When you boil it down, here is the reason why some of us (And I do stress SOME of us) are hot and bothered about what Lion brings. Mind, I have not and will not upgrade my Pro or my iMac to Lion. I just bought the 2011 Air that had it installed, and this is a clean install. I can only imagine the chaos with my existing computers. Some of you Jobsians are so busy defending what Apple has done that you're not stopping to think...really think...about what you're saying. This is common with Apple overfans...doesn't matter what Jobs tries to change, you convince yourself that it's the right thing because it's change. Even if said change is just not necessary. "Just don't use it!!!" is not a valid answer. Here's why.
- LaunchPad: What an absolute cluster. If this isn't proof that this OS is destined for a tablet in the future I don't know what is. I might not mind it so much if it weren't for the fact that the Applications folder serves the exact same purpose when added to the Dock. This is an example of a useless feature...something added for the hell of it when it wasn't needed.
- Mission Control: Those who say it's only a Spaces replacement, that's just not true. It's an unholy hybrid of Spaces and Exposé, quite clearly. It feels like a step in the right direction, but the current implementation has absolutely inane approaches. Why don't minimized apps show up? Why do the top Desktop boxes only show the name when you have 5 or less, otherwise you have to hover over them? Why can't you do your own naming of Desktops if the app doesn't support it in full screen (i.e. Firefox)? Why are you forced to go full screen to get law and order with the windows (see screenshot above for the chaos)?
- Gestures are all over the place. If the true intent is to blend iOS and Mac OS then why did they remove pinch to zoom in Finder? Seems to me they would have left that in there since it is an iOS-like feature. AN example of an illogical change.
- Why is it when you have your Dock on the left or the right, it doesn't show up in full screen mode at all? You're forced to have it on the bottom. It's the same damn Dock, why is it different depending on where it is? Also, I did notice when it was on the bottom, sometimes it doesn't respond when you go to the bottom and hover, you have to do it repeatedly for it to show up. Seems like an overall halfassed implementation to me.
- The default Finder window - MY GOD, what was Apple thinking? "All My Files" is a disaster. No way to get to the HD, as though Apple wants the user to not care about their HD and just rely on shortcuts to get to "common" places. What about non-common places? I don't store my VMs in my folder, I store it at the root, because they need to be accessible to all users without sharing. In Apple's world, I should ignore this? I spent way too much time in the Finder Preferences fixing this chaos.
- During my flight home, I ran across websites that saw Lion's Safari as a mobile browser and they refused to let me redirect to a desktop page. Now, that might have been a fluke of the mobile broadband that GoGo uses; not sure. But it was unnerving. Even my phone didn't do that.
Working in technology as I do I appreciate all-too-well what Apple wants. They want more customers. I get it. The problem is they don't need to do hybrid unholy pairings. They've got iOS; keep it for the iPhone, iPad, iPod Touch. They've got Mac OS; keep it for MacBook Pro, MacBook Air, Mac Mini, iMac, and whatever server they decide to carry. There is NOTHING wrong with having two operating systems, one for each type of device. If you've got Grandma who doesn't understand a desktop OS then don't get her one; get her an iPad. If you've got people like me who develop and do hard coding then I don't expect to see dumbed-down interfaces in my OS. That's just how I see it. Doesn't matter that "you don't have to use them!!!!11!" I don't want them there. Fix what's broken in Mac OS.
So far the only real improvement with Lion over Snow Leopard has been the ability to indiscriminately resize windows from any corner. One refinement is NOT good.
I understand your points, but i still think that "if you don't like it, don't use it" is a valid answer. Unless the app is actually stopping you from being productive, it's just an added bonus.
1) LaunchPad: Agreed, and as long as the MacBook Air/iPad mutant has OS X, i think it'll be fabulous. True there is an Application folder right there by default, and Launchpad is just there as an alternative. Don't want to use it? Remove it from the dock and disable the gesture for it.
Personally, Launchpad has replaced the Application folder for me. I use BTT to set up a custom quick gesture to open up Launchpad wherever i am, and I can launch any app i want. Much more productive than the Application folder.
And when i'm in a rush, i just Spotlight the app.
By default Apple put iMovie on my dock. And use the app once in a blue moon. So i just removed it from my dock. No biggie.
2) Mission Control: It definitely is a step in the right direction. Maybe you can send them feedback to show minimized apps somewhere, to let you edit Desktop names, etc. I don't believe you have to go to fullscreen mode to get law and order of desktops, i believe it is a glitch. I'm sure we'll see numerous fixes later on, this is still an x.0 upgrade.
The pics Fraaaa posted is a great reason as to why i love Mission Control. I usually have so many apps open on my Mac, and i always have to look around for the right one in Expose, it becomes a huge pain and affects productivity. I said to myself before "if only there was a way to group all of them by apps" and voila, Mission Control is the answer.
3) Gestures: I can't speak much about this because i disabled most of the Apple gestures and use BTT to set up my own ones. I highly recommend the app to anyone who is having issues with gestures! Pinch to zoom in Finder made it tricky for people who were scrolling with 2 fingers, i guess that's why they removed it.
4) Full Screen mode: I don't use the dock in full screen mode. If I have to open an App, i just use Launchpad. Ahhh see where Apple is going with this? If i have to use Finder, i just use the 3 finger swipe gesture and go to the next Desktop.
5) Finder window: Agreed. How does one change this?
6) That's probably your Wi-Fi's issue.