Here is what I was told yesterday:
Asked the rep how much it would cost me to upgrade given the new requirements (as of yesterday I was December eligible and spend 90 per month on my bill) final answer is I am eligible as of tomorrow to get the new iphone for the 199/299 price tag. I took the rep's name down and what city he works in in case at&t gives me trouble tomorrow. I am slightly excited but will be pumped if this is true and I can buy one tomorrow!
I am on the phone now to verify that what they told me is true, here is what they told me:
-Mr Sanchez (no I am not making that up) in El Paso told me I was eligible yesterday
-She said it's not eligible
-She said I don't fit the profile
-She stated the new requirements are for people that bought the iphone 3G in the last 90 days
-I said no, it's not, it states that it's for people who purchased the iphone 3G in Jul-Sep of last year. I also pointed out the fact that I paid full price for the iphone 3G last year and stated I wasn't trying to bilk AT&T out of 2 subsidies.
-She put me on hold and came back and said I am eligible for the 199/299 price in a very cheerful voice I might add.
-She stated to go into the physical AT&T store to purchase because Apple has reserved the right to say no, you are not eligible.
I hope this helps some people, once again here is my background
-Bought Iphone 3G on July 11th, 2008 at full price ($499)
-My monthly bills are 89.99 before tax, after discount and taxes it is around $85.
-