Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Everyone who owns / loves the X and smashes people who own / love the 8+ all probably look like this guy in real life and are just as punch-worthy.

Ad.jpg
 
Well you are comparing old Samsung tech to the best Apple has.

The Galaxy S7 Edge is hardly old Samsung tech. That phone is from just last year! The Galaxy S8 and Note 8 screens are practically the same. About the same difference as going from a 7 Plus to an 8 Plus. Maybe less difference because the 8 Plus at least got true tone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: haruhiko
This is absolutely absurd. Why do people care what iPhone I have. I had the 7 plus and upgraded to the 8 plus and my husband and I have no regrets. Three reasons why we decided on the 8 plus instead of X:
1.We like the screen size of the 5.5, it would be a huge adjustment having to go back down in size.
2. We aren’t sold on Face ID yet, we’ll see after a year.
3. No Blush Gold or Gold color on the X. My husband and I like color, we’re not really a fan of the 2 colors of the X it’s a little stale and boring for us.
Why buy something if your not completely satisfied with it. I feel like too many compromises had to be made in my opinion for me to be satisfied enough with the X.
 
I originally planned on buying an 8 and let the X users beta test the phone but that was more trying to convincing myself that I didn't want the X. I just played with one in stores and it is unequivocally the best iPhone Apple has ever made. The feel is extremely premium and the screen is so good that it looks fake, as if the icons are stickers on the screen.

Then I planned on buying a used 7 to hold me over for the XS but the iPhone X doesn't feel like a beta product, it feels like a flagship product.

"As far as iPhones go, the iPhone 8 family delivers better value at a lower price point - not to mention a better choice of screen sizes.
So if the iPhone X is indeed the start of a new generation of iPhones, we already can't wait to see what's next. That's the thing about it - the unrealized potential and the promises it holds for the future are much more exciting than the product we have in our hands today" Honest review from Gsmarena.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Black Magic
They do seem to be very angry about this whole multi device scattered release. I am not exactly sure why though. The 8, 8 Plus, and X are all great options and hit a different price point for each type of buyer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jimmy_uk
I originally planned on buying an 8 and let the X users beta test the phone but that was more trying to convincing myself that I didn't want the X. I just played with one in stores and it is unequivocally the best iPhone Apple has ever made. The feel is extremely premium and the screen is so good that it looks fake, as if the icons are stickers on the screen.

Then I planned on buying a used 7 to hold me over for the XS but the iPhone X doesn't feel like a beta product, it feels like a flagship product.

I see. You've converted your misguided motivation into pity.
 
A top of the line 8 Plus can get pretty close to the base X. I wouldn’t even categorize by price points anymore. We should be glad that Apple has offered various sizes.

Do people with an X have an elitist attitude when they sit next to someone with an 8 Plus? I sure don’t and it’s pretty sad if there are people out there.

We all have different uses and what doesn’t work for others, may work for someone else.
 
I find it hilarious when people say the 8 plus has old tech compared to the X. The internals are nearly identical!
It's not a factually incorrect statement to say that the 8 plus has old tech. The design can be considered 'tech' and is 4 years old...thus old.
 
I personally think it's an insult to the vast majority of customers who don't want to shell out a grand to get this outdated design for the fourth year in a row. The displays are not even HDR capable which almost the entirety of Android flagships in this price range support.

Unfortunately now that the X is a success, Apple will no longer develop good phones at the $700 price point and $999 is the base price for a competent flagship next year.
 
It's not a factually incorrect statement to say that the 8 plus has old tech. The design can be considered 'tech' and is 4 years old...thus old.

This is the kind of mentality that the tech industry (and the fashion industry, as a matter of fact. There's some overlap in marketing philosophy) fosters in consumers to convince people that they need to buy something new every year when their current product still meets their needs.

Preferring the OLED display or facial scanning features of the X is fine, but there's nothing functionally or technologically inferior, "obsolete", or "outdated" about a design which is essentially also a rounded-edged glass and metal rectangle with a display. It's cosmetic.
 
This is the kind of mentality that the tech industry (and the fashion industry, as a matter of fact. There's some overlap in marketing philosophy) fosters in consumers to convince people that they need to buy something new every year when their current product still meets their needs.

Preferring the OLED display or facial scanning features of the X is fine, but there's nothing functionally or technologically inferior, "obsolete", or "outdated" about a design which is essentially also a rounded-edged glass and metal rectangle with a display. It's cosmetic.

