Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] - The Game of Thrones - GAME OVER - LOYALS WIN
- Thread starter chrmjenkins
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I take a weekend unplugged and everything breaks loose! I have finally managed to get through all the posts and mostly follow what everyone is saying.
With SS's revival we might have a fighting chance! I am going to go along with SS and vote for JimN. Let's hope (s)he is right.
With SS's revival we might have a fighting chance! I am going to go along with SS and vote for JimN. Let's hope (s)he is right.
Last edited:
Yeah, this. I'm willing to hear other ideas, but no one seems to have any. At least if we are wrong about jimN, it's one of the quieter players.
With SS's revival we might have a fighting chance! I am going to go along with SS and vote for JimN. Let's hope (s)he is right.
Agreed. I too will cast my vote for jimN.
Personally, I, too, am usually quite sceptical about bandwagons but I have harboured questions for some time about jimN, and a few others among whom ucfgrad 93 is numbered.
Let them say something in their defence, as we all have had to do on occasion, and I shall certainly pay heed, but at this stage, silence, is not really an acceptable defence in my view.
Re FenrisMoonlight's tally, just to point out, in post 935, I never accused him or bolded his name intending anything other than information - the names of the others scanned are also bolded in italics; the names I bolded in that lengthy post were merely to highlight the names of those whom I had scanned, nothing else.
Let them say something in their defence, as we all have had to do on occasion, and I shall certainly pay heed, but at this stage, silence, is not really an acceptable defence in my view.
Re FenrisMoonlight's tally, just to point out, in post 935, I never accused him or bolded his name intending anything other than information - the names of the others scanned are also bolded in italics; the names I bolded in that lengthy post were merely to highlight the names of those whom I had scanned, nothing else.
Actually, I have some suspicion of ucfgrad93 as well. The only thing that gives me pause is that Koodauw and Sythas have voted for him and they're on my short list as well.
I have played the game as best I can. If you look at my votes you will see that I have not switched my vote once they have been cast. I have voted for those that I have thought were suspicious and stuck with it. No last minute switching for me.
It saddens me to see such fools' logic applied to achieve these lynchings.
If I'm killed tomorrow let my death not be in vain but note well those who were quick to join the calls for my head and be sure to kill them ASAP.
As to the charge of only posting when posted to... I don't work at a desk and, since this game started I've worked two weekends and pretty much every day in between. Opportunistic posting is largely all I manage and I really haven't had much to add given that I, unlike chatter boxes such as SS haven't had a role to fall back on. As it is your instinct for the game has produced 4 fruitless scans and this instinct will see me killed largely on your say so.
If I'm killed tomorrow let my death not be in vain but note well those who were quick to join the calls for my head and be sure to kill them ASAP.
As to the charge of only posting when posted to... I don't work at a desk and, since this game started I've worked two weekends and pretty much every day in between. Opportunistic posting is largely all I manage and I really haven't had much to add given that I, unlike chatter boxes such as SS haven't had a role to fall back on. As it is your instinct for the game has produced 4 fruitless scans and this instinct will see me killed largely on your say so.
How dare you peasants bring back a scholar before your rightful king?! I, Jav Targaryen, vow that your deaths will be swift and righteous. For those who can still repent, do so and bow down to me!!!!!
Ah. Thus far, your posts have been distinguished by ill-tempered responses and insulting posts. Responses when your name is mentioned, followed by splenetic bursts of peevish ill temper. To me and to others. Other than that, silence. Nothing constructive, posts devoid of analysis, thought, and insight. So be it. And we all have work, and lives. Here and elsewhere.
No scan that yields information is fruitless, as those that are cleared can now be regarded as less suspicious than others, among whom I now count yourself. Have you anything constructive to offer, a name, perhaps, a theory?
You have been one of those I deem questionable. That is why I have voted for you. It does not mean that you are guilty, merely suspicious, for now, in my eyes. If you are not killed, yours is one of those names I shall consider scanning, assuming I live long enough. Does that count as another 'wasted scan'?
Well now. You certainly didn't hold back, perhaps you should have a little.
That said, posts which basically call people fools for not being right in this game, yet offer no viable alternatives are a really dumb waste of time. Offer some analysis of your own or you don't really have a right to criticize SS or anyone else.
Talking about a wasted scan... I know I am on the hot list of a lot of people, but please, don't scan me it's a waste.
I'm a villager, so even if you scan me, I'll be in the first list to be hang for the sneak anyway
So my deal, is you scan someone else to find a traitor, and we hang me tomorrow...
I prefers to be hang as a villager than you wasting a scan on me.
Yeah - noted - it picked up the last bolded name in the post as a vote. When I'm less busy I'll look at making it a bit more intelligent as its obvious it wasn't intended as a vote - for the moment it makes no difference to the final tally as your real vote replaces it a few posts later
If my posts are ill-tempered then it's generally in response to the nonsense that precedes them. That said, most haven't been but I will stand up for myself when accused but at this stage I have nothing to say that will add to my defence only to watch on helplessly as my fate falls out if my hands.
Updated list since we're 1 away from majority lock. Manually removed incorrectly interpreted vote by Scepticalscribe for FenrisMoonlight from voting log.
