Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] Bloodlust GAME OVER - WEREWOLVES WIN
- Thread starter ravenvii
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
We're aren't all blessed with your rapier intellect.
I just thought that it sounded like a Day 1 excuse.
Willbro tossed the fateful paper into the pot. "We have our majority," declared NathanMuir. The villagers then looked amongst themselves for ucfgrad93, who they found to be missing.
"Search for him! Seize him and take him to the gallows!" shouted NathanMuir.
As the villagers searched the village, a shout came from the direction of the gallows.
"I've found him!" cried Melrose.
As the villagers assembled near the gallows, their eyes followed Melrose's index finger, which is pointing towards the gallows.
ucfgrad93 was swaying in the wind from the noose. He has killed himself.
A note was found below his feet. It read:
The villagers were silent as the sun slowly begun it's descent into the horizon.
ucfgrad93 was a villager. 9 now remain. It is now NIGHT - Specials, send me the PMs.
"Search for him! Seize him and take him to the gallows!" shouted NathanMuir.
As the villagers searched the village, a shout came from the direction of the gallows.
"I've found him!" cried Melrose.
As the villagers assembled near the gallows, their eyes followed Melrose's index finger, which is pointing towards the gallows.
ucfgrad93 was swaying in the wind from the noose. He has killed himself.
A note was found below his feet. It read:
ucfgrad93 said:
The villagers were silent as the sun slowly begun it's descent into the horizon.
ucfgrad93 was a villager. 9 now remain. It is now NIGHT - Specials, send me the PMs.
Even though you voted for me, I forgive you in the after life. After all, we are all welcome at iBlue's Big House.
As the villagers woke up from a restless slumber, the sun revealed the gallows, with a body hanging from the noose. The villagers has forgotten to take down ucfgrad93's body from from the previous day's suicide.
However, when they assembled closer to the gallows, they found not ucfgrad93's body, but stonyc's body, hanging from the noose. ucfgrad93's body is nowhere to be found.
The werewolves has eaten ucfgrad93's body, and left stonyc up to taunt the village.
stonyc has been killed by werewolves. 8 now remain, and 5 is the majority vote.
However, when they assembled closer to the gallows, they found not ucfgrad93's body, but stonyc's body, hanging from the noose. ucfgrad93's body is nowhere to be found.
The werewolves has eaten ucfgrad93's body, and left stonyc up to taunt the village.
stonyc has been killed by werewolves. 8 now remain, and 5 is the majority vote.
Total coincidence. Plenty of times I've logged on at this time and there's a long delay. This happened just as I was posting a reply to this thread about ucfgrad93. I wasn't expecting there'd already be another kill post. STONY!
I'll bake some bowling ball cookies straight away! So this is the post I was previewing to find the kill post:
Damn it. Well so much for that block voting theory. It seemed plausible.
In order of suspicion:
renewed, Mexbearpig, willbro, Melrose, Don't panic, appleguy123, Nathan Muir
(edited stonyc's place on the suspect list but he was third to last)
interesting that willbro voted for me and I had already placed him near the front of my suspect line so that changes things.
wow, that was quick.
i was hoping we might get lucky with ucfgrad93, but it wasn't meant to be.
Stonyc demise was unfortunately fully expected.
still no trace of vampire activity.
i think willbro is a very good candidate for infection but that's the only way he can be a baddie.
everyone else can be a wolf by infection, an original wolf (kamikaze to boost), a vamp or a goth, so i'd go after these first.
my 'original baddie' list (in order):
mexbearpig, renewed, melrose, appleguy123, iblue, nathanmuir
my 'infected wolfie' list:
willbro, nathanmuir, iblue, melrose, appleguy, mexbearpig, renewed
i'm going with mexbearpig, for now, but i remain very wary of renewed and melrose. i don't buy the "i am confused" storyline.
we can still do this,
Don'y Panic
i was hoping we might get lucky with ucfgrad93, but it wasn't meant to be.
Stonyc demise was unfortunately fully expected.
still no trace of vampire activity.
i think willbro is a very good candidate for infection but that's the only way he can be a baddie.
everyone else can be a wolf by infection, an original wolf (kamikaze to boost), a vamp or a goth, so i'd go after these first.
my 'original baddie' list (in order):
mexbearpig, renewed, melrose, appleguy123, iblue, nathanmuir
my 'infected wolfie' list:
willbro, nathanmuir, iblue, melrose, appleguy, mexbearpig, renewed
i'm going with mexbearpig, for now, but i remain very wary of renewed and melrose. i don't buy the "i am confused" storyline.
we can still do this,
Don'y Panic
We've been following that strategy, apparently, and it is isn't working.
I don't know how I can explain to you - as I've said since the first time this thread got derailed for days on end - that the confusion is the result of (mostly stonyc and you) posting long blocks of text that ended up influencing everyone... I have a problem with reading comprehension, so it doesn't come easy. It was only a day ago or so I realized Nathan was the Sorcerer. Sheesh. Give a guy a chance at least.
EDIT-
Don't panic. The reason is thus: He posted a supposedly "thoughtful" post that I just quoted from. And he even gives us a helpful list of likely candidates! Except, he lists every player left in the game but himself. (???) He's purporting to be helpful, but the signs indicate he doesn't really care. Ergo, I have my Fearfully Good Player (as confirmed numerous times
) suspicions aroused.
