So I got my Speck Candy Shell case in yesterday and today is the first day the phone has been residing in the case. So far I love it! The case is extremely solid, fit is tight, and this thing provides some serious protection for those worried about their brand new iPhone 4.
I too was really worried about the bulk that the Candy Shell would add, but to be honest it isn't anything over the top. You get used to the size really quickly, and I actually prefer the extra size which makes it a more comfortable fit in your hand for browsing the web, texting, etc. I do have the flash problem as well, Sharpie did not really fix it, but I have e-mailed Speck to report the problem with my case as well.
A couple other small gripes, the ring/vibrate switch on the iPhone 4 is much smaller than in previous models and you have to use your smaller fingers and nails to get into the little slot they built to access the switch. My thumb can't get in there to flip the slider so you just have to use your nail and a smaller finger to get to it.
Last gripe is that the headphone port isn't completely centered over the headphone jack on the iPhone. If you look at it from the top of the phone with the glass towards you, the Apple headphone jack is just so slightly to the right of the hole. With an already smaller hole for headphones, this may lead to some issues with getting complete contact when plugging in a headphone cable.
Overall though I am completely happy with my Candy Shell so far, and look forward to hearing from Speck about a replacement case which fixes the flash issue.
I did order an Incipio Feather which arrives today which I plan on trying for something which is the complete opposite of the protection that the Candy Shell provides. I have a feeling the Feather is going to be a little too minimal in protection for me but I will give it a try. I have also ordered an Apple Bumper to try out that as well and see how I like it.
Anyone else having complete ADD on a decision for a case? At least all the cases are returnable when I finally decide!