Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] MRville VI: GAME OVER - VILLAGERS WIN

Well with this new information I guess it's not the worst thing appleguy123 is the lynchee. Probably best not to have the vampire(s) activated.

jav6454 said:
You do know that if you reveal your role, the only remaining suspect will be iBlue... please do trust me. Now, what is your role? Besides, the Hunter will obviously protect you this night. I don't need protection for the next night nor the next day; but if need be you do.
Click to expand...

Why? According to your proven absurdly inaccurate "fur-o-meter"? :rolleyes: I said I had a good role and if I've not outed that yet, ever think maybe I have my reasons?

philbeeney said:
We are all villagers. It's just that some of the villagers choose to undertake extra-curricular activities at night time. Some like to kill, some like to drink blood and some just lie in bed awake all night wondering if they'll see daylight again.
Click to expand...

Spoken like a real baddie... or a very unwise member of the secret society taking the risk of getting them all killed. Either way, you're freaking me out here. In the off chance you are good, I hope the WW hunter protects you so that your potential infection doesn't cause the entire society to get wiped out.
 
Last edited:
Final voting tally:

appleguy123: 6 (jav6454, Rodimus Prime, NathanMuir, iBookG4user, mscriv, CBoss)
philbeeney: 4 (iBlue, Don't panic, appleguy123, stonyc)
iBlue: 2 (philbeeney, Mexbearpig)

"I give up. I'm one of the goths. I'll reveal the vampire to you when I find him. Don't lynch me - help me help you, hmm?"

That was the last words out of Appleguy123's mouth as the villagers immediately hauled him to the gallows upon hearing the word "goth."

"Tell us about the vampire? Yeah right - we know better than that, fool. Time to face your maker!" said jav6454 as Appleguy123 struggled against the noose. Rodimus Prime pulled the lever, and Appleguy123 dropped.

He did not transform.

"Of course goths don't transform, so that's not a bad thing. Good riddance!" jav6454 pumped his fists.

"But how are you sure he's a goth?" asked mscriv, quickly adding "of course he said it himself, but that would lead to the question, is there any motive for him to lie about being a goth?"

Appleguy123 was hanged, and is a villager. It is now NIGHT, and the deadline for all special orders is 9:30 PM EST.
 
Everyone woke up to a sunny and bright morning, and a quick head count at the communal breakfast revealed that everyone survived the night. The village gets a second chance to lynch an enemy today.

It is now DAY, everyone survived the night. The maj. vote is 6. Deadline is Monday, 3pm.
 
Well, going off the previous conversation, I am going to vote for philbeeney.

I think that it is worthing noting again that when Ravenvii answered our prayer, he said 'Yes' to the wolf and/ or vamp. Under my reading of that answer, that would not include the goth as he is not a vamp until activation, meaning we still at least one wolf and/or vamp in the top seven.

EDIT:

Here's the remaining six:

1: iBookG4user
2: stonyc
3: philbeeney
4: appleguy123
5: Don't panic
6: Nathanmuir
7: iBlue
 
I agree with NathanMuir. As I said before, I didn't quite like either Appleguy123's or philbeeney's previous arguments. So, I'm gonna vote for philbeeney. As always, if there's other evidence presented I'm open to a vote change.

For those of you who say I always take to long to cast a vote... take that! :p ;)
 
mscriv said:
I agree with NathanMuir. As I said before, I didn't quite like either Appleguy123's or philbeeney's previous arguments. So, I'm gonna vote for philbeeney. As always, if there's other evidence presented I'm open to a vote change.

For those of you who say I always take to long to cast a vote... take that! :p ;)
Click to expand...

Don't worry, I'm eating my words as I type. :D
 
NathanMuir said:
Well, going off the previous conversation, I am going to vote for philbeeney.
Click to expand...

mscriv said:
I agree with NathanMuir. As I said before, I didn't quite like either Appleguy123's or philbeeney's previous arguments. So, I'm gonna vote for philbeeney.
Click to expand...

You both posted very quickly after ravenvii's post to condemn me. That strikes me as the sign of a couple of wolves acting together using the situation to your advantage.

So which one of you shall I vote for..............NathanMuir
 
Last edited:
philbeeney said:
You both posted very quickly after ravenvii's post to condemn me. That strikes me as the sign of a couple of wolves acting together using the situation to your advantage.

So which one of you shall I vote for..............NathanMuir
Click to expand...