EDIT-
Don't panic. The reason is thus: He posted a supposedly "thoughtful" post that I just quoted from. And he even gives us a helpful list of likely candidates! Except, he lists every player left in the game but himself. (???) He's purporting to be helpful, but the signs indicate he doesn't really care. Ergo, I have my Fearfully Good Player (as confirmed numerous times
why would i include myself in MY list of candidates?
i did check my PMs and i KNOW my role in this game.
honestly, it would be completely daft to list oneself as a possible candidate and the only reason to do is to deceivingly transmit the impression of being 'fair' in the analysis.
I am sorry if my long-winded posts confuse and/or annoy you.
i am trying to post some analysis that might be helpful. same with stonyc. and indeed his analysis was instrumental in finding philbeeney. (oh and he got killed for that too)
as far as MY influence, i appreciate your appreciation, but so far i haven't been able to direct a single vote yet, just check the voting history of the game.
i also notice that you voted for me firstly in everyone of the last 3 days, so i don't think the reason for your vote was my last post (especially because as mentioned above it doesn't make any sense as a reason).
i am not switching my vote to you yet, but you are most definitively confirming my suspicions
Total coincidence. Plenty of times I've logged on at this time and there's a long delay. This happened just as I was posting a reply to this thread about ucfgrad93. I wasn't expecting there'd already be another kill post. STONY!
So this is the post I was previewing to find the kill post:
Damn it. Well so much for that block voting theory. It seemed plausible.
I am tempted to wait to post this till morning but at this point I think I'd better speak now because you never know when it's your last chance and all that.
In order of suspicion:
renewed, Mexbearpig, willbro, Melrose, Don't panic, appleguy123, Nathan Muir
(edited stonyc's place on the suspect list but he was third to last)
interesting that willbro voted for me and I had already placed him near the front of my suspect line so that changes things. willbro gets my vote. I think when King Mook Mook cleared him as a villager he got infected. It's happened exactly that way before because it's a great strategy.
I agree.
I wanted to believe stonyc's voting chart but given that ucfgrad93 was a villager, I guess we can't put that much belief into it any more.
I'll be voting for willbro.
EDIT:
Votes
iBlue: 1 (willbro)
willbro: 3 (iBlue, Mexbearpig, NathanMuir)
Mexbearpig: 1 (Don't panic)
Don't panic: 1 (Melrose)
i am not switching my vote to you yet, but you are most definitively confirming my suspicions
Since when is having a solid reason for voting a bad thing? I'm sticking with my vote for you, for the reasons I said. Simply attacking me for having a reason behind my vote is also weird.
well, given that your 'solid' reason is me not suspecting of myself, i don't see how to point that out is in any way 'weird'.but you are playing your game, so everything is fine by me
but you are playing your game, so everything is fine by me
No, my reason was that you provide a very helpful, well-thought out list of primary suspects that includes everybody who's left in the game, with the exception of yourself. That's a red flag to me. "Hey everybody! Look over there! And there! Now look over there! And there!"
I'm not sure what you mean either really, Melrose. The only relevant players now are the ones still playing. And no one is going to include themselves in their suspect list because it's meaningless.
The only relevant players now are the ones still playing. And no one is going to include themselves in their suspect list because it's meaningless.
No, my reason was that you provide a very helpful, well-thought out list of primary suspects that includes everybody who's left in the game, with the exception of yourself. That's a red flag to me. "Hey everybody! Look over there! And there! Now look over there! And there!"
i don't see the difference. you are still voting for me for the sole reason that i didn't include myself in my own suspects' list - or so you state.
and if you notice my own name wasn't the only one missing from the 'original baddie' list: willbro was missing too.
why? because we know for a FACT (per KMM) that he was a villager to begin with. NathanMuir on the other hand is on that list but on the last spot because he claims he was the sorcerer -and i believe him- however we don't know that for a 'fact' yet.
on the other hand (the third one by my count
), both willbro and nathan are on the second list 'possible infectees) because they could be infected; and they are high on the list because they would be the only two for which philbeeney (which we all assume was the alpha wolf -again an assumption and not a fact-) would have been reasonably sure that they were not a vampire.this brings us to why I am not voting for willbro right now (i might change that if we get to a stalemate): because the odds of him being a bad guy are 1/7 while the odd of everyone else (and yes, i keep excluding myself from the count) is 4/7 (assuming that vamps and goth are still out there and that indeed we have an wolf infectee, both of which i have no reason to doubt).
and if you are a villager, the odds would be the same from your perspective as well.
if you are one of the bad guys, that is different, but so is your goal in the game.
Don't Panic
I'm not sure what you mean either really, Melrose.
My point is only that it seems he's hiding something - why provide a list of suspects when you're listing everybody still in the game? It's like he points fingers at everyone else simply because they're not him. I can't be the only one who thinks that's fishy.
And we have had ones who, in efforts to be modest and honest, include themselves in suspect lists based on their voting record. jav2947 for one. In most than a few games he's been very good about including himself in is suspect lists if he fits the pattern. Don't panic just names everyone but himself. I find that odd is all..
you conveniently omitted that they were ranked in order of my 'suspiciousness'
and how could it be 'honest' if i included myself? either i am one of the bad guys, and to be 'honest' i should out myself, or I am not, and i shouldn't be on the list.