This is so well stated. I wholeheartedly agree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sunnyday2017
This is the kind of mentality that the tech industry (and the fashion industry, as a matter of fact. There's some overlap in marketing philosophy) fosters in consumers to convince people that they need to buy something new every year when their current product still meets their needs.

Preferring the OLED display or facial scanning features of the X is fine, but there's nothing functionally or technologically inferior, "obsolete", or "outdated" about a design which is essentially also a rounded-edged glass and metal rectangle with a display. It's cosmetic.

Making too much sense here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sunnyday2017
What’s that Apple? No 4.7” X? No sale.

Happy with my 8 and if Apple decides to do away with the smaller form factor, I’ll do away with Apple phones. Simple really.
[doublepost=1512058444][/doublepost]
Didn’t know that a €800 (minimum) for iPhone 8 is a poor mans choice… 😕
Considering I bought the 256G model and paid almost as much as an X.

They do seem to be very angry about this whole multi device scattered release. I am not exactly sure why though. The 8, 8 Plus, and X are all great options and hit a different price point for each type of buyer.

Price point isn’t the issue for me. I like 4.7” phones and I don’t like spending money to beta test new tech.
 
Last edited:
This is the kind of mentality that the tech industry (and the fashion industry, as a matter of fact. There's some overlap in marketing philosophy) fosters in consumers to convince people that they need to buy something new every year when their current product still meets their needs.

Preferring the OLED display or facial scanning features of the X is fine, but there's nothing functionally or technologically inferior, "obsolete", or "outdated" about a design which is essentially also a rounded-edged glass and metal rectangle with a display. It's cosmetic.

http://bgr.com/2017/11/30/iphone-x-...flow&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_medium=social

Jony Ive can add flame bait to the thread 😛 :


Upon picking up an iPhone 7 Plus, Ive remarked: “It now seems to me a rather disconnected component housed in an enclosure.” A brutally harsh assessment for a device that was just released last year, but ultimately a testament to the game changing design of the iPhone X.
 
Upon picking up an iPhone 7 Plus, Ive remarked: “It now seems to me a rather disconnected component housed in an enclosure.” A brutally harsh assessment for a device that was just released last year, but ultimately a testament to the game changing design of the iPhone X.
What cracks me up about that is that statement is that Ive made a big deal in the intro video for the iPhone 7 about how the jet black finish made it the first iPhone that felt like a single form. The finish made it so you couldn’t tell were the screen ended and the body began. Amazing how quickly he changed his tune. Of course, Apple is the master of making last year’s device suddenly seem obsolete and worthless. They want you to keep buying!

What’s interesting to me is that’s the X actually feels less like a unified device than the 7. There are more seams (screen and side, side and back vs just screen and casing on the 7). The camera bump also just juts out on the X rather than being more organically sculpted on the 7. Don’t get me wrong, I love my X and would pick it any day over my old 7. But Ive’s comment just smacks of marketing speak.
 
These are the reasons why I went with the 8 Plus and not the X.

1) Since the X is brand new technology without having the home button, I didn't want to take a chance and have something go wrong with the device itself. For example this was in the most recent iOS 11 update. It primarily fixed display responsiveness issues on the iPhone X caused by sudden cold temperature.

2) Personally speaking I still like having the home button and how it makes it easier to clear my apps so they don't keep running in the background.

3) The cost would not have been an issue for me because I would have been able to trade in my 6s and would have been given a $240 credit if I wanted to wait for the X. So I used that when getting my 8 Plus.

4) In 2 years when the contract for my 8 Plus is finished I'm sure that there won't be anymore home buttons on future iPhone devices. However until that time I can still go to the Apple Store, play around with the X's they have on display to get use to it.
 
I left a comment and got a message from a mod saying I was provoking or trolling. First time ever in my 7 years here on this forum. 😱😀

Same, any Android vs iPhone threads --- I'll stay far away. Even if I try to be fair, I'll respond to someone who gets their post deleted then I'll get a warning or something. So minus this post, I stay far away from all the Android members here who love to ... dangit, I'll stop now.


I specifically went with the 8+ because of the bigger phone, better battery life, and touch id. I came from a 6s+ so I am enjoying the additional camera and wireless charging.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.