Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Which of these devices won't make the cut for iOS 8?

  • iPhone 4

    Votes: 272 91.3%
  • iPhone 4S

    Votes: 49 16.4%
  • iPad 2

    Votes: 178 59.7%
  • Third Generation iPad

    Votes: 50 16.8%
  • First Generation iPad mini

    Votes: 42 14.1%
  • Fifth Generation iPod touch

    Votes: 31 10.4%

  • Total voters
    298
Do you realise this is not true, and why? Because the A5 in the 4S needs to push LESS pixels then the A5 in the iPad 2. Resolution is what matters not DPI.


I stand corrected. Though the screen resolution on the iPad 2 is only very slightly larger than the 4S.
 
Right now each framework on iOS is a fat binary with ARMv6, ARMv7 and ARM64 compiled code.

Wait, ARMv6?!? Why is it still there? If I'm not mistaken isn't ARMv6 only used on pre iPhone 3GS devices? It surely won't be supported now right? Correct me if I'm wrong.

I am not a developer, but I have a question for you: if the API is 64 bit only, then when you update the app using he new API, does that mean your app will be 64 bit only? Does that also mean it won't run on 32-bit pre-A7 devices?

I believe that you are correct in saying that if it is only compiled in ARM64 code it wouldn't run on pre A7 devices. (However, A7 devices are able to run older frameworks like ARMv6 and ARMv7.) Therefore, I believe to make it compatible with older devices, ARMv7 code will also need to be included in iOS. Again, correct me if im wrong ;)
 
iPad 2's fate is tied to the iPad mini. iPhone 4 doesn't stand a chance. The original iPad got dropped fairly quickly so I could see them doing the same to the iPad 2/mini but seems unlikely.
 
Schools in the US have dumped a lot of money into the iPad 2 with a lot of students having the devices.

For Apple to dump the iPad 2 now would be a serious slap in the face to the millions they are making off the iPad 2 and the school systems.

I see iOS 8 supporting the iPad 2 still ... but I see iOS 8 being its last supported OS. Of course, it may "run" iOS 8, but it will have a limited function set.
 
Schools in the US have dumped a lot of money into the iPad 2 with a lot of students having the devices.

For Apple to dump the iPad 2 now would be a serious slap in the face to the millions they are making off the iPad 2 and the school systems.

I see iOS 8 supporting the iPad 2 still ... but I see iOS 8 being its last supported OS. Of course, it may "run" iOS 8, but it will have a limited function set.
How is not getting a new version of an OS after getting 3 or 4 new ones already a slap in the face or anything close to it? Does the device stop functioning by not getting it's 4th or 5th update? Do those who purchase it suddenly have a device that isn't performing like it did when they purchased it or when they got the most recent 3rd or 4th update already?
 
It's not like the iPad 2 will stop working. It won't be until iOS 9 that it even starts to lose app support (I'm still finding app updates including fixes for iOS 6 problems in the description of app updates).

If it doesn't get iOS 8 it'll still work just as it is right now. No one will be losing out on things.

I actually don't expect nor do I care if my iPad 3 is updated to iOS 8. Or my 4S for that matter. I do plan on updating my iPhone this go around however.
 
It's not like the iPad 2 will stop working. It won't be until iOS 9 that it even starts to lose app support (I'm still finding app updates including fixes for iOS 6 problems in the description of app updates).

If it doesn't get iOS 8 it'll still work just as it is right now. No one will be losing out on things.

I actually don't expect nor do I care if my iPad 3 is updated to iOS 8. Or my 4S for that matter. I do plan on updating my iPhone this go around however.
That is not true. A quality/property of the iPad is that has an ecosystem of high quality. Not being able to run the latest apps limits the functionality of the iPad. So it won't work exactly the same, because right now it is able to run the latest apps, after support has halted it won't be.
 
That is not true. A quality/property of the iPad is that has an ecosystem of high quality. Not being able to run the latest apps limits the functionality of the iPad. So it won't work exactly the same, because right now it is able to run the latest apps, after support has halted it won't be.
Is an iPad then sold and purchased with some sort of explicit expectation and agreement that it would always be able to run the latest applications (quite a bit of which is under control of an application's developer--who can even simply pull an application one day--and not really Apple or anything like that)?
 
That is not true. A quality/property of the iPad is that has an ecosystem of high quality. Not being able to run the latest apps limits the functionality of the iPad. So it won't work exactly the same, because right now it is able to run the latest apps, after support has halted it won't be.


Any quality developer supports old versions of iOS since it increases revenue especially if a device is left out with a large customer base. But that's besides the point since there is no telling what a dev will or will not do.

However how long should devices be supported especially devices that are no longer sold. Older iOS devices can cripple iOS because it has to work on them. The longer they are supported the less appealing newer versions of iOS become. The day iOS 8 rolls out every app is still going to be capable of running on iOS 7.

The main feature/functionality loss is brought by Apple (Siri, navigation, airdrop, etc). Not by devs.
 
It's not like the iPad 2 will stop working. It won't be until iOS 9 that it even starts to lose app support (I'm still finding app updates including fixes for iOS 6 problems in the description of app updates).

If it doesn't get iOS 8 it'll still work just as it is right now. No one will be losing out on things.