Perhaps because voting for you required very little thought given the conversation yesterday.

If you'd like to give us hint as to what your role might be (or redirect me to that post, I can't remember if you've hinted towards you role), I'd be glad to consider changing my vote.
 
well it is always a good sign when our hunter keeps us all alive for another night. Good job hunter.
 
NathanMuir said:
Well, going off the previous conversation, I am going to vote for philbeeney.

I think that it is worthing noting again that when Ravenvii answered our prayer, he said 'Yes' to the wolf and/ or vamp. Under my reading of that answer, that would not include the goth as he is not a vamp until activation, meaning we still at least one wolf and/or vamp in the top seven.

EDIT:

Here's the remaining six:

1: iBookG4user
2: stonyc
3: philbeeney
4: appleguy123
5: Don't panic
6: Nathanmuir
7: iBlue
Click to expand...

mscriv said:
I agree with NathanMuir. As I said before, I didn't quite like either Appleguy123's or philbeeney's previous arguments. So, I'm gonna vote for philbeeney. As always, if there's other evidence presented I'm open to a vote change.

For those of you who say I always take to long to cast a vote... take that! :p ;)
Click to expand...

This just seems a bit too convenient to have you both voting so close together to try to get the mob mentality going. With that in mind I will vote for NathanMuir, which is who I voted for in the first round as well.
 
woot woot for the hunter!

good job also to the villagers who saw through appleguy's sharades (i have to say that after the confession, I thought he was a wolf trying a desperate card).

appleguy wasn't the baddie identified by jav, so there is at least another one in the upper half. although I don't get many baddy-vibes from that bunch, so i am inclined to think the bottom 5 also hide some nasty surprises.

philbeeney tops my suspect list again for the upper half, like before.
from his posts he is likely either a NW or a baddie. which leaves us with:
a) he is a wolf.
b) he is a vamp.
c) he is a goth.
d) he is a NW. this raises a problem: if he is infected, him and the other 2 NW would be killed instantly. pretty bad for the village, very good for the wolfies. however, this has not happened yet, so...
--d1) the wolves don't believe he is a NW, and didn't attempt to infect him (yet)
--d2) wolves did try to infect him but he wasn't a NW (however in that case he would be a wolf now)
--d3) wolves did try infect him but he was immune because:
-------d3i) he is the hunter
-------d3ii) the hunter protected him the previous night (depending on when the infection attempt occurred)
-------d3iii) he is a vamp (this is the best case scenario, as wolf lost their most dangerous weapon with no gains)

i don't think he is the hunter and doubt the hunter would have protected him last night. so this leaves us wit mostly bad scenarios as far as philbeeney's role, and hence my vote for him.
 
NathanMuir said:
Perhaps because voting for you required very little thought given the conversation yesterday.

If you'd like to give us hint as to what your role might be (or redirect me to that post, I can't remember if you've hinted towards you role), I'd be glad to consider changing my vote.
Click to expand...

I'm a plain ol' villager, like everyone else. That's my role in this game. What more do you want to know and why do you want to know? Only a bad guy would be asking those sorts of questions. Hence I'm not changing my vote.
 
philbeeney said:
I'm a plain ol' villager, like everyone else. That's my role in this game. What more do you want to know and why do you want to know? Only a bad guy would be asking those sorts of questions. Hence I'm not changing my vote.
Click to expand...

Thank you for reiterating my reason for voting for you.

The flaw in this argument has been pointed out numerous times.
 
Don't panic said:
woot woot for the hunter!

good job also to the villagers who saw through appleguy's sharades (i have to say that after the confession, I thought he was a wolf trying a desperate card).

appleguy wasn't the baddie identified by jav, so there is at least another one in the upper half. although I don't get many baddy-vibes from that bunch, so i am inclined to think the bottom 5 also hide some nasty surprises.

philbeeney tops my suspect list again for the upper half, like before.
from his posts he is likely either a NW or a baddie. which leaves us with:
a) he is a wolf.
b) he is a vamp.
c) he is a goth.
d) he is a NW. this raises a problem: if he is infected, him and the other 2 NW would be killed instantly. pretty bad for the village, very good for the wolfies. however, this has not happened yet, so...
--d1) the wolves don't believe he is a NW, and didn't attempt to infect him (yet)
--d2) wolves did try to infect him but he wasn't a NW (however in that case he would be a wolf now)
--d3) wolves did try infect him but he was immune because:
-------d3i) he is the hunter
-------d3ii) the hunter protected him the previous night (depending on when the infection attempt occurred)
-------d3iii) he is a vamp (this is the best case scenario, as wolf lost their most dangerous weapon with no gains)

i don't think he is the hunter and doubt the hunter would have protected him last night. so this leaves us wit mostly bad scenarios as far as philbeeney's role, and hence my vote for him.
Click to expand...

