Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Kal Madda

macrumors 601
Original poster
macOS Tahoe brings many benefits in my opinion. The unified Liquid Glass design language between Apple’s platforms make picking up projects on the Mac far more pleasant. And it feels like it fits much better within Apple’s ecosystem of devices. It feels congruent and consistent with Apple’s other platforms.

The Liquid Glass design also looks better and cleaner than the prior design in my opinion. It adds a bit of depth, but doesn’t go to far towards skeuomorphism. It strikes a perfect balance in my opinion of adding some depth and character (dare I say fun?) to the system, without overdoing it.

Beyond aesthetics, there are two primary practical benefits of the Liquid Glass UI that I find useful. One, app UIs tend to feel less distracting, and it feels like there’s less between me and the content I’m working on. I already thought before that Pages’ UI was more minimalist than Microsoft Word, and I found it less distracting. But the Liquid Glass UI makes that even better. It helps for me to focus more on my writing without distraction. Same with other apps, like Pixelmator Pro. 👍🏻.

1770470203931.png


This next screenshot of Pixelmator Pro is from my iPad, I don’t have any screenshots on hand from my Mac, I may replace this or add one from the Mac later. But the UI is nearly identical, and Liquid Glass has the same effect. The UI feels less intrusive and it isn’t as distracting to me as the UI in other photo editing apps that use solid color toolbars and buttons everywhere. It feels less cluttered and distracting.

1770470423228.png


And here’s a screenshot from Pixelmator Pro on the Mac. It’s so much less distracting than other app UIs like the UI for Affinity. 👍🏻. It feels less like I’m fighting with the UI to work on my content, and more like it’s working with me, and staying as out of the way as possible. It’s far less distracting to me than the UI of other photo editing apps like Affinity, where UI buttons and elements fight for my attention. 👍🏻

1770483026821.png


The other primary practical benefit of Liquid Glass I find helpful is that App UIs tend to be more unified with the new design. So if I pick up a project on my Mac Mini in Pages or Notes, or just about any of Apple’s system apps, the experience feels more consistent than it used to. The UI looks more consistent, which makes it far easier for me to pick up a project without it feeling jarring. This is also great for creatives who have a “flow” or “groove” who don’t want it disrupted by hitting into a ton of UI differences between the same apps. Pixelmator Pro is another great example of this. Moving projects between the iPad and Mac feels nearly seamless, as both share nearly identical UI designs.

The Spotlight enhancements are also quite useful, though I do miss the Launchpad. Still, the new Apps page works fine for most, and there are third-party alternative apps that add a Launchpad-like option back, and even a layout like the App Library on iOS and iPadOS! I would have rather Apple just snagged the App Library from iOS and iPadOS rather than this separate Apps page design, but it’s a minor thing overall.

And the Phone app is a very handy addition. It is so much nicer than the old FaceTime voice call method. And my most used custom Siri Shortcut now works on the iPad and Mac along with my iPhone! It’s a shortcut I created called “Call Favorites” that gives me a list of select contacts I’ve added into it, and tapping on one from the list calls that contact. That’s super handy when I just need to contact someone quick. 👍🏻

Live Activities are also really good on macOS. I’m glad to see them included on macOS.

In so many ways, I think Tahoe has struck a great balance of incorporating more consistent design and features into macOS. I feel a few more changes in subsequent updates, and macOS will actually feel more modern and like the rest of Apple’s lineup! 🙂👍🏻

I welcome others to share their thoughts and opinions as well. My goal is for this to be a place where we can discuss and highlight the merits of macOS Tahoe and the new Liquid Glass design. That said, I also welcome dissenting views. All I ask is that people please keep things civil and respectful. 🙂👍🏻
 
Last edited:
Another change I really like is the new Control Center design. 👍🏻 It’s much nicer with the customization options. That was one of my absolute favorite iOS and iPadOS 18 features. It’s nice to be able to create a custom page for me to pin my Siri Shortcuts. I intend to take some more time to add more of them into my Control Center, but I’ve placed some into it so far. One of my most used custom Siri Shortcuts, “Call Favorites”, gives me a popup with phone contacts I need to call often for fast access. I have this shortcut enabled on my iPhone Lock Screen and use it all the time. It didn’t used to work on my Mac before Tahoe, and it was a real bummer, because there were so many times it would have come in handy. But now that Tahoe supports the Phone app, the shortcut works, and I can use it to make a quick call when I’m working at the Mac! I also really like this on my iPad, as I use my iPad as my laptop/primary computer, and it’s really handy to not have to juggle my iPad and my iPhone when I need to make a quick call. 👍🏻

1770413569251.png


And the main Control Center is far more congruent with the rest of the platforms, though I would like them to make the display brightness and volume sliders the same.

