So then your entire basis for ripping me, is that you *think* he has insider information that he is dutifully passing along for Apple. And obviously that is a pointless debate to have since its unproveable.
And as for Analysts covering companies... yes, they usually cover them for a long while. yes they develop relationships. Yes, the companies prefer they report things that are favorable to the company. Duh. One of the first things an analyst is supposed to do is ask lots of questions. Conduct interviews with industry and company factors. Get as much information as possible. They then are supposed to give reports in which they reach conclusions. This is what they get paid to do. If all an analyst does is pass along a press release for the company... they would not be employed as an analyst for very long. The fact that you think otherwise makes me highly skeptical of you having been an “analyst for 20 years.” Unless you just mean that you work for an investment company and “analyze companies.” In that case... great... so am I! I mean, i have a business degree also, and i “analyze companies too!”