Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] - The Game of Thrones - GAME OVER - LOYALS WIN

rick snagwell said:
hot dog! awesome job vulture!

costabunny, you got some explaining to do.
Click to expand...

I cannot explain what i do not know my lords. I am but a humble servant trying my best to follow my lords wishes. I am not in the knowledge to do any better than that. I am loyal to the core and i am saddened by the loss of our other loyal brothers :(

I am true to our lands and would never betray anyone. Please believe me (see I said please also).

We need better intel before we mistakenly send another innocent to the hangman.
 
As I said, I'll wait till the next nightly killing happens; until that I won't go anywhere near raven or ss. So I'll have to look somewhere else...ucfgrad93 comes to mind, always sticking around - never posting something noticeable: the perfect Traitor! :eek:
 
costabunny said:
I cannot explain what i do not know my lords. I am but a humble servant trying my best to follow my lords wishes. I am not in the knowledge to do any better than that. I am loyal to the core and i am saddened by the loss of our other loyal brothers :(

I am true to our lands and would never betray anyone. Please believe me (see I said please also).

We need better intel before we mistakenly send another innocent to the hangman.
Click to expand...

not that i entirely believe you, but im going to go with my gut on this one, and with what moyank stated earlier. koodauw.

she says he tries to get the vets out early, and then he voted for philbeeney, starting what he might of seen as an easy lynch (newer player)....
 
rick snagwell said:
not that i entirely believe you, but im going to go with my gut on this one, and with what moyank stated earlier. koodauw.

she says he tries to get the vets out early, and then he voted for philbeeney, starting what he might of seen as an easy lynch (newer player)....
Click to expand...

I agree about Koodauw. He made easy throwaway-votes from the get-go. Him or ucfgrad - who cares?! :D

I like that s/he runnning gag going on btw.
 
My Lords and my Lady,

I need to say that I am suspicious of my neighbour, Lord rick snagwell.

In the past, he is always quick to say I'm responsible for everything bad, yet he did not accused me yet of anything in this gathering.
 
Sythas said:
My Lords and my Lady,

I need to say that I am suspicious of my neighbour, Lord rick snagwell.

In the past, he is always quick to say I'm responsible for everything bad, yet he did not accused me yet of anything in this gathering.
Click to expand...

really? my scapegoat has always been moyank...please point me to a time i used ya.

and i actually believe most of, if not all of, the people talking are good peeps.
 
twietee said:
I agree about Koodauw. He made easy throwaway-votes from the get-go. Him or ucfgrad - who cares?! :D

I like that s/he runnning gag going on btw.
Click to expand...

I care.;)

I'm still not buying costabunny's innocent act. She changed her vote last time from comeagain to philbeeney. She was the last one to vote for phil, and her vote is responsible for his death.
 
Well ucfgrad93 keeps trying to put suspicion upon an innocent (me) - i think this makes him a person of interest.

I have stated my innocence and loyalty on many occasions. I am remorseful for the loss of phil. :( i am upset that i am considered responsible for killing one of our own.
 
costabunny said:
Well ucfgrad93 keeps trying to put suspicion upon an innocent (me) - i think this makes him a person of interest.

I have stated my innocence and loyalty on many occasions. I am remorseful for the loss of phil. :( i am upset that i am considered responsible for killing one of our own.
Click to expand...

Well you did switch your vote, which was the 5th one cast for Phil. That makes you responsible in my opinion.
 
Koodauw said:
:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

I'm sorry, here take this cool shirt as an excuse.

his-lordship-tee-4.png
 
Scepticalscribe said:
A little fast out of the starting blocks.

Ah, yes, that was a discussion about the merits of various vintages of wine, as I recall.

Foe the record, I am not on the side of evil. I have stated this before, but shall now repeat it. And moreover, I'll simply say 'twould be a most misfortunate act to do away with me.
Click to expand...

But that's what a traitor would say. It seems no one else agrees with me that your post reds almost worth dying for was in any way a hint. If I'd been the one choosing the traitors targets I'd have taken a risk that it was though and picked you as a target.

Scepticalscribe said:
Yes, that is very good news indeed.

And I agree with the analysis above. Either the Red Man has been found by his searching fellows, or, a protection worked and a planned kill did not. Let us hope it was the latter......
Click to expand...
We can hope it was the vulture's protection but must also prepare for the worst. Ideally we want to find and execute the red man before any of the others.
 
Sorry, had crap to do this morning.

costabunny. I voted for him/her yesterday #1 because after I had the time to go through the voting activity of the last 2/3 days, the facts point very strongly toward guilt/traitor. In the last 3 days, costabunny has registered many of the deciding bandwagon votes on innocents. It's right there in the voting pattern - including swapping around to join on bandwagons after meaningless votes.

And if costabunny is a traitor, we'll have a decent idea of who he/she is working with, also based on the votes. Yesterday, I wanted to see what the voting activity would be if I didn't reveal my full thoughts - thereby getting a little extra intel. I'm willing to ask people to join this vote because if we're wrong, it's purely bad luck/bad decisions by costabunny and note some random hunch.
 
Lords and Ladies, 16 still live, so majority of 9 will bring a swift demise.

