I'm not sure why those mock ups cut some off the bottom too. It's not necessary to take care of the notch, and it makes the solution on the right look not as good because the screen looks much smaller with portions missing on the top and bottom
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Notch Solution
- Thread starter Blazinbell
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I'm not sure why those mock ups cut some off the bottom too. It's not necessary to take care of the notch, and it makes the solution on the right look not as good because the screen looks much smaller with portions missing on the top and bottom
Thanks for the honest answer. If Apple were creating a display for the NY Museum of Modern Art then they probably would have made a different design decision than a electronics device for the masses.
I must be one of the few that really like the notch. Maybe I watched too much Transformers when I was a kid.
Guys, chill. The devs are already on it.
https://twitter.com/vojtastavik/status/907911237983449088
https://twitter.com/ZevEisenberg/status/908148886363103232
https://twitter.com/vojtastavik/status/907911237983449088
https://twitter.com/ZevEisenberg/status/908148886363103232
I hate calling Steve back from the grave but he was the one that understood what I'm saying. He understood angles and making things even and matching.
thats what apple WAS. It hasn't been that apple for a while now. Especially with this phone.
Thats what apple was known for. Pleasing design. They have a huge design team that makes things look "pretty" and "right" I don't know how it went this far...
This isn't some knock off company
It is a design choice that Apple made and for my personally I am fine with it. If everyone had the same taste in design life would be pretty boring. For those that do not care for it, let Apple know by NOT opening your wallet to buy it.
I'm mostly playing devil's advocate here, I agree with what you are saying. That being said I have no self control and will probably buy it anyway.
You took the words right out of my mouth!...I have no self control and will probably buy it anyway.
This thread is about solutions for the notch. Not about people repeating themselves over and over about how they are personally fine with the notch, as if their personal opinion rebuts all the legitimate criticism for it (e.g. Functional limitations wherein content is blocked in full screen).
It is not simply a matter of "don't buy it if you don't like it." Apple won't get that message. That is the same type of thing nationalists say to people who criticize aspects of a country: "if you don't like it, get out/go home." And I'll bet you that the same psychological underpinnings of that nationalism are the same as those of fanboyism.
I for one am an Apple loyalist. I'm committed to their ecosystem, and own the iPhone, iPad, MacBook Pro, AirPods, etc.
It is not simply a matter of "don't buy it if you don't like it." Apple won't get that message. That is the same type of thing nationalists say to people who criticize aspects of a country: "if you don't like it, get out/go home." And I'll bet you that the same psychological underpinnings of that nationalism are the same as those of fanboyism.
I for one am an Apple loyalist. I'm committed to their ecosystem, and own the iPhone, iPad, MacBook Pro, AirPods, etc.
Someone's personal opinion that they are fine with the notch adds nothing new to the discussion of "solutions for the notch". This is not a thread/poll asking whether or not people like the notch.
Not only has it already been said, but we all know some people are fine with it. It adds nothing to the discussion.
I will help everyone on that side: some people are fine with the notch and don't think any solution needs to be implemented.
Hopefully now we don't need 50 more people repeating the same thing clogging up the thread.
I didn't mean with people in this thread I meant how will peoples voice get heard from apple about their design choice if people just don't buy it
Some people dig ugly chicks. The notch is ugly...
I think you may be mixing me up with someone else. Because we seem to be agreeing on a lot of points.
I agree: not buying the iPhone X will not get any message to Apple.
Why? Because they will sell out regardless if you, me, or everyone in this thread don't buy it.
Again, it's the same rhetoric as "if you don't like this country, then go home" "if you don't like the product, don't buy it."
It's being a fanboy.
Ironically, what the aim of this thread is, is to discuss a solution to the notch. And a lot of people keep trying to rebut that with their opinion that the notch doesn't bother them.
I think what many of us want are good mockups/ideas that hopefully make their way to Apple somehow at the best, and at the worst just indulge our fantasies.
I like the way it looks in portrait mode. It just bothers me in landscape mode because of the lack of symmetry. That lack of symmetry doesn't make sense in landscape because there's no reason for it, unlike in portrait mode.
the same reason why iPhones on the front have always looked symmetrical. Why the s8/notes look symmetrical on the front too. To make it even on bottom and top instead of just a top gap
The notch is a great example of the internet freaking out over a non-issue. Ten minutes in, you'll have forgotten what the fuss was about. Photos and video aren't impacted by the notch at all unless you expand them to the point you're cropping the whole thing, which you wouldn't do.
I don't know if you guys have seen this but this is the guideline to developers about how to program for the notch
https://developer.apple.com/ios/human-interface-guidelines/overview/iphone-x/
https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/fall2017/801/
Basically, when displaying content, there is a safe area that is meant for content which is defined below.
They did kind of caution against doing something like this because it is "less immersive" makes the viewing area seem smaller when you get rid of the notch that way.
https://developer.apple.com/ios/human-interface-guidelines/overview/iphone-x/
https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/fall2017/801/
Basically, when displaying content, there is a safe area that is meant for content which is defined below.
They did kind of caution against doing something like this because it is "less immersive" makes the viewing area seem smaller when you get rid of the notch that way.
Last edited by a moderator:
]so developers are going to find a solution for something intentional on Apple’s part. Sigh. The world gets dumber every day. Good luck with any of these solutions passing App Store review.Guys, chill. The devs are already on it.
https://twitter.com/vojtastavik/status/907911237983449088
https://twitter.com/ZevEisenberg/status/908148886363103232
[doublepost=1505408582][/doublepost]
Buy an 8. Has the latest tech inside with no notch.
Cut your loss and look at open solutions. From the industry I come from, it's called vendor lock-in. Big webscale companies are never vendor locked because they know they'll have to bendover.
Which means replace hardware bezels with software bezels or make the phone look like a G6 or an S8. And then everyone can come here and complain about how Apple is ripping off LG and Samsung.