Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
How can you go through 5 of them. My friend told me that the second time he's trying to exchange for one in an Apple store, the attendant told him: ok, we can open one for you, but this is the last one we can give you for free exchange.

i assume he returned it and bought another one. A bit pathetic imo, no wonder they come up with stricter rules regarding the returning policy


its not a 30.000$ car, its just an iPad. If u still see issues on your 6th iPad, maybe the device just isnt for u ^^
 
It's going to be fun and games when my 64GB WiFi and "Super Fast 3G" model arrives from Apple. Every new iPad I've looked at, be it in the Apple Store in Glasgow, the local Tesco Extra store, or the 3 store, has looked fantastic.

Oh well, 2 to 3 weeks to go.

Why didnt u buy it straight from Apple store?
 
Why didnt u buy it straight from Apple store?

Got it in conjunction with my work, they order it for you from Apple, and my employer deducts my salary directly over a selected period of months. So it'll be a bulk order from Apple.com, but sent out to our homes individually.
 
Got it in conjunction with my work, they order it for you from Apple, and my employer deducts my salary directly over a selected period of months. So it'll be a bulk order from Apple.com, but sent out to our homes individually.

Nice! Hope you get it soon enough :)
 
How can you go through 5 of them. My friend told me that the second time he's trying to exchange for one in an Apple store, the attendant told him: ok, we can open one for you, but this is the last one we can give you for free exchange.

Tell him to stop exchanging it and just return it, then buy another. If that one is no good, return it again and buy another. Your money gets a little tied up for a few days, but it's worth not having to make genius bar appointment after appointment, and trying to convince geniuses of your issues.
 
I just picked up my iPhone 4 there, right? I held it almost level with my right eye, and began tilting it while holding it flat/horizontal. The colours, from a tight angle and side on, change. There is a slightly noticeable, more reddish tint viewing the right side of the screen, and a greenish/blue tint when viewing the left side. Front front on, it's perfect and I'd never have even looked at my iPhone 4 the way I just did had I not read this iPad thread.

Now, my 16GB iPhone 4 has a glorious screen. The whites are proper white, but my Father in Law who recently got the 8GB iPhone 4 has a very noticeable yellow tinge to his screen, but he says he prefers the "warmer tones" of his screen. Side by side, there is a huge difference, but he's not overly concerned of fussed.

I had a previous ipad that was pink and you did not have to sit there and tilt it back and forth to see the pink. I showed it to a few friends and everyone saw the pink. Straight on and slight angle, it should not be there.

The video showed extreme angle in complete darkness which of course is not a normal setting. but many people on here shows green and pink when on a normal web browser in light, straight on.
 
Tell him to stop exchanging it and just return it, then buy another. If that one is no good, return it again and buy another. Your money gets a little tied up for a few days, but it's worth not having to make genius bar appointment after appointment, and trying to convince geniuses of your issues.

I see. That should work, but my friend took another approach. He had a fight with the attendant and then the store manager for them to agree that he can exchange until he gets a perfect one. He got it after two more boxes.
 
That video is ... well, unbelievable.

Again, when there is content ON the screen it looks fine in that video. The shot of the App Store with Epoch being advertised, the whites look fine on there.

Who is going to sit with the power on, with a black screen, tilting it from side to side. I'll tilt it when there's content on the screen, so if this is such a huge issue, why doesn't the guy put content on the screen, the shift it to see if the picture becomes tinted pink or green depending on direction?

I would say with something on screen, the tint isn't even noticeable.

----------

This forum seems to be the only place where this "problem" is being discussed or "reported". Surely if the screen had a major issue, we'd have another Antennagate style media frenzy by now?

I just check my old iPad 2, it has the same pink issue if you look at it at an extreme angle... only from the opposite side of the iPad. I hold my iPad in landscape with the home button on my right side usually so I notice it more now... but my iPad 2 it's flipped... you only really see it if you're holding it landscape with the Home button the the left side. Which I almost never do.

Upon doing this too I noticed that the new iPad is a hell of a lot brighter at full brightness but not so much at 50%. Anyone else notice that 50% and lower looks really dim in comparison to the iPad 2's level of gradient?

Not saying I'm the be all end all of the matter... but I think it's a non-issue and it probably effects all iPads, so I'm satisfied with my iPad.

----------

I had a previous ipad that was pink and you did not have to sit there and tilt it back and forth to see the pink. I showed it to a few friends and everyone saw the pink. Straight on and slight angle, it should not be there.

The video showed extreme angle in complete darkness which of course is not a normal setting. but many people on here shows green and pink when on a normal web browser in light, straight on.

