Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Why do u think Apple is trending toward a notchless X? Because I'm not alone.

I'll answer your question with a question - why do you think Android is trending toward the notch, with Google including the notch support in the upcoming P version?

Just to be clear, I am not a fan of the notch, but it's certainly better than the alternative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tooloud10
I'll answer your question with a question - why do you think Android is trending toward the notch, with Google including the notch support in the upcoming P version?

Just to be clear, I am not a fan of the notch, but it's certainly better than the alternative.
Because all the Chinese OEM phone manufactures always follow the worse trends Apple comes with.
 
a better way to get more space is not just make it smaller, but to remove it.

Perhaps by making it smaller, most won't notice its there *shrugs* ... They have probably now accepted it look awful, so they gotta do something right?

So, why not shrink it?
 
I'd love to bet with you on that. But it would be unfair to you.
[doublepost=1520444266][/doublepost]
No more selfies? Fat chance. Maybe if they put displays on both sides of the phone, so you can use the 'rear' camera for selfies.
[doublepost=1520444361][/doublepost]
Sure, and there will be technology to take pictures of something behind a wall.

The tech already exists, there are patents. It’s just a matter of getting it right. I guess you’re an expert though so I’ll defer to you.
 
a new "amateurish" technology that will take a long time to improve

Your post actually makes more sense now. Hence, It’s because you don’t approve of this technology versus something that has actual functionality. Your opinion isn’t fact, it’s anecdotal.

For the record, anything technology related over the course of its lifespan is always an improvement through course if it’s existence. I can make that same argument about anything technology related I own or anything it’s manufactured on a level where it continues to refine on an annual basis.
 
How is the notch affecting your video content?

Hardly noticeable.

iphone-x-video-modes.gif
 
I wonder if everyone on here who supports and claims to like the notch, will be refusing to buy the 2019 onwards iPhones as they no longer have this feature...?! ;-)
For them, Joni will work out pseudo-notch kits made of plastomere ($200) or premium black anodised aluminum ($600)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: BMcCoy
I'm going to hold out for 2019. Getting ready to test the Android waters with the Nokia 7 Plus or the Samsung 9+.
 
People, don't get your hopes up. The only reason we are dealing with notches and FaceID is because Apple failed at incorporating the touch ID behind the screen. Talking now about incorporating FaceID behind the screen is crazy talk, it won't happen anytime soon.

I'd rather get TouchID behind the screen than FaceID... I hate phones with fingerprint reader on the back. Big no no.

Rocking an iPhone SE ATM and waiting for a similar form factor, bezeless and with FaceID under the screen, hopefully from Apple.
 
Are you saying that Google is a Chinese OEM phone manufacturer?
Google didn't make any phone until now with a notch did they? ;)
[doublepost=1520456580][/doublepost]
Your post actually makes more sense now. Hence, It’s because you don’t approve of this technology versus something that has actual functionality. Your opinion isn’t fact, it’s anecdotal.

For the record, anything technology related over the course of its lifespan is always an improvement through course if it’s existence. I can make that same argument about anything technology related I own or anything it’s manufactured on a level where it continues to refine on an annual basis.
My point stands, touch id was reliable not the same with faceid, it will improve? Sure but we are talking about what we have in the present not about what's happening for the future of technology.
 
There are many people who apparently don't like the notch, and it veered those same people from buying it. Put a notch on every display you own, and let me know if it obstructs your visibility of the display. Have you ever wondered why pretty much every display is either Square (4:3, old display tech) or rectangular (16:9/18:9/21:9, etc), with no notches?

I didn't say that no one dislikes the notch - I said it's silly to dismiss the iPhone X because of it. Yes, it isn't the ideal situation. But it does a good job of maximizing the screen real estate in the form factor with the technology limitations. There was already a status bar there on other iPhones making that space unusable most of the time anyway.

Again, I would prefer no notch. But it's a non-factor right now, and I much prefer the notch to the large top and bottom bezel. I'd also dislike a notch on something like an iPad or MacBook, where the bezel doesn't sacrifice as much for size.
[doublepost=1520456810][/doublepost]
It's a design choice and disliking the design of a phone is one of the most influenciable things when you are going to waste your money on it.

It's partially a design choice largely driven by technology limitations. When it comes to actually using the phone, its hardly noticeable, and completely disappears if the screen is off. Hence why I think its silly to make it a deciding factor about purchasing a phone.


Too expensive? Great, totally understand. Prefer Android? Same. Don't want to give up TouchID? Well, I'll disagree with you and talk about how FaceID is great, but I understand skipping the X because of that. But the notch? That's a silly thing to base a purchase decision on.
 
I didn't say that no one dislikes the notch - I said it's silly to dismiss the iPhone X because of it. Yes, it isn't the ideal situation. But it does a good job of maximizing the screen real estate in the form factor with the technology limitations. There was already a status bar there on other iPhones making that space unusable most of the time anyway.

Again, I would prefer no notch. But it's a non-factor right now, and I much prefer the notch to the large top and bottom bezel. I'd also dislike a notch on something like an iPad or MacBook, where the bezel doesn't sacrifice as much for size.
[doublepost=1520456810][/doublepost]

It's partially a design choice largely driven by technology limitations. When it comes to actually using the phone, its hardly noticeable, and completely disappears if the screen is off. Hence why I think its silly to make it a deciding factor about purchasing a phone.


Too expensive? Great, totally understand. Prefer Android? Same. Don't want to give up TouchID? Well, I'll disagree with you and talk about how FaceID is great, but I understand skipping the X because of that. But the notch? That's a silly thing to base a purchase decision on.
So by your point this would be totally okay to you?
24.jpg

[doublepost=1520457770][/doublepost]
Google still hasn't made a phone with a notch. They did, however, release an operating system with notch support. In fact, the article is right on the front page of MacRumors.

https://www.macrumors.com/2018/03/07/android-p-iphone-x-style-notches/
Google hasn't even released anything, they are planning to add "Notch" support in the next Android P for the future Android OEM's who are "embracing" the Nocth which are mostly chinese.
 
Google hasn't even released anything, they are planning to add "Notch" support in the next Android P for the future Android OEM's who are "embracing" the Nocth which are mostly chinese.

LG is probably the most high profile OEM that will be using the notch in their upcoming flagship and they are Korean. Sure, most Android OEMs (it's been what, 2-3 of them?) who are "embracing" the notch may be Chinese, but wouldn't it be easier to allow them to skin their version of Android to fit the notch, instead of supporting it via AOSP? Unless, that is, Google itself will be supporting the notch in the next Pixel?
 
LG is probably the most high profile OEM that will be using the notch in their upcoming flagship and they are Korean. Sure, most Android OEMs (it's been what, 2-3 of them?) who are "embracing" the notch may be Chinese, but wouldn't it be easier to allow them to skin their version of Android to fit the notch, instead of supporting it via AOSP? Unless, that is, Google itself will be supporting the notch in the next Pixel?
Proof that LG will be using the notch in their upcoming flagships? Let me guess, you work at LG?
The LG G7 pictures that you may have seen were only rumours not the final design.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.