you could be right, but i think it's more productive to go after one of the original wolves. jav (and you) can only be wolves if infected. everyone else can be an original wolf and can be infected.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] MRville VI: GAME OVER - VILLAGERS WIN
- Thread starter ravenvii
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
you could be right, but i think it's more productive to go after one of the original wolves. jav (and you) can only be wolves if infected. everyone else can be an original wolf and can be infected.
A better question might be to ask Jav how he knew the two people who I have scanned thus far?
(Yes, I scanned iBlue and Chrmjenkins)
That was made purely as a statement. If it seemed biased it wasn't intended. I am still unsure if you should reveal the other roles (beside the goth).
well, there aren't many other options, the other one would be appleguy who admitted his role. they are the most reasonable choices
You just told us who you scanned.... I do math and the remaining people are the ones I want to find out...
In other words, appleguy123 self admitted the goth role, and we know by your distinction lbro was the vampire hunter... so that leaves, stonyc, iBlue and chrmjenkins. Tell us those roles and we call it.
Edit - It also not hard to figure out who you've scanned if you are the Undertaker... given lbro was lynched, that means we was the 1st scan, but we know who he is so take him out of the equation.
Later we see chrmjenkins dead on N1, and appleguy is lynched on D2, since appleguy self admitted it would be reasonable to assume chrmjenkins was the N2 scan. Now, that leaves the D3 lynchee, iBlue remaining to scan.
It's not hard logic son...
Last edited:
it's tricky.
it would be helpful to know who's gone (but is also very helpful to the wolves), but it is also a way to find out if one of them is lying
edit: if he tries to bluff his way out of lynching
it would be helpful to know who's gone (but is also very helpful to the wolves), but it is also a way to find out if one of them is lying
edit: if he tries to bluff his way out of lynching
for nathan to read
It also not hard to figure out who you've scanned if you are the Undertaker... given lbro was lynched, that means he was the 1st scan, but we know who he was (you told us) so take him out of the equation.
Later we see chrmjenkins dead on N1, and appleguy is lynched on D2, since appleguy self admitted being a Goth, it would be reasonable to assume chrmjenkins was the N2 scan. Now, that leaves the D3 lynchee, iBlue remaining to scan for N3.
It's not hard logic son...
So, the question comes back to... What are/were iBlue's and chrmjenkin's roles?
It also not hard to figure out who you've scanned if you are the Undertaker... given lbro was lynched, that means he was the 1st scan, but we know who he was (you told us) so take him out of the equation.
Later we see chrmjenkins dead on N1, and appleguy is lynched on D2, since appleguy self admitted being a Goth, it would be reasonable to assume chrmjenkins was the N2 scan. Now, that leaves the D3 lynchee, iBlue remaining to scan for N3.
It's not hard logic son...
So, the question comes back to... What are/were iBlue's and chrmjenkin's roles?
No one said it was hard, son.
You just seemed very self assured in your suppositions. What if I was being careful and scanned Appleguy123 anyways?
Relax.
Unless you're a wolf.
No one said it was hard, son.
You just seemed very self assured in your suppositions. What if I was being careful and scanned Appleguy123 anyways?
Relax.
Unless you're a wolf.
Also, assume you scanned appleguy123, I would have still made a guess and got 1/2 of it right. Now, as per wolf arguments, I'm not, but I still want to know what are the other two roles remaining? Why evade the question to this extent? Something to hide?
it isn't unreasonable that he is holding on some of the info for now, it could be later useful to nail the wolves. It's not such an obvious decision
Yeah, the other two roles from the wolves. Why give the wolves more information than necessary? So you know which role not to claim?
Wasn't it this same attitude that got iBlue wrongfully lynched? Pardon me if I'm a little suspicious right now.
I really can't say directly why I want those roles.. see, if you prove to be right, then that leaves Don't Panic on the top part of the list to prove as bad, if Don't Panic has a good role, we move on to the bottom section of the list, which already shows signs of easy deduction as two on the guys there are gone and me being there (confirmed good guy). So, we have 4 people and we know 2 of those are wolves and the other have to be vampires. So, it'll be a win win.
I still think the wolves finding out the roles of the dead really gives them the upper hand.
For example if the Seer they do not have to fear getting scanned so they can go after who they think is a threat with out worried about being scanned and figured out.
Another one is lets assume they knew the hunter was dead. That means they do not have to try to guess if the hunter is going to protect someone. They can take out who ever they want with out any fear of being stopped or even have to worry about the instant kill.
I do not get what is with the huge push to have NathanMuir tell us who was killed.
For example if the Seer they do not have to fear getting scanned so they can go after who they think is a threat with out worried about being scanned and figured out.
Another one is lets assume they knew the hunter was dead. That means they do not have to try to guess if the hunter is going to protect someone. They can take out who ever they want with out any fear of being stopped or even have to worry about the instant kill.
I do not get what is with the huge push to have NathanMuir tell us who was killed.
Alright, seeing as revealing all the roles is bad. Just tell us....
what was chrmjenkins. That one role will change this game.
Edit - Your silence speaks volumes.
what was chrmjenkins. That one role will change this game.
Edit - Your silence speaks volumes.
Last edited:
give him time to think it over.
also, he might not be online right now.
in any case, i think to hold back on the identity is a good sword of damocles on the furry heads
give him time to think it over.
also, he might not be online right now.
in any case, i think to hold back on the identity is a good sword of damocles on the furry heads
On the identities yes, but on what chrmjenkins was no. Let us have that one.
If it is correct I can say we can question you and if you are good sided, move to the bottom section of the list.
Sorry, I still don't see how letting everyone know is more beneficial to the group. If the wolves know which roles to avoid claiming, then it's just that much harder to identify them. However, if a wolf claims X role and it was iBlue's or chrmjenkins role, then I can call BS and hopefully we'll lynch them.
Trust me, I'll be faithful to my role... I am the Priest, and the Gods will smite me the moment I'm Infected.
No, evading the question....
Nathan Muir
I'd ask the remaining villagers to remember the iBlue situation that Jav created. I held my ground there and ended up on the right side of things.
Don't let Jav screw this up again.
Lynch me if you want, it still won't reveal their roles.
Also, ask yourselves why Jav wants to lynch a known good guy? (At least he assumes I'm a good guy, why else would he be hounding me about the other two roles?)
Have as is, I'm still keeping my vote for you. Your attitude of not revealing the entire roles is fine, but revealing one role is not. Chrmjenkins role is everything right now, from my viewpoint. I'll let you guys lynch me if this time I fail.
I've already revealed lbro's role.
What do you want? A two for one special?
Just chrmjenkins... even after him, we still have 2 unknown roles.
Just lbro, just chrmjenkins, just iBlue...
Sorry, I'm not Chamberlain, I'm not following a policy of appeasement.