Potential Traitors
jimN: 7 twietee, Scepticalscribe, Queen of Spades, SilentPanda, WoodNUFC, Roric, ucfgrad93
ucfgrad93: 5 Koodauw, jimN, Sythas, FenrisMoonlight, rick snagwell
comeagain?: 1 ravenvii
Yet to vote: Comeagain?, Moyank24,
Accusations
Post 786 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 799 FenrisMoonlight accused Roric
Post 800 twietee accused jimN
Post 823 FenrisMoonlight accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 799 for Roric
Post 826 rick snagwell accused FenrisMoonlight
Post 857 SilentPanda accused rick snagwell
Post 878 twietee accused FenrisMoonlight replacing previous accusation in post 800 for jimN
Post 879 WoodNUFC accused FenrisMoonlight
Post 881 SilentPanda accused FenrisMoonlight replacing previous accusation in post 857 for rick snagwell
Post 886 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 899 jimN accused ucfgrad93
Post 903 Sythas accused ucfgrad93
Post 913 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 823 for jimN
Post 929 SilentPanda accused no vote replacing previous accusation in post 881 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 936 twietee accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 878 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 937 rick snagwell accused Sythas replacing previous accusation in post 826 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 938 Scepticalscribe accused jimN
Post 940 Queen of Spades accused jimN
Post 941 SilentPanda accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 929 for no vote
Post 953 WoodNUFC accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 879 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 954 Roric accused jimN
Post 956 ucfgrad93 accused jimN
Post 957 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 937 for Sythas
Potential Traitors
jimN: 7 twietee, Scepticalscribe, Queen of Spades, SilentPanda, WoodNUFC, Roric, ucfgrad93
ucfgrad93: 5 Koodauw, jimN, Sythas, FenrisMoonlight, rick snagwell
comeagain?: 1 ravenvii
Yet to vote: Comeagain?, Moyank24,
Accusations
Post 786 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 799 FenrisMoonlight accused Roric
Post 800 twietee accused jimN
Post 823 FenrisMoonlight accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 799 for Roric
Post 826 rick snagwell accused FenrisMoonlight
Post 857 SilentPanda accused rick snagwell
Post 878 twietee accused FenrisMoonlight replacing previous accusation in post 800 for jimN
Post 879 WoodNUFC accused FenrisMoonlight
Post 881 SilentPanda accused FenrisMoonlight replacing previous accusation in post 857 for rick snagwell
Post 886 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 899 jimN accused ucfgrad93
Post 903 Sythas accused ucfgrad93
Post 913 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 823 for jimN
Post 929 SilentPanda accused no vote replacing previous accusation in post 881 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 936 twietee accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 878 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 937 rick snagwell accused Sythas replacing previous accusation in post 826 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 938 Scepticalscribe accused jimN
Post 940 Queen of Spades accused jimN
Post 941 SilentPanda accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 929 for no vote
Post 953 WoodNUFC accused jimN replacing previous accusation in post 879 for FenrisMoonlight
Post 954 Roric accused jimN
Post 956 ucfgrad93 accused jimN
Post 957 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 937 for Sythas
But you offer nothing up instead. I'd rather listen to theories/nonsense than nothing...
Most of those who believe themselves innocent request a scan. And you don't?.....Fascinating.
And, to repeat, no scan is wasted, although some obviously yield more fruitful dividends than others by way of immediate information.......
This may well be my last chance to contribute so might as well try to say something useful.
My death will leave 14 with all the traitors still in play bar Jav (3+1) but the Red man yet to be discovered so you only need to track down 3 of them.
Of the players in the game still we have three confirmed goodies, one of whom will likely be killed tonight and two cleared by scan. This leaves 9 possibles for the traitors or a better than 1 in 3 chance of a successful pick.
Suspects (in no particular order and with myself omitted because I'm both loyal and most likely dead)
Twietee
Ufcgrad93
Queen of Spades
Comeagain
Koodau
Sythas
Roric
Fenris
Rick Snagwell
Twietee seems to have aligned himself on the side of good and for now is fairly convincing. Fenris is consistently involved and seems to offer good theories but this could be an elaborate ruse. Rick, Roric and Queen are all very quiet.
If I had to scan someone tonight it would be Ufcgrad (never trusted them). If I could do two scans I'd go for Queen.
If I get really bored overnight I'll change my vote to myself and exit the game by majority vote.
My death will leave 14 with all the traitors still in play bar Jav (3+1) but the Red man yet to be discovered so you only need to track down 3 of them.
Of the players in the game still we have three confirmed goodies, one of whom will likely be killed tonight and two cleared by scan. This leaves 9 possibles for the traitors or a better than 1 in 3 chance of a successful pick.
Suspects (in no particular order and with myself omitted because I'm both loyal and most likely dead)
Twietee
Ufcgrad93
Queen of Spades
Comeagain
Koodau
Sythas
Roric
Fenris
Rick Snagwell
Twietee seems to have aligned himself on the side of good and for now is fairly convincing. Fenris is consistently involved and seems to offer good theories but this could be an elaborate ruse. Rick, Roric and Queen are all very quiet.
If I had to scan someone tonight it would be Ufcgrad (never trusted them). If I could do two scans I'd go for Queen.
If I get really bored overnight I'll change my vote to myself and exit the game by majority vote.
Eliminate twietee and Fenris from the list -- they've been more or less cleared by Silent and 'Scribe.
Keep in mind Either moyank or Raven could be the sneak, so your odds could be as low 2/9 at that point.