1770413635360.jpeg


Note, I have jumbled some text to protect my private info. 👍🏻
 
Last edited:
Oh, and I love the new app icon designs! 👍🏻. They look much nicer, and are consistent across the platforms now. This just makes so much sense. Same app icon for the same app on all the platforms. The only exception to this is the Finder icon, which still doesn’t clearly communicate the purpose of the app with the weird smiley face. I hope Apple will rebrand Finder as Files and replace the current app icon with the folder icon for Files. That would make things much nicer, especially for newcomers unfamiliar with the platform, as the folder icon actually communicates the purpose of the app. 👍🏻

But yeah, I would consider that another benefit of macOS Tahoe. 👍🏻
 
This thread was likely started to deflect attention from current discussions regarding Liquid Glass.

Which is odd, because I haven’t read many, if any, opinions of Tahoe’s functions being poor: they seem well regarded.

The divided opinions are regarding Liquid Glass. So I’m not sure what the point of this thread is when reviews already exist and no one is denying the usefulness of Control Centre et al.
 
This thread was likely started to deflect attention from current discussions regarding Liquid Glass.
Wrong, it was started at the suggestion of someone on your side of the debate…
Which is odd, because I haven’t read many, if any, opinions of Tahoe’s functions being poor: they seem well regarded.

The divided opinions are regarding Liquid Glass. So I’m not sure what the point of this thread is when reviews already exist and no one is denying the usefulness of Control Centre et al.
Well, I am sharing some of my favorite aspects of macOS Tahoe, which includes Liquid Glass… Again, at the suggestion of someone on your side of the debate… 🤷🏼‍♂️

I welcome discussion here, I just ask people keep things civil, and are respectful. 🙂👍🏻
 
Personally, I love the Liquid Glass design. It feels like less is getting between me and the content I’m creating or working on. And it feels modern and sleek too. I really enjoy it.

A great example of this is Pages. The app UI already felt more minimalist than Microsoft Word, which I always found to be a welcome change for focus on my writing. But the new design is even nicer, with the semi-transparent buttons feeling less in the way than the old solid color bar.

And another benefit is that the app UIs are more similar across platforms. This is really nice when you’re picking up a project on the Mac or vice versa. Things are far more consistent and congruent across Apple’s devices. Some things are still different, and some differences make sense. But everything feels so much smoother when moving between devices. There’s far less points of friction when moving between Apple’s devices, which just makes a lot of sense given Apple’s continuity efforts.
 
Oh, and I love the new app icon designs! 👍🏻. They look much nicer, and are consistent across the platforms now. This just makes so much sense. Same app icon for the same app on all the platforms. The only exception to this is the Finder icon, which still doesn’t clearly communicate the purpose of the app with the weird smiley face. I hope Apple will rebrand Finder as Files and replace the current app icon with the folder icon for Files. That would make things much nicer, especially for newcomers unfamiliar with the platform, as the folder icon actually communicates the purpose of the app. 👍🏻

But yeah, I would consider that another benefit of macOS Tahoe. 👍🏻
Interesting discussion. My one point is that I do really want them to keep the smiley face, and the Finder name. Its iconic. Follows classic design language. Anchors so much of the MacOS heritage and feel. People make stuffed pillows and toys that look like the Finder icon. It is universally loved. Whereas "Files" is generic and lacks character, and nobody is ever going to make a pillow out of it.
 
Interesting discussion. My one point is that I do really want them to keep the smiley face, and the Finder name. Its iconic. Follows classic design language. Anchors so much of the MacOS heritage and feel. People make stuffed pillows and toys that look like the Finder icon. It is universally loved. Whereas "Files" is generic and lacks character, and nobody is ever going to make a pillow out of it.
Maybe they could make it a theming option? Set the folder icon by default, and have an option to use the smiley face? Or maybe they could place the smiley face on a folder? It’s just that it doesn’t communicate the app’s purpose. Or maybe it could be incorporated elsewhere in the system where it could make more sense. Like maybe that could be the face of Siri.

I understand people have nostalgia associated with it, and so I’m not saying it has to be completely removed from macOS. It’s just I’ve had far too many people ask me “where’s the file manager” when they pick up a Mac for the first time. 🙂👍🏻. So I guess I’m just looking at it from that perspective. 👍🏻

Interestingly, the smiley face didn’t originally signify the Mac’s file manager, it was a startup animation when turning on the Mac. They could bring that back in a modernized way, and make the file manager icon the Files folder icon. 🙂👍🏻. Or perhaps another compromise. 👍🏻
 
Nice to see some folks like Tahoe. I have found that Apple typically gets out of beta at about the X.3 version of a Mac OS, so maybe I will jump in to 26.3.