I actually don't expect nor do I care if my iPad 3 is updated to iOS 8. Or my 4S for that matter. I do plan on updating my iPhone this go around however.



There will be apps that require iOS 8 only. Like 12 days of Christmas and such.

App updates may require iOS 8 too.
 
There will be apps that require iOS 8 only. Like 12 days of Christmas and such.

App updates may require iOS 8 too.


App updates pertaining to iOS 8. But they won't be updated away from 7.

And yes there will be new apps that do require iOS 8 but then we are back to the how long should a device be supported for.

The iPad 2 is on it's 4th version of iOS. It can't go on forever.

I actually wouldn't be surprised if Apple discontinue the iPad 2 just to put some distance between it and iOS 8.

I have no stock in whether it does or doesn't get iOS 8. If it does, great if it doesn't oh well. I just personally don't think it will. Just my opinion though which holds no weight.
 
I love the way people take this so seriously and are convinced they are right.

We will find out when it is announced, until then, I agree with all of you.
 
Is an iPad then sold and purchased with some sort of explicit expectation and agreement that it would always be able to run the latest applications (quite a bit of which is under control of an application's developer--who can even simply pull an application one day--and not really Apple or anything like that)?
It doesn't matter, it frustrates customers and that's something Apple should do at least as possible since Apple is a user experience company.
 
It doesn't matter, it frustrates customers and that's something Apple should do at least as possible since Apple is a user experience company.
While in a general sense I understand what you are saying, as far as reality goes, there are plenty of things Apple should have done and/or do that they haven't or don't that frustrate people, and yet they still have done them and/or do them.
 
While in a general sense I understand what you are saying, as far as reality goes, there are plenty of things Apple should have done and/or do that they haven't or don't that frustrate people, and yet they still have done them and/or do them.


Meanwhile in another thread there is a class action law suit because devices were updated. Lol. Apple can't win. :)
 
App updates pertaining to iOS 8. But they won't be updated away from 7.

And yes there will be new apps that do require iOS 8 but then we are back to the how long should a device be supported for.

The iPad 2 is on it's 4th version of iOS. It can't go on forever.

I actually wouldn't be surprised if Apple discontinue the iPad 2 just to put some distance between it and iOS 8.

I have no stock in whether it does or doesn't get iOS 8. If it does, great if it doesn't oh well. I just personally don't think it will. Just my opinion though which holds no weight.
Incorrect, all of the iWork apps required iOS 7 right away.
 
Look at the current lineup

I think every device on the current line up will get iOS 8, that includes both iPad minis, iPad 4 and Air (IMHO that's one of the reasons why they dropped iPad 2), iPhone 4s and above.

iPhone 4 is no longer part of the main line so definitely not getting it.

iPad 3 could sway either way, but if it gets 8 it will definitely be its last.

Current iPod touch is safe too.
 
First off, I like this thread and the discussion that has sprung up from it. It's all interesting conjecture and it'll be fun to see how right or wrong we all are about the iOS support fate of our A5/A5X iOS devices. This all being said, I think it is useful to clarify on a couple facts that I've seen mis-represented a few times:

1. The fourth generation iPod touch:

- was sold through May of last year when it was replaced by the 16GB front-camera-less variant of the iPod touch.

No, it is back-camera less.
 
While in a general sense I understand what you are saying, as far as reality goes, there are plenty of things Apple should have done and/or do that they haven't or don't that frustrate people, and yet they still have done them and/or do them.
Difference is, there is a huge number of iPhone 4 and iPad 2 users out there. The scale is very different when compared with the 3GS or iPad 1. That changes everything and that's why you can't use history as a reference.
 
Difference is, there is a huge number of iPhone 4 and iPad 2 users out there. The scale is very different when compared with the 3GS or iPad 1. That changes everything and that's why you can't use history as a reference.
But you can't exclude it either. 3GS was one of quite successful phones for a while, and iPad 1 was bought by many many people as it was the first tablet not only from Apple but even in general essentially. So, while the numbers are even larger now for some newer devices, it's not like the numbers for the older devices at the time when their support stopped or a bit before it were small exactly.

There are arguments for and against it all, that's basically what it comes down to, as has been pointed out before. The only way we'll actually know is when Apple makes an announcement about it all (and even then we might not really know what the reasoning might be behind the decision, whichever way it goes).
 
Wait, ARMv6?!? Why is it still there? If I'm not mistaken isn't ARMv6 only used on pre iPhone 3GS devices? It surely won't be supported now right? Correct me if I'm wrong.

I believe that you are correct in saying that if it is only compiled in ARM64 code it wouldn't run on pre A7 devices. (However, A7 devices are able to run older frameworks like ARMv6 and ARMv7.) Therefore, I believe to make it compatible with older devices, ARMv7 code will also need to be included in iOS. Again, correct me if im wrong ;)

Sorry. It's:

UIKit (architecture armv7):
UIKit (architecture armv7s):
UIKit (architecture arm64):

Currently in iOS7. You are right.

Regarding the API I meant that everything will be 64bit.
Today ARMv7 compiles against 32bit UIKit.

For me that mens that iOS8 will probably be slower on iPhine 5, because of the additional instructions. (Which are a lot, I checked.)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.