Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] MRville VI: GAME OVER - VILLAGERS WIN
- Thread starter ravenvii
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I'll sway you. Philbeeney has not special powers, but is an asset to the village. This is what I get from the whole "normal" villager ordeal.
Also, I would like to bring this to everyone's attention. Notice I said, in my prayer is there a vampire and/or wolf in the 1/2 top of the list.
Now, appleguy123 was not a wolf, nor was he a vampire as of yet; he was a Goth, ergo he doesn't really fall into the category described by the question. Call it gasping for air, but here the only one without having hinted at ANYTHING related to her role is iBlue. She has thus far accused philbeeney and tried to disarm my defense for him. Also, she gives no sign of having a role that helps us, rather the opposite.
I think I know what lbro was. He was the Undertaker. Why? Killed as a villager and he said his role was nothing to bring him back for. Now, people might think the NW, but given that the NW have to be careful due to infection, I don't see lbro comiting a rookie mistake like that incase he is ever brought back.
All in all, out of everyone iBlue is worst suspect here. If she is the bad girl, then we got one wolf down and one to go. Again, and not trying to sound like a broken record, I strongly disbelieve philbeeney is the wolf.
Last edited:
On that note, I'll spell out my plan for the next day:
If philbeeney turns out not to be a baddie, my next choice is iBlue for the reasons you've listed.
I'd have to disagree, we'd be down one villager, and I may well be next since my protection dies as the sun sets on Day 3. In the other game I was right (the previous simple game), and in this game I feel it strongly on iBlue.
Midici level 8/10
Well, assuming lbro was the undertaker, would he be able to come back, if the
EDIT:
Sorry, Sorcerer.
Last edited:
Ok, I change my vote to iBlue
I originally voted for her in the first round. She keeps claiming her innocence, but I don't believe her. I think she's been infected already and that the werewolves are going for it straight from the off this game using her innocence to fool everybody. Hell, it worked last time.
NathanMuir and mscriv are next on my list as the main werewolf tag team. Should I be lynched, you will be sorely disappointed and then you will see later on in the game that I was correct.
I originally voted for her in the first round. She keeps claiming her innocence, but I don't believe her. I think she's been infected already and that the werewolves are going for it straight from the off this game using her innocence to fool everybody. Hell, it worked last time.
NathanMuir and mscriv are next on my list as the main werewolf tag team. Should I be lynched, you will be sorely disappointed and then you will see later on in the game that I was correct.
Voting tally:
philbeeney: 4 (NathanMuir, mscriv, Don't panic, Cboss)
NathanMuir: 1 (iBookG4user)
iBlue: 5 (jav6454, Mexbearpig, Rodimus Prime, philbeeney, stonyc)
iBlue is at n-1.
(Updated as of post 463)
philbeeney: 4 (NathanMuir, mscriv, Don't panic, Cboss)
NathanMuir: 1 (iBookG4user)
iBlue: 5 (jav6454, Mexbearpig, Rodimus Prime, philbeeney, stonyc)
iBlue is at n-1.
(Updated as of post 463)
Last edited:
honestly I am torn between Phil and iBlue. Phil to me if NW screams problem if he has not been infected yet so it might almost be worth killing him on that ground alone.
iBlue just has question marks.
I am going to go get some more beer then I will decide if I will change my vote.
iBlue just has question marks.
I am going to go get some more beer then I will decide if I will change my vote.
I don't reveal my role. I prefer the other players to work it out, hence why I'm a plain ol' villager. I like the psychological questions / answers and thinking that has to be involved. Perhaps I'm a sadist in disguise or something, however please listen to what jav6454 has to say.
I'm convinced, I change my vote to iBlue.
If philbeeney were on the NW, he would be stupid to keep insisting that he is a plain ol' villager. And he's anything but. So him being on the NW is out, but he's definitely something... maybe a baddie?
If he were actually a baddie, he would also be stupid to keep insisting that he is a plain ol' villager, which we all know is something he can't be...
Which means, I think... that we can take him at face value at the same time as not taking him at face value: he is not a plain ol' villager, but his continued insistence that he is, means that he isn't... a plain ol' villager. Hehe, confusing... but I think I'm convinced enough that he's not a baddie.
If philbeeney were on the NW, he would be stupid to keep insisting that he is a plain ol' villager. And he's anything but. So him being on the NW is out, but he's definitely something... maybe a baddie?
If he were actually a baddie, he would also be stupid to keep insisting that he is a plain ol' villager, which we all know is something he can't be...
Which means, I think... that we can take him at face value at the same time as not taking him at face value: he is not a plain ol' villager, but his continued insistence that he is, means that he isn't... a plain ol' villager. Hehe, confusing... but I think I'm convinced enough that he's not a baddie.
This is a lot more convincing than the reason I voted for NathanMuir. Although I'm still not completely convinced about NathanMuir's innocence. However, I will change my vote to iBlue on the chance that she is a werewolf.
Well, not that it matters now, as iBlue's lynching has been sealed, but I don't really think that she's a wolf. I just don't see the evidence. I hope that iBlue is innocent and that we lynch Philbeeney tomorrow.