It sucks that Apple treats X.0 users as beta testers, because buyers of new devices are forced to use the beta-level X.0 OS. Craig Federighi may think that routine is cute and he is fooling users, but it just makes me (a fanboi) strongly dislike him, even though I have never met him.
 
Maybe they could make it a theming option? Set the folder icon by default, and have an option to use the smiley face? Or maybe they could place the smiley face on a folder? It’s just that it doesn’t communicate the app’s purpose. Or maybe it could be incorporated elsewhere in the system where it could make more sense. Like maybe that could be the face of Siri.

I understand people have nostalgia associated with it, and so I’m not saying it has to be completely removed from macOS. It’s just I’ve had far too many people ask me “where’s the file manager” when they pick up a Mac for the first time. 🙂👍🏻. So I guess I’m just looking at it from that perspective. 👍🏻

Interestingly, the smiley face didn’t originally signify the Mac’s file manager, it was a startup animation when turning on the Mac. They could bring that back in a modernized way, and make the file manager icon the Files folder icon. 🙂👍🏻. Or perhaps another compromise. 👍🏻
I understand you but I just think you're attempting to fix a non problem. It takes less than 10 seconds to figure out what Finder is, and how it works. It's been around since 10.1. That's a very long time. It would cause more confusion to get rid of it, at this stage. And again, people do really like it. It's part of the Mac user identity.
 
Nice to see some folks like Tahoe. I have found that Apple typically gets out of beta at about the X.3 version of a Mac OS, so maybe I will jump in to 26.3.
Yeah, I think you’ll like it. 🙂👍🏻
It sucks that Apple treats X.0 users as beta testers, because buyers of new devices are forced to use the beta-level X.0 OS. Craig Federighi may think that routine is cute and he is fooling users, but it just makes me (a fanboi) strongly dislike him, even though I have never met him.
I don’t know that I’d say that early versions are betas. 🤷🏼‍♂️. I’ve never really encountered any bugs on the early public versions like you will sometimes on the early beta versions. But to each their own, YMMV. 🙂👍🏻
 
I understand you but I just think you're attempting to fix a non problem. It takes less than 10 seconds to figure out what Finder is, and how it works. It's been around since 10.1. That's a very long time. It would cause more confusion to get rid of it, at this stage. And again, people do really like it. It's part of the Mac user identity.
Ok, though in my experience, it’s more than 10 seconds. When I first moved to the Mac, I wasted a lot of time looking through all of the apps in the Launchpad to try to find the file manager, because it certainly would use a folder icon, right? It was an exercise in frustration. Finally I googled it and was shocked that they used a smiley face to represent the file manager. It honestly ticked me off a bit. And every other person I know that’s picked up a Mac has had to do the same. I thought for sure that that app was some social app or an AI search assistant or something. And so did my friends and family when they picked up a Mac for the first time.

But to each their own. I understand why you feel nostalgia for it, I just think it can be frustrating for newcomers. I know it was for me. 🙂👍🏻
 
Ok, though in my experience, it’s more than 10 seconds. When I first moved to the Mac, I wasted a lot of time looking through all of the apps in the Launchpad to try to find the file manager, because it certainly would use a folder icon, right? It was an exercise in frustration. Finally I googled it and was shocked that they used a smiley face to represent the file manager. It honestly ticked me off a bit. And every other person I know that’s picked up a Mac has had to do the same. I thought for sure that that app was some social app or an AI search assistant or something. And so did my friends and family when they picked up a Mac for the first time.

But to each their own. I understand why you feel nostalgia for it, I just think it can be frustrating for newcomers. I know it was for me. 🙂👍🏻
I was a newcomer once too. It took a minute or two. Now, 20+ years later, those minutes count for a trivial amount of the overall time I've been a Mac user. So, again, it's absolutely a non problem. In the scale of issues faced by those making the transition to a Mac, it's a very very trivial problem. A much bigger issue faced by newcomers is the single mouse button, for example. I remember my dad struggling much more with that than the Finder, when he switched. Should we bend to PC transitioners on that too? All these changes have costs in terms of both of function and identity/brand.
 