You missed one.

The wolves may of already infect him and all they are doing is sitting on the knowledge because they are not worried about the NW yet. They may be waiting for the NW to get its full size of 5 first.
Remember the wolves can use that ability to kill all the NW when ever they want.
so d4) he is on NW, He is infected and the wolves have chosen not to kill all of NW yet.
 
Rodimus Prime said:
You missed one.

The wolves may of already infect him and all they are doing is sitting on the knowledge because they are not worried about the NW yet. They may be waiting for the NW to get its full size of 5 first.
Remember the wolves can use that ability to kill all the NW when ever they want.
so d4) he is on NW, He is infected and the wolves have chosen not to kill all of NW yet.
Click to expand...

:)
i am sure i missed more than one.
however if he is a NW, and he is infected, the wolves can wait for a while, as i don't think that the NW would recruit anyone. it's way too dangerous and there isn't a good enough payoff.

the only way I can think this kind of scenario would pay off is: wolves infect a NW, they wait with the mass killing, they pick off the non-infected NW, then the remaining infected NW recruits two more villagers. Now they do the mass killing. this requires the willing sacrifice of the infected NW, but it would almost certainly ensure a wolvish triumph. scary scenario :) [however, i am not sure you can keep the mass killing option: i think the wolves have to decide if they want to infiltrate or to kill the NW, but it's a one-off decision]
 
iBlue I don't believe in philbeeney's guilt. Also, three possible scenarios here since the full time length of the Night didn't go through. Either:

1. I was attacked, and my immunity kicked in.
2. The WW Hunter was attacked and immunity kicked in
3. A person protected by the Hunter was attacked, in which case immunity also kicked in.

I'm leaning more towards the last 2. Also, like I said, I do not believe philbeeney is a bad guy at all.
 
jav6454 said:
iBlue I don't believe in philbeeney's guilt. Also, three possible scenarios here since the full time length of the Night didn't go through. Either:

1. I was attacked, and my immunity kicked in.
2. The WW Hunter was attacked and immunity kicked in
3. A person protected by the Hunter was attacked, in which case immunity also kicked in.

I'm leaning more towards the last 2. Also, like I said, I do not believe philbeeney is a bad guy at all.
Click to expand...

i don't think it is 1) because they would know that.
hopefully it's 3 because if they attacked the hunter, he lost his/her immunity and now could be infected (giving the insta shot to the wolves)
 
Don't panic said:
i don't think it is 1) because they would know that.
hopefully it's 3 because if they attacked the hunter, he lost his/her immunity and now could be infected (giving the insta shot to the wolves)
Click to expand...

Luckily, they still can't get me. I have this day left immune. However, please consider my fur-o-meter response to philbeeney. It doesn't even move. However, it reads off high midici's (WW radiation emitters) when I point it towards iBlue.
 
jav6454 said:
Luckily, they still can't get me. I have this day left immune. However, please consider my fur-o-meter response to philbeeney. It doesn't even move. However, it reads off high midici's (WW radiation emitters) when I point it towards iBlue.
Click to expand...

I LOLLED

the problem with phil is that he's dangerous to keep around even if he is in the NW, once he'souted, for the reasons above.

but i'll consider whether it's better an egg today or a chicken tomorrow
 
I am going to vote iblue
Something just feels odd how she is behaving. Plus I have not gotten my cookies yet.
 
iBookG4user said:
This just seems a bit too convenient to have you both voting so close together to try to get the mob mentality going. With that in mind I will vote for NathanMuir, which is who I voted for in the first round as well.
Click to expand...

Seriously folks, make up your mind. If I take a long time to vote then I'm suspicious, but if I vote to quickly then I'm also suspicious.

damned-if-you-do-dont.jpg
 
I will be voting for philbeeney because there are no normal villagers and for the reasons mentioned by Don't panic.

I could be swayed to vote for iBlue and end this round early if someone can provide a good enough reason. I just don't see it right now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back