3:41 ...exactly my experience
My 16 Pro Max has absolutely none of these touch screen issues. Never a single time, no matter how I hold it-- including in situations like in the above video. Which makes me suspect that this is some kind of undiagnosed hardware issue that Apple is avoiding admitting to...
And here's why I'm extra suspicous of that. My previous phone, a 15 Pro Max, had a different intermittent issue with the touch screen since I first got it on launch day, where the area above the Dynamic Island would randomly stop responding to touch. Maybe 30% of the time I was unable to pull down my notification window. I had a second 15 Pro Max for work that had the exact same issue. I thought it had to be a software bug, but it never resolved, so I took it in to the Apple Store. They refused to do anything to fix it, because their screen test diagnostic (where you move your finger all over the screen to "paint" in all the touch zones) didn't show anything wrong with it. And that's not surprising, because that kind of test will never be able to diagnose a screen that is working itermittently.
After much arguing I gave up, because the Apple Store employee said that they can't do a repair unless they get a diagnostic report that shows a failure, OR unless the phone is physically damaged (he even inferred to me that maybe I should go smash it myself and bring it back in so that they can put in a physical damage repair in the system....). So I traded it in for a 16 Pro Max (manufactured Sept 2024), and what do you know-- now I can pull down my notifications 100% of the time, from anywhere along the top of the screen, just as it should be.
So SOMETHING was faulty with the touch screen on two of my 15 Pro Max units, which means it couldn't have been THAT rare of a hardware defect, but nothing has ever been reported about it. I'm sure a lot of people with the same issue probably live with it on a daily basis and have no clue, either because they're swiping down from the top-left of the screen for notifications and don't know the middle doesn't work right, or else they've just gotten used to swiping down multiple times to check notifications thinking that they just didn't swipe down properly.
Last edited: