No, of course I don't want to read CNN on my watch. But I also want to go walk around the neighborhood without having to carry my phone. And adding all the functions through bands doesn't strike me as an answer, as that would just make heavier bands instead of heavier watch. Plus, what if I wanted both GPS and extra battery. How am I going to put on two bands at once?
In any case, back to your argument that the Apple watch is meant to last longer than other Apple devices. Well, considering some people keep phones and tablets around for 3-4 years or even longer, I don't disagree with you that the first Apple gen watch would still function five years from now. But would it get the latest OS update? If you are right about the GPS accessory band, yes, something released next year would possibly work with the first gen watch. But would an accessory band released five years from now work with a first gen watch?
Good points. Will see. But for me, Apple has thought things thru about longevity of Apple Watch, which again makes sense if you're gonna sell $17,000 watches...and keep selling them! I am pretty sure that next gen Watch will have EDITION too. So, who is gonna buy that IF bmac4 is right about having a 3-5 yr shelf life?!