I was a newcomer once too. It took a minute or two. Now, 20+ years later, those minutes count for a trivial amount of the overall time I've been a Mac user. So, again, it's absolutely a non problem. In the scale of issues faced by those making the transition to a Mac, it's a very very trivial problem. A much bigger issue faced by newcomers is the single mouse button, for example. I remember my dad struggling much more with that than the Finder, when he switched. Should we bend to PC transitioners on that too? All these changes have costs in terms of both of function and identity/brand.
So irritating how the mighty mouse defaults to single button. At one college I attended it was something to change every single time you log in. There went any reason to use the lab computer instead of my MBP. The other lab has ASD, much better when paired with my machine than using old iMac lab.
 
I was a newcomer once too. It took a minute or two. Now, 20+ years later, those minutes count for a trivial amount of the overall time I've been a Mac user. So, again, it's absolutely a non problem. In the scale of issues faced by those making the transition to a Mac, it's a very very trivial problem. A much bigger issue faced by newcomers is the single mouse button, for example. I remember my dad struggling much more with that than the Finder, when he switched. Should we bend to PC transitioners on that too? All these changes have costs in terms of both of function and identity/brand.
Like I said, I just think it would be nice, that’s all. I don’t think it’s the biggest struggle a newcomer may face, but I just do think it would be nice. 👍🏻. And I’m not suggesting everything be done to cater to PC transitioners. It’s not just a problem for PC transitioners either, because the iPhone and iPad use Files with a folder icon. So anyone who first owned an iPhone or iPad before a Mac (a lot of people these days), it can be confusing. But as I said, I don’t think it’s the worst thing ever. I just think it doesn’t clearly communicate the purpose of the app, and so I think it would be better to use the smiley face elsewhere where it makes more sense. 🙂👍🏻

But as I said, to each their own. 🙂👍🏻
 
Nice to see some folks like Tahoe. I have found that Apple typically gets out of beta at about the X.3 version of a Mac OS, so maybe I will jump in to 26.3.

It sucks that Apple treats X.0 users as beta testers, because buyers of new devices are forced to use the beta-level X.0 OS. Craig Federighi may think that routine is cute and he is fooling users, but it just makes me (a fanboi) strongly dislike him, even though I have never met him.
I don’t get this. I’ve upgraded macOS when the public betas dropped for both Sequoia and Tahoe. Sequoia had a few bugs that I reported, but Tahoe was smooth sailing all the way.
 
Wrong, it was started at the suggestion of someone on your side of the debate…

Well, I am sharing some of my favorite aspects of macOS Tahoe, which includes Liquid Glass… Again, at the suggestion of someone on your side of the debate… 🤷🏼‍♂️

I welcome discussion here, I just ask people keep things civil, and are respectful. 🙂👍🏻
Mea culpa. I suggested that creating a constructive discussion about the pros of Tahoe would be better than continuing endless and unproductive arguments based mainly on LG. The other discussions can thus continue without casualties. 😂

There are the new developments:


Has anyone, for example, already explored spotlight actions? Do you have examples of productive ways to implement them in your workflow?
 
  • Like
Reactions: maxoakland
While I was hoping for a resurrection of the Aqua motif, I do think Liquid Glass brings a freshness to the flat stale design that predated it.

With all of the doom and gloom, I was pleasantly surprised at how well macos 26, ios26, and ipados 26 all worked.

It was at this point I realized that much of the interactions here in MR resembled more of an echo chamber where the same complaints were being offered and how horrible LG is. I get its not everyone's cup of tea but I have no issues with it.

some of the negativity is rather humorous, there's a thread where one member was threatening to leave the mac platform because he was so upset at the curvature of the corners. Don't get me wrong, a bad UI that prevents you from working should give someone pause about sticking with the UI, but corners? Windows 8 faced this issue, but it was due to the fact that people on laptops/desktops were treated like second class citizens and that UI made it harder for people to work. Tahoe is no where near that level, and with the recent updates apple has dialed the design in making it more polished and refined.

One of the requirements I want in an operating system is not to get in the way, let me work the way I want too. Tahoe does not get in the way.
 
No offence to the OP but you said you were a designer yourself but you never really offer any real reason why you like Tahoe or Liquid Glass despite posting many times. As a designer you should be able to offer critiques on how and why something does or doesn't appeal to you. In this thread alone your only offering is 'it's nice'. When challenged on why you think circles were modern in another thread the response was pretty much 'I like circles'. So this thread is pretty pointless as it's basically saying you think 'Liquid Glass is nice' which we already know. Offer up your reasoning on WHY you think its better will probably get you some more engagement and less hostile responses in general. 🙂
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.