest explanation is that SS is telling the truth, so I am going with Moyank for the time being
----------
the undertaker is village core, while the swapper is general, so that is one hit against twietee.
of course like for SS, moyank could be telling the truth but be infected on day one.
very intriguing.
the swapper power could be used to verify moyank's story, although it is a bit of a waste (but better then letting it go to the worms).
also, although we lost QoS, we didn't necessarily lost the seer: the leech could have taken it before the night, or the scavenger could have taken it now. of course this also could mena the Zw might have seer powers
----------
EDIT: i am going back to NO VOTE, need time to think here
so i will assume scepticascribe is indeed the guard, and thus one of moyank and twietee is the ZW anticipated by koodauw's prophecy.
it possible that scepticascribe is the ZW however, if
- she is indeed the guard, but plutonius infected her on night one, so she in not protecting anyone (if we have a seeker, they might know this if they followed the guard)
- she is impersonating the guard. if this is true, the real guard will know and can out her (at the cost of being exposed). it is also possible that the ZWs targeted QoS without the Maniac, so the fact that the attack was successful might have suggested that the guard was already dead, and inspired SS's putative gamble.
however, the easiest explanation is that SS is telling the truth, so I am going with Moyank for the time being
----------
the undertaker is village core, while the swapper is general, so that is one hit against twietee.
of course like for SS, moyank could be telling the truth but be infected on day one.
very intriguing.
the swapper power could be used to verify moyank's story, although it is a bit of a waste (but better then letting it go to the worms).
also, although we lost QoS, we didn't necessarily lost the seer: the leech could have taken it before the night, or the scavenger could have taken it now. of course this also could mena the Zw might have seer powers
----------
EDIT: i am going back to NO VOTE, need time to think here
Hmm, villager core. Twice.
Would be a wonder if I'd survive this one!
But yea, either one is lying (risky) or infected (poosible).
If the latter proves to be true I may have to rethink my friendship with Pluto since I told him specifically before the game that I'd like to play once as a WW with him.
Would be a wonder if I'd survive this one!
But yea, either one is lying (risky) or infected (poosible).
If the latter proves to be true I may have to rethink my friendship with Pluto since I told him specifically before the game that I'd like to play once as a WW with him.
if you swap moyank's or skeptical scribe's power with someone else's, this third person will know for sure if you or either moyank/scepticalscribe are telling the truth about your respective roles.
still doesn't prove anything about being a baddie, but it would be a first step.
of course, if the selected person is a wolf, then you are giving them a lot of power
----------
wow, there are so many possibilities
I am loving this!
still doesn't prove anything about being a baddie, but it would be a first step.
of course, if the selected person is a wolf, then you are giving them a lot of power
----------
wow, there are so many possibilities
I am loving this!
I'd guess infection is in play. Pluto likes to think of him as someone getting lynched early in the game so this makes some sense imo.
Toin coss for me, gut says Pluto would choose Moyank. Both weren't much prolific Day 1 iirc.
----------
And infection would mean jack when swapped. Or do I miss something? I'm off to bed so either quick action or sweet, sweet dreams (7:1 BAM!). Don't blame you for lynching me, would do it myself too.
----------
And by that I mean regarding clearing me or outing the baddie. Just messing things up a bit more eventually. But I could miss something, tired.
Toin coss for me, gut says Pluto would choose Moyank. Both weren't much prolific Day 1 iirc.
----------
And infection would mean jack when swapped. Or do I miss something? I'm off to bed so either quick action or sweet, sweet dreams (7:1 BAM!
). Don't blame you for lynching me, would do it myself too.----------
And by that I mean regarding clearing me or outing the baddie. Just messing things up a bit more eventually. But I could miss something, tired.
role claimed/established (directly and indirectly) so far:
1. Moyank24 - undertaker (village core)
2. Plutonius - alpha wolf (wolf core)
3. twietee - swapper (general)
4. Sythas
5. Tomorrow - seeker (general)
6. rick snagwell
7. Don't Panic
8. Queen of Spades - seer (village core)
9. Scepticalscribe - guard (village core)
10. Jav6454
11. Techgod- stretcher (general)
12. Ucfgrad93
13. Koodauw - oracle (general)
14. ravenvii
15. appleguy123
all the village core are 'taken'
if moyank is telling the truth about being the undertaker (and about the scans), then likely also SS is telling the truth about being the guard (otherwise she could be exposed by the real guard, who must be alive)
so if either is a wolf, they would have been infected on night one by plutonius. either scenario is believable.
in this case we have a total of 3 wolves remaining (infected, kami, original general pool wolf), plus the question mark about the morpher
twietee can prove he is a swapper, but not that he is not a wolf. however, he could pass the exposed guard power from scepticalscribe to a new person (who however could be a wolf)
meanwhile, the scavenger (if present) could have taken the seer power from QOS, and the leech (again, if present) could have taken either the seer power from QOS before she died or the guard power from SS
----------
if you use your swapping power, you would confirm that indeed you are the swapper (just to the people being swapped, unless they go public), and could validate either moyank's or SS story), but it does not do anything in the sense of proving if any of you is a baddie.
of course if the swap show one person is straight out lying, than it would be significant
1. Moyank24 - undertaker (village core)
2. Plutonius - alpha wolf (wolf core)
3. twietee - swapper (general)
4. Sythas
5. Tomorrow - seeker (general)
6. rick snagwell
7. Don't Panic
8. Queen of Spades - seer (village core)
9. Scepticalscribe - guard (village core)
10. Jav6454
11. Techgod- stretcher (general)
12. Ucfgrad93
13. Koodauw - oracle (general)
14. ravenvii
15. appleguy123
all the village core are 'taken'
if moyank is telling the truth about being the undertaker (and about the scans), then likely also SS is telling the truth about being the guard (otherwise she could be exposed by the real guard, who must be alive)
so if either is a wolf, they would have been infected on night one by plutonius. either scenario is believable.
in this case we have a total of 3 wolves remaining (infected, kami, original general pool wolf), plus the question mark about the morpher
twietee can prove he is a swapper, but not that he is not a wolf. however, he could pass the exposed guard power from scepticalscribe to a new person (who however could be a wolf)
meanwhile, the scavenger (if present) could have taken the seer power from QOS, and the leech (again, if present) could have taken either the seer power from QOS before she died or the guard power from SS
----------
I'd guess infection is in play. Pluto likes to think of him as someone getting lynched early in the game so this makes some sense imo.