If I don't make it through the night, I'd cast my imaginary vote for Philbeeney come tomorrow. I also seriously doubt that lbro was the undertaker. The undertaker role is useful in that s/he can work with the sorcerer to revive a particularly relevant player that has been killed. If anything, I'd assume that lbro was the vamp hunter. It would sense in that the vamps are rarely, if ever(?), activated in the game, thus his comment about his role.
Nice. Majority happily and quickly reached while I was sleeping because I am in a different time zone? Such gentlemen, throwing fate-sealing votes around before I could have defended myself and proved it. You all followed the most clueless player's fur-o-meter "logic". I'm looking forward to the end now when the roles are revealed.
Bravo!
edit 2: maybe the avatar: http://upc.*************/uploads/avatars/V.gif was bad luck.
Bravo!
edit 2: maybe the avatar: http://upc.*************/uploads/avatars/V.gif was bad luck.
Last edited:
^ let's hear it... also, fur-o-meter has worked before and if by clueless you mean the guy who helped win a game from the wolves and also help renewed eat an entire village, then yes, I am clueless.
No thanks. The deal is done. You can find out at the end. What I will say is that I was absolutely telling the truth about having a good role and had my reasons (JUST LIKE EVERYONE ELSE) for not revealing it outright, but you were so damn determined with that stupid bloody fur-o-meter of yours. You and your buddy aggie are much better at being baddies than good players because your powers of deduction are abysmal, mister "struggles to understand the concept of a 'yes or no' question." I'm a little shocked people went right along with you and your "logic". If you weren't (right now) a confirmed good guy I would have thought you were a baddie for your insistence on leading the charge to vote for me without even giving me a chance to defend myself. I had my reasons for not proving it before but I would have... if you all hadn't so casually put majority forward before I woke up. (FFS, it's 6:30am here. It's amazing I'm up THIS early.)
So yeah, enjoy the slaughter.
Ta-ta!
Last edited:
Suit yourself....
edit - oh and btw, -aggie- is much better than what you think at this game...
as per a simple yes and no question, I believe that has an answer...
Attachments
^ OooOOOooooOOOoooohh, and what a great defense for your pitiful "fur-o-meter". If anything I'll know in future to vote against it because all it ever seems to do is lead you the wrong way. I had high hopes that if the village had caught a baddie this round that there was a small chance of village victory but those odds have just been lessened substantially. It's a bit frustrating again being victim of mob mentality before having a chance to explain or prove myself. (and I could have in a pinch but I was trying to use my role more wisely than that.)
FWIW, I'm not just being spiteful about not revealing my role, I think it may be part of the rules that I don't after my fate is sealed. But personally I think it's more fun this way anyhow.
FWIW, I'm not just being spiteful about not revealing my role, I think it may be part of the rules that I don't after my fate is sealed. But personally I think it's more fun this way anyhow.
Last edited:
Hey, you're friends and you do seem to have a similar style, so sure, why not? All I said is that you're both better at playing baddie roles than good ones because you're not as skilled at correct deductions as you are at killing.
Hey, you're friends and you do seem to have a similar style, so sure, why not? All I said is that you're both better at playing baddie roles than good ones because you're not as skilled at correct deductions as you are at killing.
Jeez, whatever.
Final voting record:
philbeeney: 4 (NathanMuir, mscriv, Don't panic, Cboss)
iBlue: 6 (jav6454, Mexbearpig, Rodimus Prime, philbeeney, stonyc, iBookG4user)
iBlue was sleeping as jav6454 led the charge into her house. iBookG4user and jav6454 grabbed iBlue's arms and dragged her out of bed and the mob headed straight for the gallows.
iBlue was only fully awake as the noose slip over her head. "What?! Voting against me while I'm asleep?! What gentlemen!" iBlue spat as jav6454 smugly grasped the lever. "Tis' the fur 'o' meter, lady."
Lever pulled, iBlue dropped. Just as the noose tightened around her neck, a blast of flour covered the watching mob.
There is a practically visible "WTF?" above the mob's heads.
"... well... um... fur sounds like flour... right?" jav6454, covered from head to toe with flour, offered from the platform.
iBlue was lynched, and is a villager. 10 now remain, and it is NIGHT. Deadline for all orders is 9 AM on Sunday. EST or EDT or whatever it is, 9 AM
philbeeney: 4 (NathanMuir, mscriv, Don't panic, Cboss)
iBlue: 6 (jav6454, Mexbearpig, Rodimus Prime, philbeeney, stonyc, iBookG4user)
iBlue was sleeping as jav6454 led the charge into her house. iBookG4user and jav6454 grabbed iBlue's arms and dragged her out of bed and the mob headed straight for the gallows.
iBlue was only fully awake as the noose slip over her head. "What?! Voting against me while I'm asleep?! What gentlemen!" iBlue spat as jav6454 smugly grasped the lever. "Tis' the fur 'o' meter, lady."
Lever pulled, iBlue dropped. Just as the noose tightened around her neck, a blast of flour covered the watching mob.
There is a practically visible "WTF?" above the mob's heads.
"... well... um... fur sounds like flour... right?" jav6454, covered from head to toe with flour, offered from the platform.
iBlue was lynched, and is a villager. 10 now remain, and it is NIGHT. Deadline for all orders is 9 AM on Sunday. EST or EDT or whatever it is, 9 AM