Ok cool... I don't have the same problem as you.
Mine was like the video and is probably fine.
 
My 16GB iPhone 4 has a glorious screen. The whites are proper white, but my Father in Law who recently got the 8GB iPhone 4 has a very noticeable yellow tinge to his screen, but he says he prefers the "warmer tones" of his screen. Side by side, there is a huge difference, but he's not overly concerned of fussed.

Why would he be? I'm betting your father-in-law has watched more more TV than he's used a computer and hasn't been subtly brainwashed over the years into thinking — wrongly — that cooler colours are correct.
 
Why would he be? I'm betting your father-in-law has watched more more TV than he's used a computer and hasn't been subtly brainwashed over the years into thinking — wrongly — that cooler colours are correct.

Nobody has been brainwashed into anything. This warmer color/cooler color BS is getting stupid now. Some old guy or any regular user isn't going to notice the color temperature on an iPad. Don't be ridiculous. There is no brainwashing going on here.
 
Why would he be? I'm betting your father-in-law has watched more more TV than he's used a computer and hasn't been subtly brainwashed over the years into thinking — wrongly — that cooler colours are correct.

It's not cooler. His screen is yellow, mine has no tint ... blue or yellow. My white's are WHITE. Best seen on the Calendar app, the bubble in the Messages app, etc.

The point being, he didn't run to the Apple store and moan about it demanding exchange after exchange.
 
I have bought almost every Apple product I own on launch and have never had an issue. Oh, and if I did that is what warranties / AmEx is for anyone who returns 5 ipads in a row before they get a "good" one is OCD and way to pretentious. It's a tool use it if it does wht you need good enough!
 
I have bought almost every Apple product I own on launch and have never had an issue. Oh, and if I did that is what warranties / AmEx is for anyone who returns 5 ipads in a row before they get a "good" one is OCD and way to pretentious. It's a tool use it if it does wht you need good enough!

Do you even know what pretentious means? What does pretense have to do with discolored iPads? So you don't return defective things directly, you just use Amex's purchase protection? And the difference is...? And since when is an iPad a tool? Speaking of tools...
 
Last edited:
A. Why do you care?

B. The people on here that spend a sad amount of time dwelling on other people's nitpickiness are no different than iPad nitpickers...and certainly no less annoying. Do you hang out on the weekends at the Best Buy customer service counter and try to talk people out of returning things? Because that's basically what you're doing now...

C. Who are you to say what I or anyone else should be happy with? Should I be happy with a broken stereo speaker because YOU can't hear out of your left ear? Should I stay at a concert that I think sucks because it's YOUR favorite band? Should I accept a pink blotchy iPad because your sensitivity to the color pink is lower than mine? Seriously, random internet guy, don't flatter yourself.

After 5 iPad 3s, all returned for various problems, I finally got one today that's acceptable. Is it perfect? No, but I am a reasonable person. I had exactly one iPad 1 and one iPad 2....both were basically perfect out of the box. No returns necessary. I'm a picky customer, but they were great.

Fact is, this time around, Apple made A LOT more iPads than last year's launch, potentially creating big QC problems, which will compound issues with an already challenging new technology in the retina display.

I'm glad you're happy with your iPad. But an increasing number of increasingly vocal people here on MR are not happy with theirs. That's why you keep seeing more and more posts about it...duh?

Apple has built their $600 billion empire on selling sleek, sexy, high quality goods. Maintaining that quality in the face of exponential popularity and massive sales is a huge challenge. I maintain they bit off a bit more than they can chew by launching the new iPad in so many countries simultaneously.

Is it any mystery that Tim Cook is a supply guy and that his first major product at Apple's helm was an exercise in pushing the supply limits rather than the typical Jobs era method of a smaller, more controlled US only launch? Is it any wonder that producing a few extra million iPads might have some effect on QC?

If the Tim Cook megalaunch is here to stay, and quality does in fact slip, and no one calls them out on it, then as many pundits predicted, Steve Jobs passing will have in fact been the beginning of the end of Apple.

Is that what you want? Because by telling people with QC complaints to effectively shut up, you are effectively calling for the downfall of Apple.

If you want to see less nitpicking posts, then ironically, it's YOU that needs to pipe down. Let people complain. When enough do, it will get noticed...first by the blogs, then by the press. Then Apple will be forced to do something about it. When they step up QC, there will be less nitpickers.

Think different.