Toin coss for me, gut says Pluto would choose Moyank. Both weren't much prolific Day 1 iirc.
----------
And infection would mean jack when swapped. Or do I miss something? I'm off to bed so either quick action or sweet, sweet dreams (7:1 BAM!
----------
And by that I mean regarding clearing me or outing the baddie. Just messing things up a bit more eventually. But I could miss something, tired.
if you use your swapping power, you would confirm that indeed you are the swapper (just to the people being swapped, unless they go public), and could validate either moyank's or SS story), but it does not do anything in the sense of proving if any of you is a baddie.
of course if the swap show one person is straight out lying, than it would be significant
Hm, not sure DP. No problem for me in showing off with my astonishing swapping technique but would be kind of stupid to eventually lose the guard(ing) ability that way while ss really wasn't infected.
Lynching/killing should be in this order twietee, mo and then ss. Not sure how we can argue around that tbh. But you guys will find the right solution while I'm asleep. Just ask ravenvii!
The unfortunate thing is that I secretly wanted to swap QoS power with xxx today. Thought it was a good enough plan and entertaining too. Damn zombies.
Lynching/killing should be in this order twietee, mo and then ss. Not sure how we can argue around that tbh. But you guys will find the right solution while I'm asleep. Just ask ravenvii!
The unfortunate thing is that I secretly wanted to swap QoS power with xxx today. Thought it was a good enough plan and entertaining too. Damn zombies.
Hm, not sure DP. No problem for me in showing off with my astonishing swapping technique but would be kind of stupid to eventually lose the guard(ing) ability that way while ss really wasn't infected.
Lynching/killing should be in this order twietee, mo and then ss. Not sure how we can argue around that tbh. But you guys will find the right solution while I'm asleep. Just ask ravenvii!
yea there are a lot of combinations.
but if SS is not infected, she becomes an obvious night target as soon as the wolf in the 3 is found out.
if she is infected, then it would be good to take back the guarding power from the wolves
----------
Hm, not sure DP. No problem for me in showing off with my astonishing swapping technique but would be kind of stupid to eventually lose the guard(ing) ability that way while ss really wasn't infected.
Lynching/killing should be in this order twietee, mo and then ss. Not sure how we can argue around that tbh. But you guys will find the right solution while I'm asleep. Just ask ravenvii!
The unfortunate thing is that I secretly wanted to swap QoS power with xxx today. Thought it was a good enough plan and entertaining too. Damn zombies.
that would have been a good plan. In hindsight, you should have done it last night right after plutoniius was confirmed a wolfie. might have saved her, too, if you did it publicly.
she might still come back, or her power might.
Yep. Toin coss.
----------
Alright. Watch out, I'm swapping. What could possible go wrong? You just sit back and watch the show. Not.
the problem is that your power is so awesomely great that only the people swapped will notice, and even that, only after ChrmJenkins has time to tell them!
Tbh, I was convinced she'd be save today
But yea, thought about it. Even had my little innocent post prepared that would have told her it was me, so she wouldn't have necessarily voted for me afterwards. In hindsight though...
----------
Should I start an argument with our gg whether those powers swapped have to be from players still alive or living dead at least? Better not.
Tbh, I was convinced she'd be save today
But yea, thought about it. Even had my little innocent post prepared that would have told her it was me, so she wouldn't have necessarily voted for me afterwards. In hindsight though...
eh, in hindsight i would have put a few grands on germany destroying brazil by 6+ goals. i am sure i would have gotten decent odds
you can ask.
eh, in hindsight i would have put a few grands on germany destroying brazil by 6+ goals. i am sure i would have gotten decent odds
In hindsight I just wouldn't have swapped - what could possibly go wrong? A lot, if you ask me..
----------
Too late.
If I would be gg I think I wouldn't play that way but for future games chrmjenkins could clarify if he likes. Sorry, much too late for me now. *exit twietee*
Woah!!!! I'm not sure if I understand the situation correctly, but I do agree with the order from twietee : Twietee, Moyank, SS.
So Twietee "swapped" 2 powers SS or Moyank to another person, surely SS since she said she's the guard.
And anyway, if she's not the guard, the person who received the power will know if she's really the guard, or not. But if she's the guard, that person should stay silent right ? So that does help us to keep the guard secret ?
Like I said, much confuse here.
So Twietee "swapped" 2 powers SS or Moyank to another person, surely SS since she said she's the guard.
And anyway, if she's not the guard, the person who received the power will know if she's really the guard, or not. But if she's the guard, that person should stay silent right ? So that does help us to keep the guard secret ?
Like I said, much confuse here.
It could be both.
But, as DP ( I think ) said earlier, Pluto normally doesn't last very long in these games, and with the ability to infect coming only at night, I wouldn't put it past him to infect earlier, rather than later.
I'll say this - and I know it doesn't mean much, but I'm not infected. And I am the undertaker.