Potential Traitors
costabunny: 3 ucfgrad93, SilentPanda, Queen of Spades
Koodauw: 2 rick snagwell, twietee
rick snagwell: 1 Sythas
ucfgrad93: 1 costabunny
Scepticalscribe: 1 FenrisMoonlight

Yet to vote: Comeagain, jimN, WoodNUFC, Roric, Moyank24, ravenvii, Koodauw, Scepticalscribe,

Accusations
Post 673 FenrisMoonlight accused Scepticalscribe
Post 678 rick snagwell accused Koodauw
Post 680 Sythas accused rick snagwell
Post 682 ucfgrad93 accused costabunny
Post 684 costabunny accused ucfgrad93
Post 685 SilentPanda accused costabunny
Post 687 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 693 Queen of Spades accused costabunny

FenrisMoonlight - Squire in service to the King's Justice
 
I agree that Costabunny is very suspicious, and I will put my vote on her.

But first, why Koodauw? He flew under the radar (mine, at least) this game, but is there something I missed?
 
I am more curious about those who have flown under the radar so completely that in at least two cases, they have not bothered to register a vote, (let alone post) and have not been called out on it.

On two different days, one of either Comeagain? and JimN failed to even register a vote, let alone post.

I agree that costabunny's voting pattern requires that questions be asked of it, but it could also be the blunders of someone who is new to this; at least, she is posting and voting in full sight. I am more concerned with the silent ones. Roric is also someone we have not heard much from.

For now, I'll stir a pot and see if we can get a squeak out of someone who has been fairly silent to date. So, Roric....
 
Queen of Spades said:
Sorry, had crap to do this morning.

costabunny. I voted for him/her yesterday #1 because after I had the time to go through the voting activity of the last 2/3 days, the facts point very strongly toward guilt/traitor. In the last 3 days, costabunny has registered many of the deciding bandwagon votes on innocents. It's right there in the voting pattern - including swapping around to join on bandwagons after meaningless votes.

And if costabunny is a traitor, we'll have a decent idea of who he/she is working with, also based on the votes. Yesterday, I wanted to see what the voting activity would be if I didn't reveal my full thoughts - thereby getting a little extra intel. I'm willing to ask people to join this vote because if we're wrong, it's purely bad luck/bad decisions by costabunny and note some random hunch.
Click to expand...

What more can i say/do to convince you of my loyaly? You are wasting votes and time on mewhen i have done nothing other than try to follow thise i beleive to be loyal also.

If my death serves only to prove this, then so be it.
 
costabunny said:
What more can i say/do to convince you of my loyaly? You are wasting votes and time on mewhen i have done nothing other than try to follow thise i beleive to be loyal also.

If my death serves only to prove this, then so be it.
Click to expand...

If you're innocent, your behavior belies that.

On day 1, you cast vote #4 for ucfgrad, making him the leading vote getter. Then you swapped from ucfgrad to vote #8 for jav, after that bandwagon had built up, when jav was basically done for. Late and useless pile on vote for someone who turns out to be a traitor is always a huge red flag.

On day 3, you jumped on ravenvii right after twietee voted for him, registering vote #2, moving ravenvii to viable lynch candidate. Then you swapped to Comeagain?, registering vote #3 for him. Again, a building bandwagon. Finally, you swapped to philbeeney, registering vote #5 for him, putting him over the top to be lynched.

Obviously you could just be completely freestyling and/or not realizing the pattern you're creating, but it's hallmark traitor behavior.
 
costabunny said:
What more can i say/do to convince you of my loyaly? You are wasting votes and time on mewhen i have done nothing other than try to follow thise i beleive to be loyal also.

If my death serves only to prove this, then so be it.
Click to expand...

If you are innocent and especially if you're not a special, there's really nothing you can do. You can't reveal information to validate your claim of being a special (and sometimes that isn't even possible if you are a special). Everybody will read each other's playing different. Some even read into it a bit falsely since they themselves are traitors and know you're not (if you're not), so bend their thoughts just a bit to generate suspicion. Not much you can do about it.

Of course, if you're a traitor, I hope you die! :D
 
Queen of Spades said:
Sorry, had crap to do this morning.

costabunny. I voted for him/her yesterday #1 because after I had the time to go through the voting activity of the last 2/3 days, the facts point very strongly toward guilt/traitor. In the last 3 days, costabunny has registered many of the deciding bandwagon votes on innocents. It's right there in the voting pattern - including swapping around to join on bandwagons after meaningless votes.

And if costabunny is a traitor, we'll have a decent idea of who he/she is working with, also based on the votes. Yesterday, I wanted to see what the voting activity would be if I didn't reveal my full thoughts - thereby getting a little extra intel. I'm willing to ask people to join this vote because if we're wrong, it's purely bad luck/bad decisions by costabunny and note some random hunch.
Click to expand...

I think its strong theory. If you look at twietee's voting pattern its some what similar. A random first vote, then switching to whoever is popular.

You also combine that with Jav's comments about leaving instructions. Was he just talking non-sense to get a rise out of everyone, or was there some truth to it? I think you would only need to leave instructions if your fellow traitors were new to be being bad guys. I have never played with costabunny before, and I dont remember the last time twietee was a bad guy. If they are communicating behind the scenes their actions could be similar.

I might be grasping at straws here, but its what I noticed looking at the voting.

I am more inclined to vote for people who are not participating as much, to get them involved as well. Its hard to catch the silent traitor.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back