You do a good job of exemplifying the OP's point
 
Someone here last night made a very interesting point. Apparently it is only on this forum that people are literally shouting from the roof that there is a yellow tint issue with the New iPad but had that been such a common phenomenon The Media would have Ripped Apple apart with all the reports coming from all parts of the world !

Point worth to be noted ! :rolleyes:
 
I've owned several Macs, iPods, iPhones, Apple TV, All 3 iPads, and I must day you guys really are just being OCD! Simple as that. I'm glad the OP said what I've been thinking this whole time.
 
Someone here last night made a very interesting point. Apparently it is only on this forum that people are literally shouting from the roof that there is a yellow tint issue with the New iPad but had that been such a common phenomenon The Media would have Ripped Apple apart with all the reports coming from all parts of the world !

Point worth to be noted ! :rolleyes:

Doesn't mean it isn't a problem. Case in point, there's a HUGE thread going on at Apple Discussions about another major problem, that being the crappy wifi signal strength. It's even been referred to by the media. Yet, there's hardly a whisper of it on this forum. :confused:

A point also worth noting.
 
Should I be happy with a broken stereo speaker because YOU can't hear out of your left ear?

Hahaha! I love it!
But even so there are no rules on the forum that limits us from spewing our thoughts, posively or not...
Great post!
 
If your child yells ouch from an overheated iPad that's not being nit picky. That's a damn hot iPad. If you don't mind paying hundreds of dollars of a machine that won't detect any wifi signals, have a volume button that doesn't work, screen is yellow, I won't list all the issues i've had with it as it would be to long and borring but this isn't being nit picky. This iPad launch has been riddled with defects for me personally.

LOL

Got Drama?

You are being nit picky. Period. Yes, every single iPad3 has those problems you listed....

If you truly have a defective device then return/exchange.

The iPad3 is for the vast majority of millions of owners, pretty much flawless.

Mine is perfect.

Don't be so dramatic and nit picky....and relax a little. The sky aint fallin'.
 
Why do people get so upset and against wanting a perfect iPad? Or device in general?

If I'm going to spend over 500 for a device, I want it to be perfect.. At least from the get go. Any defects should happen by me, but it should not come that way. Imagine trying to resell it, a lightbleed will definitely hurt the value down the road. And a yellow tint is definitely not a nitpick as far as I'm concerned. The only thing you do with an iPad is look at it, if the screen is not perfect to look at, why wouldn't you have a problem with it? A dead pixel is the same, it would hurt resale value and at least to me, if I know there's a dead pixel, it would bug me forever. (I had a PSP that had a few of them, and Sony would do nothing about it. I had to sell the PSP and buy a different one because it bothered me so much.) Also, imagine there's two iPads on the marketplace here for sale. One has a dead pixel, one doesn't. The one with a dead pixel would probably be hounded and offered lower prices. A light bleed would probably be the same way, and a yellow tint would absolutely be the same. I'm sure if Apple asked you if you would want one with or without a defect like that, you would probably go with the one without, so why act as if it doesn't really matter?

If you went out and spent 100k on a car, would you expect it to be perfect in every way? What if the engine ran bad? It still drives though.. How about if there was a big dent / scratch in the front and side of it? Still is completely usable.

Why are people so nitpicky about what people on this forum post and care about?
Why are people so nitpicky about "nitpickers"?
 
I just wanted to say that I shipped in a new iPad a couple of days ago with what I thought to be an uneven backlight / yellow tint (I first got upset about it and then went online to look around, so I guess my concern was genuine).

As per now, it says "Product Replacement Pending". So I guess the people who are annoyed about the screens are not completely wrong and nitpicky.
 
Why do people get so upset and against wanting a perfect iPad? Or device in general?

If I'm going to spend over 500 for a device, I want it to be perfect.. .... And a yellow tint is definitely not a nitpick as far as I'm concerned. The only thing you do with an iPad is look at it, if the screen is not perfect to look at, why wouldn't you have a problem with it? .......

You look at it and you touch it.

Now there's a thread started about the anti-fingerprint screen coating not being even.

https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1357388/
 
Why are people so nitpicky about what people on this forum post and care about?
Why are people so nitpicky about "nitpickers"?

Because the fleeting false sense of superiority that comes with posting on the internet is irresistible for many who can't achieve anything remotely close to superiority offline.

And yes, I feel superior for saying that. :D
 
Because the fleeting false sense of superiority that comes with posting on the internet is irresistible for many who can't achieve anything remotely close to superiority offline.

And yes, I feel superior for saying that. :D

It's far easier to call people out on the Internet and write passive aggressive digs online. Or in this case, agressive comments. Most people who write these snarky comments wouldn't let out a peep in person.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.